Paige Tyler - Two Cops, a Girl and a Pair of Handcuffs

She turned back around to look at Hayes. He’d stopped massaging her cheeks the second she’d balked at what Reed was planning. Now he nodded at her and squeezed her bottom, making her anus tighten around Reed’s finger. This was probably the most attention her ass had ever received at one time. It felt amazing. It also made it hard to think.

“Cilla?” Reed prompted.

She looked at him over her shoulder. “I've loved everything the two of you have done to me tonight. It's been amazing, Unforgettable even.”

“Then what makes you thing that you won't enjoy what I'm about to do next?”

The combination of Hayes’s hands on her ass and Reed’s finger inside it were too distracting to answer right away, and she had to force herself to focus. “But your cock is so…”

“Big?” he finished for her. His mouth quirked. “Just because I have a big cock doesn't mean it has to hurt. The secret is being slow and careful, two things I'm very good at. Of course, proper preparation is key as well. You have to work the lube in and relax the muscles.”

As if to demonstrate, Reed moved his fingers again. She was surprised at how relaxed she was. She supposed that supported Reed's assertions.

“You really should give it a go,” Hayes said from under her. “Reed’s not exactly a newbie at this. He knows what he's doing. I think you'd enjoy the hell out of it.”

Easy for Hayes to say. He wasn’t the one Reed wanted to shove his big erection in. She loved Reed's fingers in her bottom, but the math just didn't seem to work out beyond that. Even with a gallon of lube and hours of stretching, there was no way his monster cock would fit in her ass, no matter how slow and careful he was.

“Just because you can get two fingers in there doesn't mean your cock will fit,” she insisted.

“Three,” Reed said.

Cilla opened her mouth to move on to her next logical point when Reed's words sunk in. “What?”

“Three,” Reed repeated. “As in I have three of my very big fingers sliding in and out of your bottom right now.”

She frowned as she tried to get a sense for what was happening back there. She hadn’t felt him slip another finger in her. Wouldn't she have felt that?

“Are you sure?” she asked, stalling for time as she clenched her muscles around him in an effort to feel each individual finger.

Both men laughed.

“I'm sure,” Reed said. “I may be a cop instead of an accountant, but I can count to three. And stop tightening up like that. You're supposed to be relaxing.”

Cilla forced herself to relax, but it was difficult. She tried to imagine how big three of Reed's fingers would be. That thought alone was a little intimidating. But as he continued to add more lube and massage her opening, she found herself melting against Hayes's chest. He lifted his hips to meet hers, squeezing her cheeks at the same time.

She bit her lip to stifle a moan. She should put her foot down-metaphorically, at least-and tell Reed her ass was off limits. But she couldn't. What he was doing felt too damn good. What they were both doing felt too good.

“Well?” Hayes asked.

Cilla lifted her head from his chest to find him gazing up at her with an almost pleading look in his hazel green eyes. How the hell could she say no when he looked at her like that? Maybe he was right. Maybe she would enjoy it. He and Reed had been right about everything else they’d done to her.

“Okay,” she said softly. She glanced over her should at Reed. “But you have to stop the second it's too much for me.”

He bent and pressed a kiss to the small of her back. “Of course. I’d never do anything to hurt you.”

Hayes turned her face toward him with a single finger and kissed her hard. “You made the right decision. You’re never going to forget this.”

Cilla was going to make a snide comment about people rarely ever forgetting traumatic events, either, and that this had better not be one of those, but Reed's strong hands on her ass silenced her. Both men had been nothing but tender with her since they started this. A comment like that would have been insulting.

It was obvious the two of them had done this before. There was no clumsy fumbling around trying to figure out where to put knees or hands. Reed simply cozied up to her ass and positioned the head of his cock at the opening. She tensed, unable to help herself.

Reed stilled, but didn’t pull away. He glided his hands up her back to massage her shoulders.

“Relax,” he whispered. “I’ll go at your pace. When you're ready, okay?”

“Okay.” She looked at Hayes. “Kiss me.”

He grinned. “Yes, ma'am.”

Wrapping his hand in her hair, he pulled her down and nibbled on her lower lip. She lost herself in the feel of Hayes’s mouth on hers as his cock moved in her pussy. It wasn't difficult-Hayes was a spectacular lay all by himself.

But while Hayes was distracting, it was impossible to ignore Reed and what he was doing. True to his word, he took his time. She knew a lot of guys who’d get impatient and push harder. Not Reed. The man had the self-control of a machine.

The feel of his cock working its way into her ass wasn’t uncomfortable. On the contrary, the way it throbbed against her opening was enough to make her moan against Hayes mouth. It was hard not to relax trapped between their big, strong bodies like she was. She could already feel her ass inviting him in. This just might work.

After what was probably ten minutes of trying, she realized it wasn't. Sure, it felt great, and she was relaxed, but while the head of his cock was now snuggly sitting inside the opening of her anus, it didn't seem like he was going to go any deeper no matter how much she wanted him to.

She shook her head. “I’m sorry, Reed. I tried, I really did. But your big guy just isn't going to fit.”

He chuckled. “Oh ye of little faith. My cock is already halfway in.”

Spinning around to look at him was beyond impossible trapped and cuffed between two big hunks, but she managed to crane her neck to give him an incredulous look. “No way! You’re kidding me?”

“No, I'm not. And before you ask, yes, I'm sure. Trust me, I think I know where my cock is. But since you didn’t know how far in I am, I guess that means it doesn't hurt.”

Cilla chewed on her lower lip as she focused on Reed’s cock. Could he possibly have gotten that big fella in her without any pain at all? It seemed incredible, but she felt it now-a fullness deep in her ass. It felt…great. Better than great. Her anus was buzzing with excitement. How had she missed it?

The answer was plain and simple. Reed had entered her so slowly that her body had adapted to his large size.

She smiled. “It doesn't hurt at all. I can't believe it.”

Hayes laughed. “I told you he was pretty good at this.”

Cilla couldn't help giggling. She felt as giddy as if she’d just won a prize at the county fair. “What now?”

She had no doubt she could take all of him now, and that knowledge turned her on like crazy.

“Now,” Reed said in answer to her question. “I take my time and work my cock a little deeper.”

While he entered her inch by glorious inch, Hayes rocked her on his cock again. It felt delicious, but now that she’d taken half Reed’s erection in her ass without complaint, she wanted the rest-immediately.

“You don't have to go so slowly,” she said. “I'm ready for more.”

“You are, are you?”

He sounded dubious, as if he didn’t quite believe her. Wanting to show him exactly how ready she was, she planted her hands on Hayes's chest and shoved back against Reed's cock.

The move clearly caught him by surprise. He sucked in a breath as her ass engulfed him all the way to the base of his cock. Cilla barely heard the sound over her own gasp. Okay, maybe that hadn't been such a bright idea. There was definitely some discomfort now.