Mark Gimenez - Accused

Pete Puckett had won the U.S. Open.

It was his first win in over twenty years, and hands-down the sports shocker of the year. Pete high-fived Goose then walked off the green and wrapped his arms around his young daughter and lifted her into the air. The TV crew stuck cameras in their faces as they cried together, and the microphones caught Pete saying, "I wish your mama was here." Nick Madden stood next to them. When Pete released Billie Jean, Nick hugged him like a boy hugging his grandpa. After he signed his scorecard, Pete accepted a check for $1.35 million and the silver trophy then stepped to a microphone set up on the green.

"I dreamed of this day for twenty-six years out here on tour. And now, for that dream to come true… I just wish my wife could be here." He hefted the trophy high and gazed into the sky. "Dottie Lynn, this is for you."

He put his arm around his daughter. Tears streamed down Billie Jean's face, but Scott couldn't help wondering if some of her tears were for Trey Rawlins.

Holding the U.S. Open trophy aloft, Pete Puckett didn't look like a killer-but a father would kill to protect his child. A twenty-eight-year-old man had seduced his seventeen-year-old daughter. Pete had learned of the affair and had threatened to kill Trey if he didn't stay away from Billie Jean. He had done what any father would do. He had tried to protect his daughter.

Had he killed for his daughter?

The law allowed network TV to show commercials for erectile dysfunction cures and seventeen-year-old children to have sex, but fathers didn't. What would Scott do to a man who lured Boo or Pajamae into sex at seventeen? It frightened him to think what he might do… what he could do. What any man could do. What a father would do. That dark side of a man resided in every father. We suppress it and control it and deny it-but it's always there. Waiting. For when it was needed. When a father needed to be a man… in the worst way a man could be.

Had Trey Rawlins brought out the worst in Pete Puckett?

"Louis, if Mr. Fenney marries Miz Fenney again, Boo'll have her family back together. They won't want a little black girl in the way."

"Mr. Fenney, he adopted you. You ain't no little black girl. You're his girl."

"You think it's okay for a white man to be my daddy? Even if he can't play basketball?"

"I think you're blessed to have any man love you as much as Mr. Fenney does and want to be your daddy. Ain't no color to love."

"But my mama's dead."

"Your mama was gonna die sooner than later, that's just the way it was for her. But you could've ended up with no one instead of Boo and Mr. Fenney."

"I'd still have you."

"That's a fact, but Mr. Fenney, he knows how to be a daddy. I don't."

"But I already had a daddy, so how can Mr. Fenney be my daddy?"

"You already had a daddy?"

"Unh-huh."

"So what'd he look like?"

"I don't know."

"He ever play with you?"

"No."

"Live with you?"

"No."

"Take care of you?"

"No."

"Love you?"

"No."

"Then you ain't never had no daddy, girl. Till Mr. Fenney."

"But he's Boo's daddy. Don't seem right, me taking some of his love from her."

"It don't work that way. A man's love expands to meet the demands."

"Huh?"

"You ain't taking love from Boo, you adding love to Mr. Fenney. His heart is like a tree-it grew bigger for you."

"Huh?"

Louis put his hands on his hips like he did when he got annoyed.

"He's got twice as much love now that you're in his life."

"Oh."

"Pajamae!"

She looked over to Mr. Fenney and Miss Fenney and Boo playing in the surf. Mr. Fenney was waving her over. Louis nudged her.

"Go on over to your father, girl."

What was he doing here?

Had he made a mistake when he agreed to represent Rebecca? He had no doubt there was a good explanation for her fingerprints being on the murder weapon, but there was no good explanation for her using cocaine. How would he explain that to the jury? Juries don't like that kind of evidence in a murder case. They like a clean and sober defendant-and no direct evidence tying the defendant to the crime-in order to acquit. They have to believe beyond all reasonable doubt that the defendant is innocent. An American jury's greatest fear is not convicting an innocent person but acquitting a guilty person. Being ridiculed in the press for abdicating their responsibility-their duty-to put people in prison. Why would the police have arrested her and the D.A. have charged her and the grand jury have indicted her if she weren't guilty? A presumption of guilt burdens every juror's mind when he or she takes a seat in the jury box on the first day of trial-which was now only twenty-nine days away. Would he be able to overcome that presumption and prove his ex-wife innocent? Would he be able to prove that Pete Puckett-or perhaps the Muertos — had killed Trey Rawlins? Or had A. Scott Fenney taken on the biggest lost cause of his career? And sacrificed his career? Again.

He realized he was staring at Rebecca and Boo was standing next to him. He looked down at her. Her eyes went from him to Rebecca and back to him. She grinned.

"Are you having a Cialis moment?"

Two hours later, the sun was low, the girls were inside, Miss Fenney was doing her yoga on the beach, and Carlos had talked Louis into going out on the surfboards.

"Miss Fenney, she's a fine-looking woman. And flexible."

"Don't go there, Carlos."

They had paddled out-way out. Louis and Carlos were bobbing on surfboards in the Gulf of Mexico, Carlos looking like he should be the lifeguard at a maximum security prison pool with his black hair slicked back, his dark sunglasses, his tattoos on his muscular arms-and Louis feeling scared. He gazed around at the sea of brown water that surrounded him. It was vast and it was deep and it was filled with creatures that belonged in the water-unlike him. He was a three-hundred-thirty-pound black man who belonged on dry land.

"Louis, you think you ever gonna be a daddy?"

"I hope so. You?"

"Hell, I might already be one. We got machismo, we don't need no Viagra or Cialis."

"Figure you'll get married and have a normal family, like Mr. Fenney?"

Carlos laughed. "Normal?" He waved a hand at the beach. "Ain't nothing normal going on over there, the boss defending his ex-wife. That's abnormal. And no, I don't figure either one of us is ever gonna get married."

"You're handsome."

"Why, thank you, Louis, you're kind of cute yourself… in a big way."

"Why not? We're good men-a few priors maybe, but no violent crimes."

"No convictions."

"I stand corrected."

" 'Cause women, Louis, they don't want good men, they want rich men. And I don't figure on ever being rich. Hence, I ain't never gonna have a wife."

" Hence? "

"I heard the boss say it. Sounds good."

Louis nodded. "It does. So you're saying we're gonna be alone all our lives?"

" 'Fraid so, bro."

"Damn."

"But think of the bright side."

"What's that?"

"You ever get a chance to cheat with a fine-looking woman like Miss Fenney, you can cheat without getting caught."

"But it ain't cheating if you don't have a wife."

"Exactly my point."

"Your point don't make no sense."

"My point is, you'll always be a free man."

"And alone."

"That, too."

"You done with your point?"

"Yep."

"Okay. Now that you got me out here, what the hell am I supposed to do?"

"Wait for a good wave, then lie down and paddle like the devil himself is after your ass. Once we get going, we just stand up on the board and ride that mother all the way to shore."

"Just like that?"

"Yep."

"What if we fall off? Figure that could kill us?"

Carlos laughed. "Hell, Louis, it ain't falling off that's gonna kill you-it's the sharks eating you."