Niall Williams: As It Is in Heaven

“I can’t feel any joy,” he said.

Tim Magrath said nothing. He felt the eyes of the patient staring at him for an answer, but was so surprised that he had to get up and look at the street outside. He watched the cars passing for a moment.

“My wife died. My daughter died with her.”

The doctor felt a shiver of guilt run down his spine; he had heard of the crash, of course, but had missed the funeral, and then let the facts of it slip away beyond acknowledgement.

“It was three years ago,” Philip said, “and it’s just, I can’t feel any joy. In anything. Maybe I’m not supposed to. But I just thought I’d mention it to somebody. I wonder, will I? … I just can’t seem to.” He was not distressed, he spoke about it as if telling a mildly unusual facet of his diet.

Tim McGrath did not know what to say; he looked out the window. (He did not yet know the prescription for loss, and would not even understand the ailment until four years later, when he would return from golf at the Grange on a Saturday afternoon and find his wife, Maire, dead on the bed upstairs. Then the loss would descend upon him and he would walk out across the manicured summer lawns of his front garden and feel nothing. Then he would recall the tailor and realize with a blow that made him sit down on the grass that in fact he knew nothing about healing.)

But he did not know yet that the incredible world could vanish from the living as easily as from the dead. He looked out the window and watched the traffic in a practised way that he knew looked as if he were thinking. Finally Dr. Magrath turned around to face his patient. “Are you sleeping at night?” he asked.

And that was it. When Philip walked back across the city to the shop, he had a bottle of sleeping tablets in his jacket pocket. He had never taken them, and gradually allowed the promise of spring to die away into the wet summer of that year, taking with it the faint prompting at the corners of his mind that perhaps there was a way back to joy. By the autumn, the relentless and immutable progress of sorrow had continued like an intimacy in Philip Griffin’s heart. He anticipated affliction and imagined that by doing so his life was more bearable.

No, happiness did not run in the Griffin family, it fled away; for them there was no relief to balance tragedy. In quiet moments after Stephen had moved to the west, Philip had begun to hope that his son’s life would simply escape into ordinariness, that nothing remarkable would happen. But now, sitting opposite him at the chessboard in the dark, he realized that was not the case. And worse, that he was to live to see it.

He looked at the chessboard and memorized the position. He would lay it out again after Stephen had driven away and study it for clues. He knew the woman Stephen was in love with was unsuitable, but was not sure yet why. Perhaps she was married or did not care for him at all.

It was a little time before Philip stood up and moved past the sleeping figure. He moved out into the hallway and in the hot press found a blanket. When he came back and laid it over his son, the young man seemed to him to have grown younger. He was smaller, too. And for the four hours that remained until morning Philip decided to sit there in the armchair opposite him.

They had had so much time together since the day, that day; years of living in the same house that had taught them the fine skills of walking in empty rooms and being aware of the ghosts. They had lived around each other as much as with each other. But the invisible bond that held them together was the searing memory of those first moments after the accident when they had seen each other for the first time and stood in mute but tearless rage as they felt the burning pain of love and the perishing of hope. The funeral had been automatic; it was as if two other people and not Philip and Stephen were there. But afterwards, in the unnaturally stilled days when father and son came from their rooms in the house only when they knew they would not encounter each other, when they stole down the stairs laden with the guilt of having survived, the bond between them had grown. It grew without their speaking of it. It grew while they lay in their beds in the dark, sleepless and angry, asking God over and over why it was they who had lived. Why not kill me? And as week after week passed and they still lived on, the man and his son washing the dishes at the counter, hanging out the clothes on the line where the ghost of the mother was already standing, Philip and Stephen carried the burden of their survival in exactly the same manner. They did not speak of it but took the puzzle of their days everywhere with them, growing an identical jagged wrinkle across the middle of their foreheads and talking fitfully in the brief periods of their night sleep.

Now, fifteen years later, Philip Griffin saw that his son had not entirely escaped the habits of those years. For at once, instants after the blanket had been put across him in the armchair, Stephen began talking in his sleep. His words were unintelligible at first, and even though his father got from his chair and knelt down beside him like a priest, he could make nothing of them. He touched the sweat on his son’s forehead, where it glistened in the low light. He was startled at how cold it was. It was as chill as seawater. He was thinking to get another blanket, or wake Stephen and move him to the bed, when he finally realized that the words his son was speaking were Italian.

Stephen Griffin had first seen Gabriella Castoldi playing violin in a concert in the thick-curtained upstairs room of the Old Ground Hotel in Ennis in County Clare. He had not intended to be there and marvelled often afterwards how one moment leads to the next, until the pattern of our lives seems inevitable. He worked as a history teacher in a grey school by the sea at Spanish Point twenty miles away and lived in a house with no curtains, where the Atlantic sprayed his windows and whispered like a mystery in every room. He had lived there for three years since taking the job. The day he came for the interview he drove west until he met the coastline and knew at once not that he wanted the position but that he wanted to be there in the west, for that sense of arrival in reaching the edge of the country. He had searched for the house for the same reason, finding a place that was small and damp but, unlike so many of the other old cottages, turned outward to the sea. Its front-room window looked out over a small slope of burnt grass that fell away in a sharp cliff into the alarming pounding of the tide. When he sat in the front room and looked westward into the slow movement of the swollen waters, he did not know it but he was the mirror of his father sitting in Dublin.

“History is disappearing,” the principal, Mrs. Waters, told him at the interview. “Nobody wants to do history anymore. It’s a terrible shame.” The students preferred computers, she said with a tone of derision. “History is long and difficult, Mr. Griffin; there’s a lot of reading in it,” said Mrs. Waters. “That’s the reason. They don’t like reading. They’re too lazy. Your classes will be small. But maybe you’ll be able to change all that.” It was a little threat. Mrs. Waters was a big woman with a small mouth; she seemed to know that the smallness of her mouth betrayed some lack of feeling and had overpainted her lips, which she pursed constantly to reassure herself. She sat across the table from Stephen and wondered would he do. It wasn’t everybody who could stick it out, the west was bleak in the winter, and between the broken Atlantic skies and the rough sea, few souls not born to it endured. So Mrs. Waters imagined, sitting in the neatness of her principal’s office and priding herself on the rigid indestructibility of her own person.