The Medieval Murderers - Sword of Shame

‘And what time did you leave Milk Lane-and when did you arrive at the castle, eh?’

‘How the hell would I know? I don’t carry a graduated church candle about with me! The cathedral is the only place that knows the time in this city. It was all before the Matins bell, that’s for sure.’

John was getting increasingly angry with his brother-in-law. ‘These questions are futile, Richard! As my officer says, who can tell the time except by guesswork? It is either night or day and apart from that, the cathedral bells are the only measure we have. Unless you have some better evidence than this, I suggest we all go home!’

De Revelle smirked and preened himself by throwing one edge of his furred cloak over a shoulder to reveal his fine embroidered tunic.

‘At this so-called inquest you held today, you admitted to the jury that the mortal injuries suffered by the victim could have been caused by a sword. Is that not correct, John?’

‘Of course, it is possible,’ agreed John, suspiciously. ‘But they could equally well have been made by a dagger, a large carving knife or even a reaping hook.’

‘But your servant there habitually carries a sword,’ continued de Revelle suavely. ‘In fact, I understand that he has just acquired a new one.’ He turned and snapped his fingers at the gaoler, who waddled to a nearby table and brought across Gwyn’s weapon, resplendent in its handsome scabbard.

‘This is the one, is it not? It was taken from the dwelling in Milk Street when I had him arrested.’

Gwyn stared blankly at the sword, then at the sheriff, who stood with a smugly satisfied expression on his narrow face. ‘Yes, that’s mine! What of it?’

De Wolfe took a step forward and snatched it from Stigand’s hands. He partly withdrew the blade to satisfy himself by the Latin inscription that it was indeed the weapon that he had purchased for his officer.

‘So what significance has this, Sheriff?’ he demanded. ‘Would you like to see my sword as well?’ he added sarcastically. ‘And those of the hundreds of men in Exeter who carry one?’

‘I have no interest in other men’s swords, John,’ retorted Richard smoothly. ‘Only the one belonging to the man who had the best motive and the opportunity to kill Walter Tyrell.’

He stepped across to de Wolfe and withdrew the blade completely from its sheath. Waving it gently about, he spoke again to the mystified Gwyn. ‘This weapon came into your possession only within the last couple of days-and before that, did it not lay for some time with Roger Trudogge, a well-known armourer of this city?’

Gwyn grudgingly grunted his agreement, still unclear as to where all this was leading.

‘And no doubt, that good armourer would have cleaned and polished the sword, to increase his chances of selling it?’

Again Gwyn could not deny that that was probable and watched with a furrowed brow as Richard de Revelle pulled out a handkerchief of fine white cambric from the sleeve of his tunic. Stigand had obviously been primed beforehand, as he held out a small leather bucket of moderately clean rain-water. The sheriff dipped his kerchief into it, then squeezed the water from it, so that it remained damp.

‘So as that armourer had thoroughly cleaned this blade, anything found upon it must have got there since you took possession?’

De Revelle obviously expected no answer to his question, as he began busily running the folded linen down the full length of the blade, taking particular care to press it along edges of the central rib and into the indentations of the inscriptions. Handing the sword back to Stigand, he opened out the handkerchief and with a flourish, displayed it to the curious onlookers.

With a scream, Christina Tyrell staggered against her brother-in-law, who grabbed her to prevent her falling.

‘My husband’s blood!’ she screeched dramatically, conveniently forgetting that she had gazed unmoved at the far worse sight of his mutilated body during the inquest.

The sheriff triumphantly waved the pink-stained cloth at de Wolfe. ‘Can anyone now doubt that this lethal weapon has been used to slash flesh and draw blood since it was purchased?’ he brayed. ‘I now charge that man, Gwyn of Polruan, with the murder of Walter Tyrell. Take him away and see that he is brought before me at the Shire Court next week!’

There was confusion in the undercroft for several minutes, as Gwyn struggled against the four soldiers who closed in on him. The widow continued to wail and sob, the dead man’s brother began shouting abuse at the suspect and the sheriff hurried away, a satisfied leer on his face.

Only John de Wolfe remained ominously calm, as he picked a small object from the edge of the slot in Gwyn’s scabbard and carefully placed it in the pouch on his belt.

‘It was a damned set-up, that’s what it was!’ snarled John, thumping the table with his fist. He was back in the Bush again that afternoon, with Nesta and Thomas, but instead of the usual Gwyn, Sergeant Gabriel was sitting in his place.

‘So how did that blood get on the blade, master?’ quavered Thomas. ‘As the sheriff said, the sword must have been well-cleaned by that armourer, before he offered it for sale.’

De Wolfe fished in the pouch on his belt and pulled out a small wisp of something, which he carefully laid on the boards of the trestle. He placed the edge of his ale-mug on it, to stop it being blown away.

‘I picked that from the top edge of the scabbard,’ he explained. ‘It was stuck by a little blob of dried blood to the slot where the blade enters.’

Nesta peered at it closely. ‘It’s a tiny feather! From a red chicken, by the looks of it.’ John nodded, a grim expression on his face. ‘Faked evidence! After Gwyn’s sword was snatched from the house in Milk Lane when they arrested him, either de Revelle, or more likely someone acting for him, quickly smeared some blood from a dead fowl on the blade and let it dry.’

Thomas nodded his understanding ‘Of course! Why else would the sheriff even think of rubbing the blade with his handkerchief, unless he already knew that he could discover some blood?’

‘How can he be allowed to get away with it?’ hissed Nesta, livid with anger at this plot against one of her best friends.

De Wolfe shrugged helplessly. ‘He represents the king! In Devon, there’s no one who can dispute his authority.’

‘Can’t you appeal to someone over de Revelle’s head?’ she asked.

‘It would take too long, my love!’ he replied bitterly. ‘It would take a couple of weeks to get a response from the Chief Justiciar in Winchester, even assuming he was there and not in London-or even visiting the king in Normandy.’

The grizzled sergeant nodded. ‘The bloody sheriff will have Gwyn convicted and hanged before then, for that’s what he wants.’

‘Can the bishop do nothing?’ persisted Nesta, her face pale with anxiety. ‘Surely he wouldn’t want an innocent man executed?’

John gave a harsh, cynical laugh. ‘Henry Marshal? He’s almost as bad as de Revelle. A secret supporter of Prince John’s treachery-he wouldn’t lift a finger to help.’

Thomas surreptitiously crossed himself at this defamation of the leader of the Church in Devon and Cornwall, though privately he knew it was true. ‘Is there nothing we can do?’ he wailed. ‘We can’t let Gwyn go to the gallows next week.’

‘He’s being kept in the city gaol in the South Gate,’ muttered Gabriel. ‘The cells in Rougemont are full until the next hanging day.’

The substantial towers that flanked the southern entrance to the city were used to house prisoners remanded by the burgess’s court of the city, as well as for some sent there by the sheriff’s County Court. It was a foul, cramped dungeon and like most gaols, many of the inmates in there died from disease or being killed by other prisoners, before they ever came to trial.