Tamar Myers: Butter Safe Than Sorry

The henhouse exit is a simple wooden trapdoor that blends in nicely with the floor, and under a layer of straw is virtually unnoticeable. Thus it was that when I finally flung open the door and hoisted myself up into the broad light of day, I caused quite a bit of commotion.

For one thing, the hens that had been skulking about, waiting for a chance to lay their eggs, became highly emotional. That is to say, each clucking chicken had been instantly transformed into a five-pound ball of airborne feathers and earsplitting cackles. Then there was the not so small matter of Peewee Timms and Barbie Nyle, who had unwisely chosen the henhouse as the location for their romantic rendezvous-No, I take that back. This was adultery, pure and simple.

What a disappointment that was! Barbie had always treated me nicely, and although I don’t know why, I’d had this feeling that maybe Peewee was secretly Jewish. Well, Peewee, although aptly named, was certainly not Jewish. Still, who was I to judge, and why should I even entertain the idea? After all, the zillion mites and fleas resident in my henhouse were going to do the judging for me, although most of the misery would come a little later, once Barbie and Peewee started scratching.

Of course I was shocked to discover two naked people fornicating amidst bits of straw and chicken poo, but I was nowhere near as shocked as they were to see me suddenly rising from the floor, covered as I was in slime and squashed spiders. They were literally breathless for a spell, and frozen with fear, and when they did react, the first sounds they made eerily resembled chicken squawks. Fortunately by then I had exited the well-built shed, slammed the hasp into its place, and closed the Yale lock on their sinfulness.

Now to catch the evil Melvin-although I had a sinking feeling he’d already gotten away by car. I started running and was halfway to the parking area in front of my barn, just passing under the old swing tree, when George Nyle appeared out of nowhere. Well, to be fair to myself, George did have mousy brown hair, a mousy brown mustache, and a deep tan, and he was wearing a khaki safari suit-even a Maasai could have walked right past without noticing him.

“Hey,” George said, “where are you going so fast?” He sounded positively genial, but then again, he might have been putting on act. After all, I had become Alice in Wonderland; nothing was as it should have been. Until I figured out just how much he knew about what I knew, I’d best play along as though everything were normal.

“It’s been a long day,” I said, “and I still have miles to go before I sleep.”

“Ah, a fellow lover of poetry.”

“Not especially-unless you’re talking about the Song of Solomon. Now that’s poetry. ‘Thy hair is like a flock of goats, going down from Mount Gilead. Your teeth are like a flock of shorn sheep which have come up for the washing.’ No modern poet could touch lines like that with a ten-foot pole.”

“And I wouldn’t want to touch a girl like that with a ten-foot pole. Where did you say the poem was from?”

“The Bible.”

“It figures. Look, Miss Yoder, I don’t mean to be rude, but you’re not exactly touchable at the moment, either. Where the heck have you been?”

“Well-you see-one might say I look like a sewer rat.”

“That’s not what I asked.”

Uh-oh, his tone was a lot nastier than I’d hoped for. If I didn’t think fast on my size elevens, I might well perish whilst covered in a shroud composed of squished arachnids. It would not be a pretty way to go. Personally, I was hoping to hold out until the Second Coming, because I have never been a big fan of pain. Just about every day I give thanks that when I gave birth to Little Jacob, I practically shot him out like a cannonball. Of course, it hurt like St. Louis International Airport, Terminal A, while it was happening…

“Miss Yoder! This is no longer a game! How did you get out of the cellar?”

Aha! So he was in on it. Indeed, just like Melvin said, they all were.

I pointed to the upper branches of the tree behind him. “Is that an owl up there? They usually come out about this time of day.”

Surely a question, no matter how misleading, cannot be a lie. And even though I didn’t see an owl, there might have been one up there somewhere, hidden by the foliage, and it was true that they did come out about that time, which was about an hour before sunset.

“Where?” he asked, and foolishly turned.

That was when I grabbed the old wooden swing and swung it practically as high as it could go. Yes, it was a dangerous weapon in my hands, and it was a violent act that I performed, but I have since repented of this. In my defense-Well, I really have none, do I? My ancestors submitted to being scalped, rather than killing the Delaware with their muskets when they had the chance.

To sum it up, I may have been a poor pacifist, but I was an excellent markswoman. The wooden seat caught George just above the nape of the neck and gave him a nasty concussion. He survived, but for a long time-something like six months-he thought Peewee was his mother and Barbie was his sister. Frankly, it was just as well.

With four down, there were still two more to go, and that didn’t include the mysterious Surimanda Baikal. One can imagine my astonishment, followed by enormous relief, when I beheld one of the rental cars from New Jersey idling empty in the parking area in front of the barn. It was if the Lord had sent an angel down to start it for me. After all, my car keys were in my purse, which was still in the house, and the Good Lord only knew who was still in there.

I gaped at the idling vehicle for a few precious seconds. It should not have amazed me, and in that regard I was a faithless woman. After all, I was on side of Good, battling Evil in the guise of a spindly man with an ill- fitting head and bulging eyes that could rotate 360 degrees. Since Heaven had sent me a chariot-a horseless carriage, if you will-I should have immediately credited it to the Man Upstairs and given thanks.

But give thanks I eventually did, and then as the Good Lord expected of me, I took action. However, as I tried to climb into the driver’s seat of the monstrous black SUV, I was met with a great deal of unexpected resistance.

“Put your hands up, Yoder, and get in the back.”

“Mantis-I mean Chameleon-I mean Melvin! Where did you come from?”

“I’ve been sitting here the whole time, Yoder-slouched, of course.”

“And you didn’t see me either,” the craggy Carl Zambezi said, “although I was barely slumped.”

“Right. Well shame on me for not seeing either of you!”

“What’s the matter, Yoder? You going blind in your old age?”

“Au contraire, I have fifty-fifty vision. I see the half of the world that is good and kind and nourishes my soul, and the scum-sucking evil elements-like you-I just naturally overlook.”

“Now that was hurtful, Yoder,” Melvin said.

“Yeah, we watched you kill George Nyle,” Carl Zambezi said.

My heart leapt into my throat. As hard and small as my heart is, there’s always the danger that I’ll accidentally disgorge it, perhaps during a phlegm-producing cough. I shudder to think of the consequences. Besides the obvious physical difficulties this would present, what about the emotional and theological ramifications? For instance, it would put a whole new spin on Valentine’s Day-

“Yoder, are you in even in there?” Melvin barked.

“Of course, I am; and shame on you, because you should know by now that I engage in rather lengthy inner dialogues. That’s what makes me so interesting-at least to myself. And I didn’t kill George Nyle. I mean that if I did, it certainly wasn’t intentional. Shall I go back and see?” For the record, I still hadn’t as much as stuck one foot up into the SUV.