Tommaso Venturini - Controversy Mapping

6 Chapter 4 Figure 23Elements of a terroir, as told by Jean-Marie around his vineyards in Berlou Figure 24Extract from the official map of the Languedoc AOCs Figure 25Trained vines with irrigation system on the plains near Béziers and troll vines on… Figure 26Cellar floor, fermentation tanks, and the dog named Terroir in Béziers; cellar f… Figure 27A semiotic triangle of French wine oppositions Figure 28Three ways of telling the story of French wine and terroir using Greimas’s model … Figure 29A diagram of programs and anti-programs of action in a hotel reception Figure 30Markings on a street encouraging social distancing in front of a rotisserie kios… Figure 31The trajectory of the TSR2 project Figure 32The redirection of actions through the obligatory passage point (OPP) proposed b… Figure 33The Centre Pompidou in Paris Figure 34aNetwork of actors cast for HBO series visualized by separating actors and series Figure 34bNetwork of actors cast for HBO series visualized by keeping actors and series on… Figure 35aLuc Boltanski’s original table of the French dominant class Figure 35bA redesign of figure 35a as a network with institutions and individuals connecte… Figure 36Hope by Shepard Fairey (2008) courtesy of Obey Giant, flanked by the original ph…

7 Chapter 5 Figure 37South Korean search interest in the topics “Coronavirus,” “Mask,” and “Vaccines”… Figure 38German search interest in the topics “Coronavirus,” “Mask,” and “Vaccines” overl… Figure 39German search interest in the topics “Zoom Video Communications,” “Toilet Paper,… Figure 40Search topics related to the topic “Coronavirus” in Germany between February 19 … Figure 41The divide between qualitative and quantitative methods as revealed by a visual … Figure 42The three generations of social sciences Figure 43The power-law distribution of online attention and the popularity and personaliz…

8 Chapter 6 Figure 44The research chain of digital methods and how it will be covered in the followin… Figure 45Thirteen pages discovered by crawling the “Circumcision controversies” page on W… Figure 46Network obtained by crawling the “Circumcision controversies” page on Wikipedia … Figure 47Network obtained by crawling the “Circumcision controversies” page on Wikipedia … Figure 48Network of pages from the “Circumcision” category on Wikipedia connected by all … Figure 49An example of a link template from Wikipedia Figure 50Network of pages from the “Circumcision” category on Wikipedia connected to each… Figure 51Network of pages from the “Circumcision” category on Wikipedia connected by the … Figure 52Three versions of the same network of pages from the “Circumcision” category on … Figure 53aApparent correlation between queries for “side effects” and the unemployment rat… Figure 53bThe similarity of trends in Google Trends for the queries “symptoms,” “side effe… Figure 54An example of a sophisticated search query in ISI Web of Science Figure 55The Palestinian Blogosphere as crawled by Anat Ben-David in 2007 Figure 56The three-layered model of online connectivity and the three-step crawling prot… Figure 57Network shortcuts and the formation of small worlds in clustered networks Figure 58Normal distribution of connectivity in the US highway system; and the power-law …

9 Chapter 7 Figure 59HPV vaccination activity in Denmark month by month from 2009 to 2016, Danish med… Figure 60Mentions of “side effect” in Danish Facebook conversations related to the HPV va… Figure 61Network of Facebook posts mentioning both “HPV” and “side effects” from 2012 to … Figure 62Two renderings of a network of Wikipedia pages related to the Green Revolution Figure 63Central and bridging nodes in the Green Revolution network Figure 64Authorities and hubs in the Green Revolution network Figure 65The Green Revolution network according to our manual thematic classification of … Figure 66Turning the city of Königsberg and its bridges into a matrix of associations Figure 67Headline, subhead and lead of Moreno’s 1933 New York Times interview; Jacob More… Figure 68aThe London Underground map before Harry Beck’s redesign Figure 68bThe London Underground map after Harry Beck’s redesign

10 Chapter 8 Figure 69Network of scientific literature related to “AI for humanity” visualized as a contour map Figure 70Setup for the presentation of our scientometric maps at the “Global Forum for Ar… Figure 71The same network of scientific literature related to “AI for humanity” as seen f… Figure 72The same network of scientific literature related to “AI for humanity” as seen f… Figure 73Negotiations in the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (1995–… Figure 74Rise and fall in the visibility of issues in the international climate negotiati… Figure 75The level of intervention of the 21 most active countries in the UNFCCC negotiat… Figure 76Two unsatisfactory maps: too complex and too simplified Figure 77The controversy atlas as a way to manage the trade-off between the richness that… Figure 78An example of a tree of disagreements (reproduced from figure 1) Figure 79An example of an actor/issue table (reproduced from figure 2) Figure 80An example of a network diagram (reproduced from figure 3) Figure 81An example of debate scales (reproduced from figure 4) Figure 82An example of debate dynamics (reproduced from figure 5) Figure 83Ten types of evolution in the complexity of a controversy over time Figure 84The narration-exploration circle of controversy mapping Figure 85Datascape navigation on lafabriquedelaloi.fr Figure 86aRecipe for tracing the fate of a fake news story online: the digital methods pro… Figure 86bRecipe for tracing the fate of a fake news story online: the resulting visualiza…

11 Chapter 9 Figure 87The spiral of public participation

12 Controversy mapping in the shadow of Gaia Figure 88The planet Melancholia crashing into the Earth in the 2011 movie by Lars von Tri… Figure 89Lynn Margulis carving a sample from the cyanobacteria tissue responsible for the… Figure 90Two of the first and most famous pictures of the Earth seen from space, Earthris…

1 ii

2 iii

3 iv

4 xi

5 xii

6 xiii

7 xiv

8 xv

9 xvi

10 xvii

11 xviii

12 xix

13 xx

14 1

15 2

16 3

17 4

18 5

19 6

20 7

21 8

22 9

23 10

24 11

25 12

26 13

27 14

28 15

29 16

30 17

31 18

32 19

33 20

34 21