John Kellerman: Two Horny Babysitters

Terri wasn't exactly sure of how a boy's cock was shaped. It was funny at the tip, kind of streamlined. Made to go right into a girl's pussy. Terri closed her eyes, seesawed her hips and used her finger on herself as she imagined being hacked.

The sound of her sister going into the bathroom snapped Terri out of her little fantasy. She took a breath, slipped from the closet and hurried down the hail. She was on her way to her bedroom to strip off her panties and play with herself some more when she heard her mother calling from downstairs.

Frustrated for the moment, Terri slipped into a pair of shorts and padded down to see what her mother wanted. She found her pacing the kitchen floor, a freshly opened letter in her hand.

"It's your Aunt Beth," Terri's mother said. "She's trying to run that damned motel by herself again. That no-account man of hers took off and left her right in the middle of the busiest season.

"What are you going to do?" Terri asked. She'd been through this scene before and was a little bored with her aunt and her recurring problems.

"I suppose I'll have to take Arlene and drive up for the rest of the week to help out. It's the least I can do."

"Arlene's supposed to babysit tonight," Terri put in.

"She just won't be able to. I'll tell her to get one of her friends."

Terri almost suggested that she could take over for her big sister. She'd been wanting to make some extra money babysitting for some time. Her mother thought she was still too young to watch over very young children. Lots of her friends had babysitting jobs, but Terri's mother wouldn't give an inch. So Terri kept her mouth shut. Instead she started upstairs and headed down the hall to Arlene's room.

"Arlene, I've got to ask you something…

Fifteen minutes later, it was decided. Since Arlene was going to have to drive up to Big Creek with her mother and wouldn't be able to babysit for the Carltons, Terri would take her place. Terri also had the responsibility of calling Tommy and telling him not to bother showing up at the Carltons' since Arlene wasn't going to be there.

"He's on his way to work by now," Arlene said, looking glum. "Oh, I hate going up to Big Creek. Why does Aunt Beth always come apart once every three months? Why?"

Secretly, Terri was happy at her chance for more responsibility. There was a record she'd been dying to buy and now she'd have the cash to get it. She was so excited by all this that she nearly forgot her previous intentions.

Hurrying to her room, she stripped off all her clothing and took a long slow walk before her mirror, her hands cupped under her small, firm tits.

"They're not nearly as big as Arlene's, but they jiggle when I walk." Terri turned to catch her profile. Arching her back sharply with her legs straight, she poked her trim ass out as far as it would go and pouted. She had long brown hair that came halfway to her waist. Her arms and legs were willowy but with subtle curves that would soon become more defined. Where she'd fingered herself while hiding in Arlene's closet, her sparse brown cunt curls were plastered against her white skin.

Throwing herself onto her bed, Terri got in the same position as Arlene had been in and rubbed herself in exactly the same way. Her finger went into her pussy easier this time. Yet, she knew she still wasn't completely opened up down there. She wished she could know what it was like to be fucked!

"Arlene knows," she whispered. "I'll just bet she does."

Terri got off the bed and rummaged lay her closet. In a rusty box in the back, she searched among the torn comics and forgotten toys. And there it was, just as she'd remembered. The rubber arm of a doll, long ago pulled from its owner. It was about five inches long and an inch and a half in diameter. The fingers were balled into a fist, the arm bent slightly at the elbow.

"A real one looks kind of like this, I think," Terri whispered, her cunt already getting juicy with anticipation. "Yeah, I know a real one has got a knob at the tip."

As her fingers traced the shape of the doll's arm, Terri returned to her bed. She rummaged through a drawer and found the bottle of baby oil she had there. Sprinkling a good amount into her palm, she smoothed the lubrication up and down the doll's arm. It glistened brightly now and Terri's breathing had grown rapid and a bit shallow.

"Oh, wow! I wonder how this'll be?"

On her back again, knees bent sharply back and pushed apart, Terri held the well-oiled object in her fingers and rubbed it slowly against her pussy. In her mind, she made the arm become a cock. It was attached to a man. The man wanted to fuck her. She dragged a couple of pillows over, hugged one to her belly, and squeezed the other between her thighs.

"Ohhh, fuck me!" she moaned, thrusting her ass up and down.

Gingerly, she found the opening of her cunt and pressed the balled rubber fist against the oily lips. Her cuntlips parted and her muscles did too. There was another sting as the rest of her cherry gave. A trickle of hot blood on her ass cheek frightened Terri for a moment, but she recovered and bit her lower lip as she forced the head of the makeshift cock into her pussy. She was trembling so hard that she had to stop.

Looking sideways into the mirror, Terri saw herself, the pink, rubber thing jutting from her cunt. It was tightly squeezed inside the circle of muscles that was the beginning of her pussy. A smear of blood could be seen halfway up the rubber doll's arm.

"God, that feels weird! But nice!"

Grabbing her rubber cock again, Terri eased it deeper. There was no pain at all now, and as the shape went deeper into her cunt, a tingling pleasure spread. She began to pull it back, shove it in, in and out, faster… faster!

"Ohhh, ohhhhh, shit, that's neat!"

The rubber cock made a squishy sound as she fucked herself with it. She was too excited for a while to, notice that she had almost half of it inside her cunt now. She kept forcing it in until her fingers touched the juicy softness of her cuntlips and she realized that her cunt had taken five inches of firm rubber.

Rolling her hips, Terri pretended she was really getting it now! Her cunt had stretched quite a bit since she'd begun this thrilling operation. She'd gotten tired of always having her cherry there to stop her fun. This was more like the real thing would be like, she told herself.

"Uhhh, ohhhh, ahhhhh, it's really nice and big!"

Terri wasn't sure exactly how big a male cock was. It couldn't be much bigger than the doll's arm though or it wouldn't fit in a girl. She rolled her hips and pumped up and down while forcing the last inch of the slick rubber arm into her pussy.

"Whhhhaaaaah," she gasped, experiencing thrills she'd never known before this moment. To have something hard inside her was totally new. Terri wondered how she'd gotten along without this new fun for so long.

"Nnnnnnuuhh, yuuuhhhh," she panted, pumping faster, her toes fanning apart against the bed sheet. The slippery, fucking sound was very loud now. Her pussy seemed to be sucking at the rubber cock. The rubber shaft was smeared with her pussy juice and blood. Now that it was deeper inside her, she could feel the bend in the rubber elbow too. It was so exciting that Terri could hardly stand it.

"Nhhuuh, yuhhhhhh," she breathed, her eyes fluttering, her bottom lip clenched firmly between her teeth. Her nipples had gotten very hard and hot. As she rubbed a palm across them, new excitement flared through her belly and down her thighs. She writhed frantically, one hand working the rubber doll's arm, her other hand squeezing her tit.

"Wow, I'm gonna come! Ohhh, it's gonna be good, it's really g-g-gonna be good!"

Terri's heels drummed the bed. Her head tossed wildly, just like Arlene's had. Her tummy heaved up and down as she forced the last nub of the rubber make believe cock into her cunt. Pumping up and down with her hips, she squeezed the pillow against her body, pretending she was getting fucked by a real man. Her tumbling fantasies needed more than just a man. Terri wanted to pretend it was somebody she knew.