Scott Turow - Presumed innocent

I still have the envelope in my hands.

"So what do we have here?" I ask.

"Path report. Three-sheet. Bunch of pictures of a naked dead lady." The three-sheet is the prosecutor's copy of the arriving officers' reports-he third leaf in the carbon layers. I have talked to these cops directly. I go on to the report of the police pathologist, Dr. Kumagai, a weird-looking little Japanese who seems to have come out of a forties propaganda piece. He is known as Painless, a notorious hack. No prosecutor calls him to the witness stand without crossing his fingers.

"And what's the scoop? Male fluids in every hole?"

"Just the main one. Lady is dead of a skull fracture and resulting hemorrhage. Pictures might make you think she was strangled, but Painless says there was air in her lungs. Anyway, the guy musta hit her with somethin. Painless has got no idea what. Heavy, he says. And real hard."

"I take it we looked for a murder weapon in the apartment?"

"Turned the place upside down."

"Anything obvious missing? Candlesticks? Bookends?"

"Nothin. I sent three separate teams through."

"So," I say, "our man showed up already thinking he'd be doing some heavy hitting."

"Could be. Or else he just took what he used with him. I'm not positive this guy came prepared. Seems like he was hittin to subdue her-didn't realize he cooled her. I figure-you can see when you look at the pictures-that the way the ropes were tied, that he put himself between her legs and was tryin to let his weight strangle her. It's all slip-knotted. I mean," Lipranzer says, "that he was sort of tryin to fuck her to death."

"Charming," I say.

"Definitely charming," says lip. "This was a very charming type fellow." We are both quiet a moment before he goes on. "We got no bruises on the arms, hands, nothin like that," Up says. That would mean there was no struggle before Carolyn was bound. "Contusion's rear right. It's got to be that he hit her from behind, then tied her up. Only it seems strange that he would knock her cold to start with. Most of these creeps like em to know what they're doin."

I shrug. I'm not so sure of that.

The photos are the first thing I take out of the envelope. They are clean, full-colored shots. Carolyn lived in a place on the waterfront, a former warehouse parceled into "loft condominiums." She had divided the space with Chinese screens and heavy rugs. Her taste ran to the modern, with elegant touches of classical and antique. She had been killed in the space off the kitchen which she used as a living room. An overall shot of that area is first on the stack. The thick green-edged glass top of a coffee table has been tumbled off its brass props; a modular seating piece is upside down. But overall I agree with Lip that there is less sign of struggle than I have seen on other occasions, particularly if you ignore the bloodstain worked into the fiber of the flokati rug so that it has the shape of a large soft cloud. I look up. I do not feel I am ready yet to take on the photos of the corpse.

"What else does Painless tell us?" I ask.

"This guy was shootin blanks."

"Blanks?"

"Oh yeah. You'll like this." Lipranzer does his best to repeat Kumagai's analysis of the sperm deposit that was found. Little of it had seeped to the labia, which means that Carolyn could not have spent much time on her feet after sexual contact. This is another way we know that the rape and her death were roughly contemporaneous. On April 1, she had left the office a little after seven. Kumagai puts the time of death at somewhere around nine.

"That's twelve hours before the body's found," Lip says. "Painless says normally, with that kinda time span, he'd still see some of the guy's little thingies swimmin upstream in the tubes and in the womb, when he looked under the microscope. Instead, this guy's wad's all dead. Nothin went nowhere. Painless figures this guy is sterile." Lip pronounces the word so that it rhymes with pearl. "Says you can get like that from mumps."

"So we're looking for a rapist who has no children and once had the mumps?"

Lipranzer shrugs.

"Painless says he's gonna take the semen specimen and send it over to the forensic chemist. Maybe they can give him another idea of what's up." I groan a little bit at the thought of Painless exploring the realms of higher chemistry.

"Can't we get a decent pathologist?" I ask.

"You got Painless," Lip says innocently.

I groan again, and leaf through a few more pages of Kumagai's report. "Do we have a secreter?" I ask. People are divided not merely by blood type but by whether they secrete identifying agents into their body fluids.

Lip takes the report from me. "Yep."

"Blood type?"

"Ah," I say, "my very own."

"I thoughta that," says Lip, "but you got a kid."

I again comment on Lipranzer's sentimentality. He does not bother to respond. Instead, he lights another cigarette and shakes his head. I'm just not grabbin it yet," he says. "The whole goddamn deal is too weird. We're missin somethin."

So we begin again, the investigators' favorite parlor game, who and why. Lipranzer's number-one suspicion from the start has been that Carolyn was killed by someone she convicted. That is every prosecutor's worst fantasy, the long-nurtured vengeance of some dip you sent away. Shortly after I was first assigned to the jury trial section, a youth, as the papers would have it, by the name of Pancho Mercado, took exception to my closing argument, in which I had questioned the manliness of anyone who made his living by pistol-whipping seventy-seven year-old men. Six foot four and well over 250 pounds, Pancho leaped the dock and thundered behind me through most of the courthouse before he was stopped cold in the P.A.'s lunchroom by MacDougall, wheelchair and all. The whole thing ended up on page 3 of the Tribune, with a grotesque headline: PANICKED PROSECUTOR SAVED BY CRIPPLE. Something like that. Barbara, my wife, likes to refer to this as my first famous case. Carolyn worked on stranger types than Pancho. For several years she had headed what is called the office's Rape Section. The name gives a good idea of what is involved, although all forms of sexual assault tend to be prosecuted there, including child abuse, and one case I can recall where an all-male menage-a-trois had turned rough and the state's main witness had ended the evening with a light bulb up his rectum. It is Lipranzer's hypothesis, at moments, that one of the rapists Carolyn prosecuted got even.

Accordingly, we agree to go over Carolyn's docket to see if there was anybody she tried-or investigated-for a crime resembling what took place three nights ago. I promise to look through the records in Carolyn's office. The state investigative agencies also maintain a computer run of sexual offenders, and Lip will see if we can cross-match there on Carolyn's name, or the stunt with the ropes.

"What kind of leads are we running?"

Lipranzer begins to tick it off for me. The neighbors were all seen in the day following the murder, but those interviews were probably hasty and Lip will arrange for homicide investigators to make another pass at everyone in a square block. This time they'll do it in the evening, so that the neighbors who are home at the hour when the murder took place will be in. "One lady says she saw a guy in a raincoat on the stairs." Lip looks at his notebook. "Mrs. Krapotnik. Says maybe he looked familiar, but she doesn't think he lives there."

"The Hair and Fiber guys went through first, right?" I ask. "When do we hear from them?" To these people falls the grotesque duty of vacuuming the corpse, picking over the crime scene with tweezers, in order to make microscopic examinations of any trace materials they discover. Often they can type hair, identify an offender's clothing.