Judy Blundell - What I Saw and How I Lied

And how did the vase get smashed?

I felt myself almost falling, I was so afraid. Mom tilted her head and gave the tiniest shrug.

"My husband and I were dancing to the radio, and we bumped into it," she said. She looked over at Joe and smiled just a little bit. "He's not a very good dancer."

A woman in back of me laughed a little, and the judge banged his gavel.

When did my mother get to be such a cool liar? When did she learn to use her face to look so innocent?

Maybe when she fell in love with Peter. She had so many lies to tell.

The attorney in the gray suit started pounding her with questions now. He didn't like the way the tide was turning. What time did they get the boat, whose idea was it to leave the lake and go out into the ocean, did the two men argue?

"The wind picked up. There were these gusts ... they frightened me. Peter said if he couldn't fix it, we could be in trouble. The boat went up like this —" Mom held her hand out and tilted it. "I was terrified. So I went downstairs."

Everyone in the courtroom busted out laughing.

"You went below," the attorney said in a scolding way, like she hadn't done her nautical homework and he'd caught her out.

"Below." Mom nodded like an eager student. I think if she'd smiled, if she'd laughed along with everyone, that would have ruined it. They wouldn't have liked it if she was in on the joke.

He kept asking questions, but Mom had won. They liked her now. She was from New York but she didn't know what they knew. She had turned herself from a femme fatale into a dumb blonde. They knew she couldn't kill anyone. She was too pretty. She was too dim.

You both did well," Mr. Markel said. We'd left the courtroom straight through the judge's chambers to avoid all the cameras. Now we sat in a small office Mr. Markel had borrowed. Miss Geiger had left us lunch. Sandwiches had been unwrapped and a ther­mos of coffee sat steaming, its lid forgotten. The only one who ate and drank was Grandma Glad.

"Evie's next up, right?" Joe asked, leaning forward, his hands clasped. "And she's the last witness. It could all be over today, right?"

"There's another witness," Mr. Markel said. "Just came forward. Walter Forrest.”

“Who?" Joe asked.

Mr. Markel looked down at his file. "He worked at Le Mirage. As a bellhop and valet.”

“Wally?" I asked.

"What the devil does Wally know about anything?" Joe asked.

Mr. Markel looked over his glasses at Joe. "That, indeed, is the question."

Mom pushed her chair back and went to the window. She hugged herself as she looked down at the street.

"Is there anything you can think of that Mr. Forrest might have to say?" Mr. Markel asked.

"Nothing," Joe said. "Bev?"

"Nothing," she said. She didn't turn around.

Wally was wearing a white shirt tight at the neck and a bow tie. His pants were hitched up too high. When he sat down I could see his brown socks end and his calf begin. He didn't look at me or Joe or Mom.

I recognized his father in the courtroom. He kept his hands on his knees and his eyes on his boy.

Wally stated his name and where he worked. He said he was acquainted with the Spooners and with Mr. Coleridge, that he parked cars for the hotel and carried suitcases and ran errands. "Short staff, they didn't usually open in September, see," he said. "They don't get so many guests. So sure, you get to know em."

And why did Walter come forward and talk to the police, Mr. Toomer wanted to know, asking the question in a smug way that let you know he was delighted he knew the answer before everyone else.

"I walk home on the lake trail," Wally said. "Every night, the same way. It's real quiet now because it's off-season. Mr. Wentworth's place — he lives down the block from the hotel — it backs up on the lake there, and I cut through it to get to the trail. It's a shortcut. He gave me permission, since he eats at the hotel most every night during the season."

"Mr. Allen Wentworth," the attorney said, and I could tell everyone knew who he was, some Palm Beach swell.

"Anyway," Wally said, swallowing so hard I could see it from the third row, "one night, it was a Friday, because I get off later on Fridays, I was walking through the grass, and I hear something, I don't know what, so I stop. And I walk over a little bit..." Wally began to squirm in his chair and stuck a finger in his collar. "Ah, and I see a couple leaning against a tree."

"What was the couple doing?"

"They were, ah, necking, sir."

"Could you identify the people you saw, Walter?"

"Well, I recognized Mrs. Spooner right off, because of that blue gown she's got. And she must have heard me, because she twisted around, but she didn't see me. She ducked her face kind of, and the guy looked over her shoulder, and I saw it was Mr. Coleridge."

"You're certain?"

"Yessir, I saw them plain as day."

The judge knocked the gavel for silence.

I knew exactly which night it was. Mom had gone upstairs with a headache. I'd sat in the lobby for a while and then gone outside, and Peter had been walking to his car. We'd gone to the beach.

He kissed me that night.

But first, he'd kissed Mom. I remembered seeing Wally in the lobby, just getting off his shift. I'd killed at least ten minutes after that, walking around the hotel. All that time, Mom and Peter were together.

She didn't go upstairs that night. She didn't have a headache. She'd run out the side door, the same door I'd used so no one would see me. She'd met him under the trees. They'd arranged it beforehand. And Wally had caught them.

"What did you do next?"

"I walked away. Real quiet. I didn't want to get in any trouble. The thing is, about hotels, my old boss, Mr. Forney, told me, whatever happens in a hotel you keep your mouth shut. Whatever you see, you keep your mouth shut. That's the way you keep your job, he said. So I didn't say anything."

"Why did you come forward, Walter?"

"When I read the news, I told my dad what I saw. It was him who told me to come forward. It's the right thing to do, he said."

"Indeed," the state's attorney said in a flowery way, as if he was reciting the Gettysburg Address. "Indeed."

He let the silence hang while he pretended to look down at his notes. We kept our eyes straight forward, because everyone in the courtroom was trying to get a good look at us.

"Now, let's go to the early morning of September sev­enteenth. You were working at the hotel that night."

Wally nodded eagerly, a question he could answer without getting anybody in trouble. "I was on bell­hop and valet duty. Nobody was up yet, just a couple guests. Mr. Spooner came down and asked for his car, so I brought it around. Usually he'd just take off, but that morning he shot the breeze a little. We were all talking about the storm by then. Wondering where it would hit. And he asked about hurricane preparations for the hotel, what we did to prepare and whatnot. And then he asks about the boats, what happens to the boats."

The courtroom was completely silent. The judge didn't have to bang his gavel.

"Said he heard something about hurricane holes. So I tell him, sure, there are places to tie a boat, hope nothing bad happens, a kind of shelter. Bunch of them down by Lake Worth, some a little bit north. I told him about snook fishing around Munyon Island, that my dad has a boat. He's interested in that, asks if my dad rents his boat, and I say sure, that's what he does for a living. So he says that maybe he'd want to take it out that morn­ing, and he'd make it worth my dad's while. I don't think anything about it until I hear that he found a hurricane hole for the boat. That's all." Wally looked at the attor­ney in a pleading way, waiting to be released.