Leadership Characteristics
One popular way of characterizing leadership is by describing it as authentic leadership. The American Association of Critical Care Nurses in their landmark work, AACN Standards for Establishing Healthy Work Environments: A Journey to Excellence , cite authentic leadership as one of the key standards necessary for establishing a healthy work environment. AACN's belief is that to establish and sustain healthy work environments for nurses, leadership that is authentic is a critical element. Authentic leadership requires skill in the core competencies of self‐knowledge, strategic vision, risk taking and creativity, interpersonal and communication effectiveness, and inspiration (American Association of Critical Care Nurses (AACN), 2004; Raso, 2019).
Leaders are also described by fundamental qualities that effective leaders have been found to share (Bennis & Nanus, 1985). The first quality is a guiding vision. Leaders focus on a professional and purposeful vision that provides direction toward a preferred future. The second quality is passion. Passion expressed by the leader involves the ability to inspire and align people toward the promises of life. Passion is an inherent quality of the nurse leader. The third quality is integrity that is based on knowledge of self, honesty, and maturity developed through experience and growth. Other leadership qualities include self‐awareness—knowing our strengths and weaknesses—that can allow us to use feedback and learn from our mistakes (McCall, 1998). Daring and curiosity are also basic ingredients of leadership that leaders draw on to take risks, learning from what works as much as from what does not work (Bennis & Nanus, 1985).
Certain characteristic traits are commonly attributed to leaders. These traits are considered desirable and seem to contribute to the perception of being a leader; intelligence, self‐confidence, determination, integrity, and sociability (Stodgill, 1948, 1974). Research among 46 hospitals designated as Magnet ®Hospitals by the American Nurses Center for Certification(ANCC) for their success in attracting and retaining registered nurses reported that nurse leaders who are visionary and enthusiastic, are supportive and knowledgeable, have high standards and expectations, value education and professional development, demonstrate power and status in the organization, are visible and responsive, communicate openly, and are active in professional associations are valued (Kramer, 1990; Kramer & Schmalenberg, 2005; McClure & Hinshaw, 2002; McClure, Poulin, Sovie, & Wandelt, 1983). Research findings from other studies on nurses revealed that caring, respectability, trustworthiness, and flexibility were the leadership characteristics most valued. In one study, nurse leaders identified managing the dream, mastering change, designing organization structure, learning, and taking initiative as leadership characteristics (Murphy & DeBack, 1991). Research by Kirkpatrick and Locke (1991) concluded that leaders are different from non‐leaders across six traits: drive, the desire to lead, honesty and integrity, self‐confidence, cognitive ability, and knowledge of the business. Although no set of traits is definitive and reliable in determining who is a leader or who is effective as a leader, many people still rely on many of these traits to describe and define leadership characteristics.
Many believe that the critical factor needed to maximize people's involvement is leadership (Bennis & Nanus, 1985). A more in‐depth understanding of leadership can be gleaned from a review of leadership theories. Leadership theories can be classified various ways. These are summarized in Table 1.2.
Table 1.2 Leadership Theories
BehavioralLeadership Theories |
|
AutocraticCentralized decision making: Leaders make decisions and use power to command and control others. |
(Three Approaches) |
DemocraticParticipative: Leaders use expert power and the power that emanates from close, personal relationships to involve others and make decisions. |
|
Laissez‐fairePassive and permissive: Leaders defer making decisions |
Two Basic Leader Behaviors |
Job‐centered behaviorsLeaders focus on schedules, costs, and efficiency; minimal attention given to develop work groups and high‐performance goals. |
|
Employee‐centered behaviorsLeaders focus on human needs of employees. |
Two Dimensions of Leader Behavior |
Initiating structureEmphasis is on the work to be structured; focus on task and production. Concern is how the work is organized and achieving goals. Leaders plan, direct others, establish deadlines, and give details of how work is to be done. |
|
ConsiderationFocus is on consideration of the employee and relating and getting along with people. Leaders attend to the well‐being of others; show empathy and interest in others; work on creating relationships to promote communication and trust. |
ContingencyLeadership Theories(Four types) |
Contingency Theory of Leader EffectivenessLeader behavior is dependent or contingent on the interaction of the leader and the needs of the situation. By developing good or poor leader‐member relations, high or low task structure, and high or low position power, the leader matches the most favorable leadership style to the situation. |
|
Situational Leadership TheoryFocus is on the situation in determining leadership style: Telling style is high task, low relationship; Selling style is high task, high relationship; Participating style is low task, high relationship; Delegating style is low task and low relationship style. |
|
Path‐Goal TheoryLeaders make the path toward the goal easier for followers by selecting an appropriate style of leadership: Directive style focuses on the task; Supportive style is relationship focused and encouraging; Participative style involves followers in decision making; Achievement‐oriented style focuses on high structure and direction with high support and consideration. |
|
Substitutes for LeadershipSubstitutes for leadership are variables that may take the place of leadership behaviors and have influence on followers to the same degree as the leader's behavior. Examples included routine work, intrinsic satisfaction in the work, cohesiveness of the group, low position power, and rigid adherence to the rules. |
ContemporaryLeadership Theories(Five types) |
Charismatic TheoryLeaders convey an inspirational quality that promotes an emotional connection with followers. Leader qualities include self‐confidence, strength of convictions, communicating a vision, and high expectations. |
|
Transformational Leadership TheoryTransformational leaders empower others to become involved in a collective purpose, inspired by a vision of a preferred future; they motivate others to contribute and take action. |
|
Knowledge WorkersKnowledge workers bring specialized expertise to an organization. Valued for what they know, they are at the frontlines with expertise and information to take action; they are the organization's leaders. |
|
Complexity LeadershipComplexity leadership is relationship‐based. Leaders facilitate information flow, context, circumstances, and interaction to create the structure for change using systems thinking and complex adaptive systems as a foundation for leading. |
|
Servant LeadershipServant Leadership is a leadership philosophy that emphasizes service to others, a holistic approach to work, and promotes a sense of community and sharing of power in decision making (Spears & Lawrence, 2004). |
Читать дальше