Neil White - Beyond Evil

Dawn’s eyes flashed between the shotgun and the old man, then to John, looking around the room, pleading, scared. ‘We can’t do this,’ she said, her voice cracking. ‘It’s inhumane.’

‘Come out,’ Gemma said, her voice lacking in tone, flat and emotionless, and she twitched the shotgun.

Dawn put the cup down and walked towards the doorway, her shoulders slumped. When she went past John, she looked up at him, stared into his eyes, and he read what she was thinking, that it was all wrong.

John looked towards the old man, and doubts surfaced, because he looked close to death, emaciated and bedridden, and John knew it was cruel.

Gemma spoke up. ‘John, help me.’

When he glanced back towards her, he felt his doubts slip away.

John turned round to push Dawn on her shoulder, so that she stumbled towards the bottles now piled in one corner.

‘Sit there, don’t move,’ he said, and then he walked towards the door that opened onto the field.

Someone had to keep watch.

Chapter Thirty-Three

As Charlie looked at the contents of the Billy Privett file spread across the table, Donia asked, ‘So what is the story? The real story?’

‘You’ve heard of Billy Privett?’

She nodded. ‘Everyone’s heard of Billy Privett. That’s why I came to Oulton.’

Charlie was surprised. ‘What, because of Billy?’

‘Not exactly,’ she said, smiling, knowing how it sounded. ‘I knew which firm represented him, and so I guessed that you were important.’

‘And now, you’re disappointed?’

‘I didn’t expect you to be how you are,’ she said.

‘What, some small practice above a takeaway?’

‘Something like that,’ she said, embarrassed.

‘You don’t need fancy offices if you do criminal work,’ Charlie said. ‘Just somewhere convenient for the clients and not too far from the court.’

‘So about Billy?’

Charlie sighed. ‘He was just a loser who got lucky once in his life,’ he said, waving his hand dismissively. ‘Six numbers, that’s what changed him. He was a pain in the arse before he won it. Afterwards, he was a pain in the arse who suddenly thought he was a big deal.’

‘But was he a murderer?’ Donia said. ‘Did he kill Alice Kenyon?’

Charlie shrugged. ‘He said not. Perhaps there’ll be something in here,’ and he patted the papers on the desk. ‘I know that Amelia fought hard to keep him away from the inquest.’

‘Could he do that? Stay away, I mean.’

‘Inquests are just to find out how someone died. They’re not there to find the murderer. It’s the how and the why , not the who . Billy provided a written statement that said he didn’t remember anything, even who else was there. The coroner decided that there was no point in making him give evidence at the inquest if that was all he was going to say. Ted made a real stink in the papers about that, but he just wanted the inquest to be something different to what it was.’

‘I feel sorry for him,’ Donia said. ‘I’ve seen him on the news. He seems like a nice man.’

‘He is, much nicer than me, but he’ll go to the grave waiting to find out what happened, now that Billy is dead.’

Charlie reached for the correspondence clip and went to the back, to the first time Amelia had spoken to Billy, when the police had dragged him in after Alice had been found. Most of the information was just personal, just what they would need to conduct the case. There was a sheet at the back where she had written out Billy’s version of events. When he looked, Charlie was surprised. He had expected to read Billy’s story, all set out in Amelia’s neat script, but there was just one sentence. I do not wish to disclose to anyone what happened at my house on 14th May 2011 , with his signature underneath.

He tapped his lip. That was unusual. Billy Privett didn’t even want Amelia to know what had happened. That isn’t how clients work. They try to get their lawyer to believe the lies, as if it somehow makes it true when it becomes the official version. They never realise that the lawyer never truly believes, or even cares. It is only ever about two things; what can be proven, and how will they get paid.

‘What did Billy say?’ Donia asked, leaning forward.

‘Not much,’ Charlie said, and showed her the piece of paper.

She frowned and sat back. ‘So the file isn’t important.’

He started to flick through the other sheets of paper, with letters sent to Billy demanding that her bills be paid. Once the police station work had finished, Amelia billed Billy privately for her work. As he got to the end, to the letter sent most recently, he opened his mouth to speak, but couldn’t think of what to say.

‘What is it?’ Donia said, trying to get closer.

Charlie looked up. ‘Amelia sent out letters yesterday, when she found out Billy had died, enclosing a DVD.’

‘Show me,’ Donia said.

Charlie tilted the folder towards her. The letters were short, just I enclose a video shot by Billy Privett recently, and which I have been authorised to disclose in the event of his death. It was the recipients that interested Charlie. There were ten letters, all identical. There was one sent to the police, one to Ted Kenyon, three to television companies and five to newspapers.

‘Does it say what was on the discs?’

Charlie shook his head. ‘I don’t know, but it is certainly unusual. It makes it sound like a final statement, a message beyond the grave or something.’

‘The story of what really happened to Alice?’ Donia said.

‘What else can it be?’ Charlie said, nodding. ‘Which means that someone wanted to silence him, scared of what he would say.’ He frowned. ‘But why now?’

‘What do you mean?’

‘The timing must be important, because he kept quiet for over a year and then decided to commit something to video. He was killed a few days later. The timing seems crucial. So he must have been scared of something. And there is something else too.’

‘Go on.’

‘How did whoever killed Billy know about the DVD?’ When Donia looked confused, Charlie continued, ‘Think about it. The killer must have known that he was talking, or else why silence him?’

‘Yeah, but if that was the case, why kill him? It was his death that prompted Amelia to send the videos.’

‘That was their mistake. Billy was talking, they knew that, but they didn’t know that it was only to be released after his death. Only Amelia and Billy knew that.’

‘And now they are both dead.’

Charlie nodded. ‘Billy must have spoken up about the video when he was being tortured, and so Amelia was the next target because she would know where they were.’

‘But isn’t there another problem?’ Donia said. ‘If they were sent yesterday, why hasn’t it been in the paper or on the television?’

‘I don’t know,’ Charlie said. ‘Perhaps the police suppressed them, and asked the press to hold it back.’ Then something occurred to him. His stomach started to roll, knowing that the reason for all of this was becoming clearer. ‘No, it’s not that,’ he said quietly. ‘Linda came in early this morning. She said she wasn’t up to date with her post, because of the burglary.’

‘What do you mean?’

‘The videos were never posted. They were left overnight in the office, because things got messed up, and whatever was on them must have been important, because it was for distribution only after his death.’

‘They might still be at the office,’ Donia said. ‘Everything closed down once the police had gone.’

Charlie shook his head. ‘No, because I’ll bet they were stolen.’

Donia looked confused. ‘I don’t know what you mean.’