Jesse Ball - Samedi the Deafness

— I just want to be clear, said James. I'm not a prisoner?

— A prisoner? said McHale, laughing. You were never a prisoner. I'm sorry if Torquin gave you that impression. He and the others were just a bit worried after the business on Verit Street. You did, after all, throw a man out a window.

— I did not! said James. Who do you think I am? That man jumped! I didn't even know him. He jumped!

— Yes, yes, said McHale, laughing. They always do, don't they?

He went to the door, opened it, and went out into the passage. After a minute, he stepped back in.

— Oh, another thing: we ask that you leave the pistol in your room. If you want, of course, we can dispose of it for you. Better certainly that you not keep on your person anything linking you to Mayne's murder, don't you think? Yes, well, think about it. It's yours, after all.

And with that, he went away.

Beneath the Bell

there was indeed a finely wrought key. The metal of the key handle curved in a circle, in the midst of which had been formed the number 17.

— Number seventeen is this way, sir, said the maid, who stood now in the door, holding across her arm his coat.

Up James stood and crossed the room, taking not a moment to look back as perhaps he ought to have at the relative position of the two chairs. McHale's was pointing at the chair in which James had sat, while James's chair looked meekly off towards the empty fireplace.

With a curt nod, the maid closed the room and locked it so that no one thereafter could get in.

Room no. 17

was upon the fourth floor. As houses in London, so rooms in this mansion, their numbers and assignments varying not to suit their neighbors. Beside 17 was 3, beside 3 was 22. How many rooms there were, James could not say for sure.

His room was quite nice, however, and neatly set up. A large bed before a bay window, easy chairs by a fireplace, a broad reading table with stationery stamped upon with a peculiar sigil. All bore his look well.

To his great surprise, the wardrobe set against one wall contained his own clothing. How it had come to be there was a question he could not answer; nor did he feel capable even of asking it. So totally was he overcome by doubt as to that which he could be certain of, that he needed some time to reassemble in his mind certain tenets that he could rely upon, the others to dismiss.

Upon the reading table, the newspapers of the last three days. Also, the book of the house.

The Book of the House

Beside the book of the house was an envelope addressed to James Sim. He opened it. Inside was a letter.

Father,

Here is my report on the man James Sim who was with McHale when he died.

James Sim

a. 6' 1” tall, weight approximately 180 lbs., clean shaven, 32 years old.

c. curiously enough did not go to get an ambulance when McHale was dying.

d. appears to have killed a man in Estrainger's apartment building by throwing him bodily from a window (defenestration).

e. 's reasons for doing the above are unclear. d, e. has a clean criminal record.

f. is a mnemonist by trade. Might therefore be useful to us.

h. has a nondriver ID that says his eyes are gray. Therefore, cannot operate an automobile?

i. has no debts, no friends, acquaintances, wife, children.

k. is okay to look at, but certainly not handsome.

l. has never voted, for instance.

m. can act rashly if forced to it. Witness: d.

p. rarely writes things down. You are the recipient of one specimen of his writing (sample a.: napkin). Strangely enough, a search of his house yielded no other samples of writing.

I took his wallet and gave it back to him. Should I not have? Given it back, I mean.

Grieve

The Book of the House

James folded the letter and replaced it in the envelope. Why give such a letter to him? Why send the girl to follow him anyway if she was prone to lying? She hadn't lied in her report. Maybe she never lied to her father. That could be true.

And they had searched his house? When had they had time to do that?

He sat down at the reading table. His thoughts ran back over his conversation with McHale number two. What was wrong with it? He tried to think over McHale's logic.

There were several holes.

The book of the house was on the table in front of him. James picked it up and opened it at random.

rule 37

It is necessary when proceeding from hall to hall and along the stairways never to speak with anyone you see, aside from servants. Should you wish to speak to someone, ring the bell that has been provided to you. Everyone in the vicinity will stop his or her movements. Count then to fifteen and approach the other person, giving them time to gather their thoughts. Then you may pose your question or voice your concern.

Also, a better method of interaction is afforded by the system of note-sending. All the rooms of the house are provided with a small mail shelf on the near wall beside the door. Simply place your note on the shelf, and it will be received and responded to at the person's leisure. If you suspect that the person is within the room, and you are leaving a note when time is of the essence, you may knock once upon the door knocker.

See rule 14 for the particularities of the use of the door knocker.

The light coming through the window was quite pleasant. He wondered if the glass had anything to do with it. Often he had wondered about the effect of glass on a room. He had even thought of writing a monograph on it, for he had been a reclusive young boy, given to long hours of study, and seldom, if ever, playing with others. Such a monograph, though he did not in fact write it, would have been typical of his occupation during those countless solitary hours. In fact, from the monograph, which, I grant you, does not exist, we could extrapolate much that would be useful in considering James's psychology. What are his feelings for thin glass? For thick? In what ways does he characterize light? Into how many categories? A monograph, in fact, might be written to interpret the first monograph. However, as we have said, neither has been written.

James turned to rule 14.

rule 14

The door knockers, in relation to private rooms.

no. of knocks; function.

1: announcement of note.

2: announcement of prearranged visit. 1 + 2: maid service.

3: announcement of sudden visit (discouraged).

2 + 2: emergency, fire, etc.

There was a knock then at the door. Just one.

James went to the door and opened it. No one was there. Upon the shelf outside the door, however, there was a note.

It said:

I will visit you in what might be considered the seventh hour of afternoon, or the first hour of evening. G.

James looked at his watch. It was six thirty.

Nearly Three and One Half Hours

since he had been abducted. He had never imagined, when he had thought of how his life would be, that kidnapping would be part of it. Certainly, as a mnemonist, he had entertained the idea. If he would undertake to commit some state secret to memory, surely there would be dangers. But he had been put forward for no such detail.

In any case, they had not abducted him. Supposedly, he had been invited to come to the house.

Also, they thought he had pushed Mayne out the window. Furthermore, they thought that, and had not gone to the police.

This, James realized, was a pretty piece of reasoning, and might go a long way towards puncturing McHale the second and his rationalizations. Yes, the first McHale must be correct, must have been correct about everything. Only criminals would fail to turn in a man they thought to be a criminal.