Brock Clarke - Exley

Dr. Pahnee shook his head and said, “Better not tell her,” which was a little more like it.

“Why did you bring me here anyway?” I asked. “Did it have something to do with Mother?”

“No,” Dr. Pahnee said, although again he wasn’t looking at me. He was smoking and looking in an especially thoughtful way at where Mother had been standing. “I wanted you to see how much worse things could be with your dad. Can you see that now?”

I nodded. Because I could see. I could see what Dr. Pahnee had brought me here to see. I saw that I was lucky that my dad was just in the hospital and not in the box with the flag over it. I saw that everyone does what they think they have to, including me and including the soldiers. Except that the soldiers were on the bus, and I was not. Except that the soldiers had the president and a god. But my dad and I had Exley, and once I found him, he would be a better thing to have than a president or a god.

Doctor’s Notes (Entry 20)

Itake M. to the soldier’s funeral at the Public Square and discover certain things.

About M.: he knows that I was in his house last night, although I do not yet know if he knows I read his journal, or what, if anything, he intends to do with the information. Perhaps I shall find out more during our session this afternoon. In any case, after the funeral, I send him back to school with the promise that I will “catch” him later.

About me: with each newly lit cigarette I find that I am no longer entirely myself, nor am I entirely Dr. Pahnee, although I do not yet know who I am. As a mental health professional, I’ve always preached that you can achieve true mental health only when you discover who you really are. But it occurs to me now that perhaps the opposite is true. Perhaps, I think, if I stop smoking the cigarettes, then my transformation will be arrested. But even as I think that, I light another one, and I smoke several more on my walk back home. In any case, the transformation seems unstoppable: I am home and smoking yet another “butt” and must apologize to these notes upon which I accidentally ash.

About M.’s mother: by her attendance at the funeral, and by her stare, I know she has some connection with either the deceased or his survivors, although I do not yet know what the connection is. Perhaps I shall ask her directly, or perhaps I shall think of a more indirect method of inquiry. In any case, I shall investigate further. Although perhaps it would be best not to investigate at all. Because I cannot stop thinking about M.’s mother’s stare at the funeral: so beautiful, so sad, so angry, so deep that there seemed to be no bottom to it. Looking at her look at whatever was the object of her gaze, I couldn’t help being really scared; I couldn’t help wondering what every mental health professional must wonder, and, for that matter, what every detective or soldier or even writer must wonder, too: “For Christ’s sake, how does one get into this business? How does one get out?”

Perhaps one gets out, or tries to get out, by asking questions. So after I say my good-byes to M., I decide to conduct a series of interviews. My first interview should be with the dead soldier’s survivors, but they have already left the Public Square. And since I am already on the Public Square, I decide to finally enter the Crystal and speak to the owner, Mr. D., about M. And since I am apparently in the middle of some transformation and don’t know who I am now or who I might yet be, I decide to keep myself out of the interview entirely, recording only the answers to my questions, not the questions. If Exley’s book has taught me something besides the obscenity of M.’s name for me, it’s that we try, and fail, to fool ourselves into thinking we have the answers to life’s most difficult questions. But if we omit the questions altogether, then perhaps the answers might not seem so foolish.

Doctor’s Notes (Interview with Mr. D.)

He was bothering everyone, talking all the time about Exley this, Exley that. This was years ago. So I said to him, T., you may talk like Exley, and you may act like Exley, and you may drink like Exley, but you may not talk about Exley. That you may not do, not in here. Once we established that, we all got along fine. Anyway, that’s why the other guys don’t know about Exley or that T. is so crazy about him. They’re not exactly what you’d call big readers anyway. The other guys just know T. as the happy drunk who acts like a crazy bastard on Sundays when he watches the Giants but otherwise seems pretty much like them on the other days of the week. Except on Tuesdays, when they call him the Professor.

Because he has his office hours here on Tuesday nights from six to eight. That’s what he calls them: his office hours.

Well, there’s never been any of his students seen in here during office hours, so yeah, I guess you could say we’ve all figured out he’s not really a professor.

Yeah, I guess they’re his friends. They drink together, if that’s what you mean.

Yeah, I guess he’s my friend, too. I’ve known him for a long time anyway.

Yeah, I wondered where he was, and no, I didn’t know he was in the army or in the VA until M. told me.

I guess I believe it. Why would M. lie about that?

Yeah, I know M. He’s a good kid. His dad loves him.

I know that because T. talks about him all the time. He talks about him almost as much as he used to talk about Exley, back when I let him.

Yeah, I know C., too. Not that well. I know that she’s pretty. I know that I wouldn’t mess with her. I know that T. loves her.

Because he says he does.

Just because you spend some time drinking in here doesn’t mean you can’t love your wife.

Well, that’s your opinion.

Well, that’s her opinion, too.

No, I don’t know any K. Whaddya mean, ‘K.’?

Yeah, I know people with that initial. But I’ve never seen any of them doing anything they shouldn’t with T. Not that I’ve seen.

Yeah, I’ve read the book.

Listen, I run a restaurant. I cook food and make drinks. That’s my area of expertise. But yeah, I liked it.

Why does anyone like anything? Because I know things I don’t like and I liked it better than that.

Oh yeah, I knew Exley.

Yeah, “knew.” Exley’s dead.

Yes, I’m sure Exley is dead.

No, I did not see his dead body. But I did see his gravestone up in Brookside Cemetery. So yeah, I’m pretty sure.

SOS

After Dr. Pahnee prevented me from reporting to homeroom so that I could skip the rest of my classes so that I could go find Exley in Alex Bay, I decided to forget about school altogether. Instead, I would go home, call the bus station, and find out when the first bus to Alex Bay was. But in order to get home, I had to walk right past school. J. walked out of school just as I was walking past. She had her backpack on and was wearing brown corduroy pants and the kind of shaggy sweater that looked like the animal it might have been made out of. The sweater was a cardigan, and it was open, and I could see that the pants weren’t pants but overalls. There was a huge button pinned to her sweater. The button said, in white block letters, “DOS.” In the background was an American flag. It wasn’t flat, but flapping, like it was in the wind and not on the button.

“Where have you been?” J. asked.

“Where are you going?” I asked.

“To the hospital to see my father,” she said.

“In the middle of the school day?” I asked. She gave me a look that asked who was I to talk. “Young lady,” I added in a deep voice. She laughed, took off her button. “Here’s my hall pass,” she said, and handed it to me. I’d seen buttons like it before: DOS meant “Daughter of a Soldier.” I wondered where she got it and where I could get one that said “SOS.” But it seemed like the kind of thing I should have known on my own, and so I didn’t ask her. I handed it back. J. pinned it back on her sweater and started walking. I walked with her, because I’d decided on the spot that since I’d only visited my dad in my head the day before and hadn’t even seen him, I needed to go see him before I went to Alex Bay.