A. Rich - The Hand That Feeds You

“I even looked for a reason in books. A Grief Observed , by C. S. Lewis — he wrote it after his wife died, but it was about his loss of faith in God as much as his grief at losing his wife.”

I told him what I knew about C. S. Lewis when he was a boy, how when he was four, his dog, Jack, was killed by a car. The future author would only answer to the name of Jack after that, and even as an old man his closest friends and family called him Jack. I hoped McKenzie did not think I was equating a boy’s loss of his pet dog to a man’s losing his wife. Then I saw that I didn’t have to worry about that.

McKenzie laughed. “Finally, a reason to like C. S. Lewis.”

“Could you eat something? Do you have time? If I ordered macaroni and cheese, would you share it?”

“I’d love to, but I have to be somewhere at seven.”

I glanced at his watch and saw that we had about fifteen more minutes. I thought he might be going to meet Billie, but I wouldn’t ask. Instead I said, “So C. S. Lewis didn’t help, but did you find someone who did? Either on or off the page?”

“I don’t know that this helped, but soon after, I was trying a case in which an elementary school in Connecticut would not allow a ten-year-old girl with cerebral palsy to bring her helper monkey, a little capuchin, to school with her. The monkey was perfectly behaved, wore a diaper so as not to soil anything in the classroom, and was pretty much a model citizen. The girl needed this helper monkey’s assistance in fundamental ways. The other parents and the school board were afraid of diseases they thought the monkey carried, though there was no evidence of this, and the monkey was up-to-date on its vaccinations.

“Turned out, the girl left me little to do in court. She gave an eloquent description of her life before she got Maddie and then told the court what she was now able to do with Maddie’s essential help. One of the most moving examples was also the simplest. She told the court that before she got Maddie, no one ever talked to her at school. Since she started bringing Maddie, she had become popular. All the kids wanted to meet the little helper monkey. She said, ‘I didn’t feel sorry for myself after that.’ And neither did I.”

“You didn’t feel sorry for the girl, or for yourself?”

“Both.”

The irony was almost too much for me, that McKenzie was opening up to me in ways more intimate than when I thought he might be interested in me. Maybe he felt safe enough to confide in me this way now that he was with someone else. But why did it have to be Billie? And why shouldn’t it be Billie?

McKenzie put on his coat and asked me to call him when I had made my decision about Cloud. In parting, he did not offer his hand. He put his arms around me, and we stood like that for too brief a time.

I stayed at Crown Vic’s and, this time, had no interest in finding a man to waste a night with. I finished my drink and glanced up at the TV above the bar. The news was on, and I could barely hear the reporter over the music. But I recognized the woman whose photo appeared on-screen: Pat. The next photo was of a Hispanic man, identified as a migrant worker on the East End of Long Island. According to police, he had just been arrested for the murder of Pat Loewi. The reporter used what had entered the vernacular and referred to the murder as the “Heartless” case.

I was grateful to be in a place where no one knew me, or what I had been thinking. The anonymity obviated the need to feel embarrassed. All this time I had been sure that Samantha was responsible for Pat’s murder. Now I could choose to believe the police, who, after all, were good at their job. The news felt like an invitation to drop what had become, I saw, an obsession, this certainty of Samantha’s guilt. But why couldn’t a migrant worker have been responsible? I thought back to the Christa Worthington murder on the Cape a few years back. The whole town thought they knew who the killer was, and there was a second suspect, too, but, no — three years later, a sanitation worker named Christopher McCowen was arrested and, a year later, convicted for the murder.

I had been a fool to press detectives to investigate a connection between the murders of Pat and Susan Rorke. I had been a fool to suspect Samantha.

The momentary feeling of relief was supplanted by a dark and damning fact I did not want to face. I had fallen for Jimmy Gordon, a small-time, small-town delinquent who grew up to be the kind of predator I studied; my insider knowledge not only failed to protect me, it had led me straight to the predator, and I fell in love with him!

Etta James was singing “At Last.” I moved one barstool closer to the fireplace and ordered the macaroni and cheese.

I was three months behind on my thesis and hoping that Leland, my adviser at John Jay, would cut me some slack, given the reasons I was late. I had chosen him to work with based on his books, which were not only fascinating, but beautifully written. His were the kind of books I would like to write — if I could not write poetry, I could still write well.

The requisite cartoon taped to his office door was by Gary Larson, in which a psychiatrist facing his patient on the couch has written only one note on his pad: Just plain nuts! — underlined three times.

Leland’s office was a throwback to the sixties — with a lava lamp and dream catchers on the walls. His parents had been hippies before finding a home in academia, he’d told me. He had eschewed their early leanings in favor of a rule-bound academic life. He said he liked to see his mother’s handiwork on his walls. His partner, whom he called by his last name of Emory, had given Leland a large exercise ball, and Leland was trying to stay upright on it instead of sitting in his comfortable desk chair. It was comical and his struggle made me laugh.

“I hope this trend is short-lived,” he said, giving up and returning to his chair.

I took a seat across from his desk and began by apologizing.

He cut me off, saying he was just glad to see me and was sorry about what I’d been through. He had said as much in a note right after Bennett died, but I had not answered any of the large-hearted notes people had sent, even Leland’s.

His kindness set off what I had hoped to keep from him: tears. There was no point in trying to pretend that I was capable and on track; anyone could see I was utterly unglued. Leland told me to take care of myself first. When I asked how much he had heard about Bennett, he said he knew Bennett was an impostor suspected of murder. Leland would support my taking a leave if I needed it. But he made a case for work as a daily practice that could get me through this, even if I only worked an hour a day.

Could I rally for an hour a day given what my days were like? Did I believe in my thesis any longer? “This isn’t end-of-thesis doubt. I’ve been forced to make a profound reevaluation of what I thought I knew. When I started, I thought I could identify a new victim typology. I believed that compassionate women attract a certain type of predator. I thought I had the data. But now that I have been involved with one, where is my objectivity, my credibility?”

“Who better to examine the phenomenon?”

“That’s the thing. The online profile I created that attracted ‘Bennett’ was designed to draw a control group, not a predator.”

“What would you say about a cop who’s been robbed? I’d say maybe he’s going to be a better cop. Look at your whole hand, not just what you thought was your strong suit. You’ll find a new way to interpret the material.”

I told Leland how much I appreciated his understanding and his guidance. When I closed the door behind me, I hoped he had not written in his notebook, Just plain nuts!