Marisha Pessl - Special Topics in Calamity Physics

I nodded and smiled. He drove away.

And yet, as I made my way upstairs to my room, I realized that in my life, if I’d known someone certifiable, it wouldn’t be Hannah Schneider. No, it’d be June Bug Kelsea Stevens whom I caught in Dad’s bathroom having a conversation with herself in the mirror (“You look mar velous. No, you look marvelous. No, you loo — how long have you been standing there?”) or even June Bug Phyllis Mixer who treated her skittish Standard Poodle like a ninety-year-old grandmother (“Up-see-daisies. Good girl. That too much sun for you? No? What would you like for lunch, honey? Oh, you want my sandwich.”). And poor June Bug Vera Strauss, whom Dad and I found out later had been manic for years — looking back, she’d had actual signs of lunacy: her eyes were severely depressed (literally, into her face) and when she talked to you, there was something scary about it, as if she were actually addressing a ghost or some sort of poltergeist hovering just behind your left shoulder.

No, in spite of mounting evidence to the contrary, I didn’t believe that was the trapdoor out of the maze — that Hannah Schneider was simply nutty as a fruitcake. Any professor worth his salt would throw out that sort of essay, if some kid dared to turn in such an ill-considered, hackneyed Thesis. No, I’d read The Return of the Witness (Hastings, 1974) and its sequel and I’d watched Hannah; I’d seen how she’d marched so assuredly up that trail (there’d been a discernible jaunt in her step) and she’d shouted off that mountaintop with conviction, not despair (there were vast differences in a voice’s timbre between those emotions).

There had to be another reason.

In my room, I threw down my backpack and removed the materials I’d filched from Hannah’s house from the front of my dress and my shoe. I hadn’t wanted Milton to know I was swiping things. I’d started to feel more than a little embarrassed by the way my mind was working. He’d said, “Look who’s sleuthin’,” “Olives’ got her sleuth on,” “That’s so sleuthy, baby,” six times and it’d sounded less and less cute the more he said it, and so, when we climbed into his Nissan I’d said I’d left my birthstone necklace on the bureau in Hannah’s garage (I didn’t have, nor had I ever had, a birthstone necklace) and while he waited, I ran inside and grabbed those materials I’d already set aside in the cardboard box in the back corner. I shoved the thin folder of Missing Person articles down my dress so it was pressed around my waist, put the photograph of Hannah with the spiky rockstar hair into my shoe, and when I climbed back into the car and he said, “Got it?” I grinned, pretending to zip it into the front pocket of my backpack. (He wasn’t the most perceptive person; I sat stiffly the entire ride home as if perched on pinecones and he didn’t bat an eye.)

Now, I switched on the bedside lamp and opened the manila folder.

The shock with which the revelation came to me wasn’t because the idea was particularly intricate or inspired, but because it was so excitingly obvious , I hated myself for not considering it sooner. I read the newspaper articles first (Hannah appeared to have gone to a library and photocopied them from grainy microfiche): two from The Stockton Observer dated September 19, 1990, and June 2, 1979, “Search for Missing Backpacker Underway,” “Roseville Girl, 11, Found Unhurt,” respectively; another from The Knoxville Press , “Missing Girl Reunited with Father, Mother Charged” one from Tennessee’s Pineville Herald-Times , “Missing Boy Prostituted” and finally “Missing Woman Found in VT, Using Alias,” from The Huntley Sentinel .

I then read the last page, the book excerpt, which concluded the story of Violet May Martinez, the day she disappeared from the Great Smoky Mountains on August 29, 1985.

97.

the group was one person short. Violet was nowhere to be found.

Mike Higgis searched the parking lot and questioned strangers who’d parked there, but no one had seen her. After an hour, he contacted the National Park Service. The Park immediately launched a search, closing the area from Blindmans Bald to Burnt Creek. Violet’s father and sister were notified and they brought Violet’s clothes so the search dogs could identify her smell.

Three German Shepherds tracked Violet to a single spot by a paved road, 1.25 miles from the last place Violet was seen. The road led to U.S. 441 leading out of the Park.

Ranger Bruel told Violet’s father, Roy Jr., that could mean Violet made her way there and was picked up by someone in a vehicle. She also could have been abducted against her will.

Roy Jr. rejected the idea Violet had planned her disappearance. She did not have a credit card or identification with her. She had taken no money from her checking or savings accounts prior to the trip. She was also looking forward to her 16th birthday the following week at Roller-Skate America.

Roy Jr. tipped the police off to a potential suspect. Kenny Franks, 24, released January 1985 from a correctional institution for violence and theft, had seen Violet at the mall and become infatuated. He’d been spotted at Besters High and harassed Violet with phone calls. Roy Jr. contacted the police and Kenny left her alone, though his friends reported he still was obsessed with her.

“Violet said she hated him, but she still wore the necklace he gave her,” said her best friend Polly Elms.

Police investigated the possibility of Kenny Franks having a hand in her disappearance, but sources testified on Aug. 25 he’d been working all day as a busboy at Stagg Mill Bar & Grill and was cleared of suspicion. Three weeks later he moved to Myrtle Beach, S.C. Police investigated if he was in contact with Violet, but no evidence to support this claim ever emerged.

A Final Enigma

The search for Violet ended September 14, 1985. With 812 searchers, including Park Personnel, Rangers, the National Guard and FBI, no further leads in her disappearance came to light.

On October 21, 1985, at Jonesville Nations Bank in Jonesville, Florida, a black-haired woman tried to cash a check from Violet’s checking account, made payable to “Trixie Peanuts.” When the teller informed the woman she’d have to deposit the check and wait for it to clear, the woman left with it and never returned. The bank teller, when presented with a picture of Violet, was unable to confirm it was she. The woman was never seen in Jonesville again.

Roy Jr. swore his daughter would never have cause to disappear from her life. Her friend Polly thought otherwise.

“She was always talking about how much she hated Besters and hated being a Baptist. She got good grades so I think she could plan it so people thought she was dead. That way they’d stop looking for her and she’d never have to come back.”

Seven years later, Roy Jr. still thinks of Violet every day.

“I put it with God now. ‘Trust in the Lord with all your heart,’” he quotes from Proverbs 3:5, 6, “‘and lean not on your own understanding.’”

All of the articles in the folder were not merely concerning Missing Persons, but disappearances that had appeared to have been staged — definitively, in the case of the Huntley Sentinel article, which detailed the vanishing of a fifty-two-year-old woman, Ester Sweeney of Huntley, New Mexico, married to her third husband, Milo, and owing over $800,000 in back taxes and credit card bills. Police ultimately concluded she’d ransacked her home, slashed her kitchen screen and her own right arm (her blood was found in the foyer) in order to make it look like a violent break-in. She was found three years later in Winooski, Vermont, living under an assumed name and married to her fourth husband.