Ragnar Benson - Ragnar's Urban Survival

“Why would I even dream of owning a gun? I don’t want to attack anyone,” was his instant response. Obviously he was from one of those new touchy-feely type of men’s magazines that wouldn’t touch articles about guns, cockfighting, cigars, or bear hunting on a bet.

There are those among us who believe that our president’s cur rent tirade against gun owners is not really about diverting attention from his many other shortcomings, but rather a thinly disguised attempt to make average citizens more dependent on government. This theory gains credibility when we realize again that our police forces have no binding legal responsibility to protect us! Citizens have repeatedly tried to sue for damages when they were denied permission to own a gun for self-protection and were subsequently attacked. Suits for damages against their police departments got nowhere.

It’s true that Thomas Jefferson believed Americans should own firearms as a final last resort against government officials who oppress them. But in this era of wall-to-wall cities, it may be more than that. There is also the matter of government ownership and distribution—either through direct ownership or indirectly through licensing—of electricity, heat, water, communications (radio, phone, and TV), transportation, and postal services. But self-protection is even more at the core than these.

Numerous experts have pointed out that Stalin could never have murdered and carried out deportations in the Ukraine, Mao in northern China, Pol Pot in Cambodia, or England in Scotland (during their 18th-century war of independence) had average citizens been even modestly well armed.

Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn, author and philosopher, believes the Russian people could have even successfully resisted the secret police and going to the gulags with little more than resolute application of axes, butcher knives, harvesting tools, and meat hooks. Sounds like lots of resoluteness, but his idea is duly noted.

The reporter never did admit to seeing the connection between private firearms and freedom, but he seemed to warm to the idea that official provision of sewer, garbage, and water service could quickly lead to significant control. “Fact is,” he said, “I vividly recall our garbage strike and what an incredible mess that turned out to be,” he finally admitted.

He did weasel a bit by claiming garbage service was private in New York. “Yes, private, but maintained by a government-enforced monopoly,” I suggested. “All they have to do is threaten to pull the company’s permit and your garbage collectors will do whatever the bureaucracy wants. You cannot legally go into any business in New York without official sanction,” I reminded him.

Water is extremely important to city survivors. Failure of supply could be as serious as going without personal protection, and could arguably be as vital or more vital than personal gun ownership. But to claim that garbage is more important than guns is just that.

Other than electric utilities being government-controlled monopolies, is the electrical system in very many big cities in America still directly owned and controlled by the government? During the 1920s and ’30s many small, more rural cities developed their own electrical systems—mostly small-scale hydro projects. Currently, even when utility companies are not collectively owned, the authorities can throw their considerable weight around, denying service to anyone they wish. This is exactly how it works in Cuba, where average citizens don’t receive enough power each day to successfully run a refrigerator!

Wise city survivors had best look at their own situations now, before the crisis. What essentials to your life do your central authorities provide? Can they arbitrarily and capriciously cut you off, forcing you into becoming a ward of the state?

Forms of government dependence are not all obvious and may vary in priority according to a person’s philosophy Service may vary from city to city, and from country to country. In Britain and Canada, for example, citizens must go hat in hand to the bureaucracy for permission to have a vasectomy; a hernia repair, or knee surgery A close friend flew his mother to the United States for a hip replacement because she was too old to receive one in Canada! Bypass surgery is not done in Cuba past the age of 50 because recipients do not have sufficient working life left to give to the state. The United States is headed in that direction. More distressing, some people really believe this is a good thing!

In Beirut, shortly after the very bleak days, private mail courier services sprang up. Again, we must keep our eye on the ball. Establishment of private medical care might be very important. But is mail delivery on our list of absolutes required to sustain life?

On one occasion a woman told my daughter, only half in jest, that she could not envision life without her daily soaps (low-grade melodramatic entertainment). Possession of a functional TV cable, satellite dish, or computer connection might possibly be a requirement for her life. That is certainly not a judgment I wish to make.

Like any other survivors, city survivors must start planning now if they hope to provide their own services. It’s very important to note that, on close inspection, we often find many of these services are provided by central authorities. Anne Frank, the young Jewish girl in World War II Holland, almost survived. She wrote that at times a chronic lack of sewage/waste disposal actually threatened their sanity, security, and immediate health.

Personal responsibility and self-reliance require great attention to detail. An unlicensed private nursery in Salem, Oregon, for example, was discovered and summarily shuttered when authorities were tipped off to its existence by the quantity of disposable diapers found in their trash. This is not city survival, but a down-home example of the length to which bureaucrats will go to maintain their control.

My list of vital services that may be controlled by the government and for which city survivors should make other arrangements includes the following:

• Sewage systems

• Garbage collection and disposal

• Communications including radio, television, phone, mail, and Internet access

• Fuel

• Medical services

• Utilities such as gas and electric power

• Transportation

• Water

• Food

• Self-defense/security

• Shelter

Of these, only food, water, shelter, and self-defense are definitely on the list of must-haves needed to survive. Others may also be there, depending on one’s personal circumstance. My advice is to never, never rely on people who don’t give a damn—such as government officials—for something really important.