Christopher Hodapp - RVs & Campers For Dummies

Chapter 3

IN THIS CHAPTER

Weighing RV pros and cons

Figuring out how much living space you need

Picking your options

Chapter 2gives you an outline of what’s available in the RV world, which is pretty much any size or price you can imagine. But which one is right for you?

In Part 2, we discuss the nuts and bolts of researching a brand, choosing a dealer, checking a warranty, and finding the resale value. But in this chapter, we’re more general, helping you narrow down the class and type of RV to suit your needs. We cover some issues regarding pulling or being pulled, in terms of motorhomes versus towable trailers. We help you consider how much space you need and which amenities you can’t live without.

When you’ve made decisions about the subjects in this chapter, you’ll have narrowed the field quite a bit, enabling you to feel less overwhelmed by the number of companies and models out there to choose from.

The first big question you have to answer when you’re in the market for an RV is: Do you want to tow a separate vehicle, or do you want to use your vehicle to tow your RV? (Or are you going to try to go it without a separate vehicle altogether? Before you go that route, check out the nearby sidebar, “RVing without a separate vehicle.”)

In the beginning, RVing in a motorhome can look very attractive, and you may think you can get by without a car. Maybe you think you can try to structure your travels in such a way that, for example, you always stop at the grocery on the way to the campground. Okay, fair enough.

We’ve seen lots of people in smaller Class C and B+ motorhomes camping without a car. On rare occasions, we’ve seen them have to pull up stakes from a full hookup because they had to go somewhere, and on the whole, they seem to take it in stride.

The thing is, you just can’t foresee everything that may happen when you’re on the road, including the truly oddball stuff, like when our dog, Sophie the Power Poodle, got dreadfully sick and we had to find an emergency animal hospital in the wilds of Montana.

You also can’t anticipate the fun things, like finding out the pretty little town you’re in is having a wine festival that you really want to visit. Of course, the pleasure of a Class B or small Class C is that you can more easily find a place to park it when you head out for that festival. But if you’re planning on a Class A and you’re thinking you’ll be able to find a place to park it in that pretty little town, well, we don’t envy you.

These are the scenarios you need to play out in your mind. Yes, when you’re driving a coach, other options for transportation are usually available: Maybe you can take the occasional Uber or Lyft, and you can always rent a car for the duration of your stay, which is very easy to do in popular camping areas (on the other hand, it can have its annoyances — Enterprise won’t deliver a car to you in the middle of Yellowstone).

The fact is, Americans are very used to absolute freedom of mobility. This country is very spread out, the popular camping states are even more spread out, and it’s difficult to function without access to a car, particularly on a long journey. Be honest with yourself about your priorities and how much hassle you’re willing to put up with in order to leave your vehicle at home.

Before we started RVing, we knew that some people in motorhomes towed a car. Both Class A and Class C motorhomes can tow a car, which they often call a toad (towed, get it?), although RV magazines often use the term dinghy. What we didn’t know until we started RVing was how many people in motorhomes tow a car. We’ve never seen any reliable stats on this, but in the summer months, in hot camping areas like South Dakota and Wyoming, we were seeing about three-quarters of the large Class As towing a car. On more than a few occasions, we’ve seen Class As towing both a car and a very large pleasure boat behind that, just like the Southern Pacific Railroad.

We’ve met people driving Class As who were totally on top of this issue of towing a toad from the moment they bought. Lots of these guys have chosen rigs like a Dynamax Super C with a Cummins engine specifically for its remarkable ease of towing heavy loads. But from personal experience, just talking to other campers, we’ve gathered that an amazing number of people don’t really think through this issue at the buying stage. If that sounds familiar, this section is for you.

Motorhomes and fifth wheels tend to win on sheer size. These two categories are the rigs of choice for full-timers. As a rule, you just won’t get that kind of space in a standard travel trailer. Some trailers mimic the feel of a fifth wheel, but we had trouble finding them.

We well remember our first trip to a gigantic Lazydays dealership. Just in trying to understand all our options, we kept pleading, “Okay, we’ve seen the huge, luxury fifth wheel and motorhome. Now show us the trailer you’ve got that’s just as luxurious on the inside.” The saleslady said it would be easy, and she did try, but we just didn’t find it sitting on the lot. Trailers offer an incredibly wide range of sizes and amenities, but you have to look a little bit harder to find one that looks as luxurious as a Class A inside. And so, on the whole, we’ll hand over the victory laurels on size to a Class A or fifth wheel.

Motorhomes also win hands-down on boondocking, because almost all of them have their own electrical generator. Trailer people usually have to haul a heavy “portable” generator along with them and, worse, find a place to stow it. If you tow with a truck, the truck bed is the obvious place, but that means you just lost a great deal of storage space.

Again and again, we’ve heard stories about generators being stolen out of the back of a truck — one guy we know actually chained his down. Having had some similar items stolen from an open pickup, including a riding mower, we understand the issue.

You can have a generator installed in a trailer. A closet is the favorite place, but there are other, more imaginative options. (We saw one guy boondocking with an ultralight who had the entire trunk of his tow car filled with big, heavy golf cart batteries.) But the fact remains that motorhomes are great for a pull-off-anywhere boondocking situation — spending the night wherever you like without ponying up for a campground.

If you’re planning to boondock on a distant piece of Bureau of Land Management (BLM) government land, it may be very difficult to get a bloated Class A down some of those rugged roads. Class A motorhomes simply are not all-terrain vehicles. More than a few have been driven down into a steep gully, only to get wedged at both ends and suspended with the wheels off the ground.