Rick Mofina - Perfect Grave

“Then the others came,” Florence said. “Someone called 9-1-1. Most all of the sisters have some sort of medical training. They checked for signs of life but we all knew that Sister Anne was dead. We were kneeling in her blood. So much blood. We took her hands and prayed over her. We didn’t stop, even as we heard the sirens, even as the officers and paramedics thudded up the stairs with their radios going, we didn’t stop praying.” Sister Florence pressed her white-knuckled fists to her mouth. “We’ll never stop praying for her.”

As the tears flowed down her cheeks, her pain clawed at Grace and she was suddenly overwhelmed. Sister Anne had lived a holy life, had devoted herself to helping those who were often beyond it. How could Grace Garner, a pathetically lonely self-doubting cop, on a losing streak, actually believe that she was skilled enough to find her killer? Grace’s secret fear burned in her gut as she glanced to the votive candles, the flames quivering with the tiny light of hope.

“Sister, what prayers did you say when you found her?”

“The Twenty-third Psalm.”

The Lord is my shepherd.

“That’s a beautiful prayer,” Grace said as a soft knock sounded at the door and a uniformed officer stuck his head into the chapel.

“My apologies for interrupting, Detective Garner, but they need you outside now. They’ve got something.”

S teel glinted in the beam of the police officer’s flashlight.

The officer was in the alley behind the town house with Kay Cataldo, a crime-scene investigator. They were crouched over a blackberry shrub next to a length of worn picket fence and the rusting frame of a bicycle. A second officer was taping off the area as Grace Garner approached.

“Where’s the safe way in?” She didn’t want to contaminate the scene.

“Close to the fence,” Cataldo said.

“What do we have?”

“Officer Ryan Danko here’s got the eyes of a hawk.”

With great care, Cataldo spread the shrub’s leaves, revealing a kitchen steak knife. It had a wooden handle and a six-inch serrated blade. Close inspection showed tiny reddish-brown flecks in some areas.

“This our weapon?”

“It’s a candidate.” Cataldo, aided by Danko, concentrated on taking photographs, measurements, and notes. “We’ll type it against the victim. We’ll process this knife, see if it matches anything the nuns use or if anything’s missing from any drawers in there.”

“What about foot impressions?”

“Got a partial inside and we’ll use it when we cast around here.”

“All right, and we better put the word out to watch for every tossed cigarette butt in the area.”

“Our guy’s a smoker?” Danko said.

“Just a hunch. Good work, Danko. Thanks, Kay.”

Encouraged by the promise of evidence, Grace stepped aside and called Perelli.

“We may have a weapon. A blade. Serrated, about six inches. Wooden handle.”

“Could be our break.”

“Could be. You talk to the sisters about a volunteer list for the shelter and everyone she had contact with tonight. I’ll follow up next door on the canvass.”

“Sure. And Grace, this thing’s already drawing heat. Reporters are calling in here trying to interview the nuns over the phone.”

“Tell the sisters not to speak to the press, then get downtown to send someone up here to handle that. This is just the beginning.”

Grace saw a news truck creeping down the alley toward the tape as she took stock of the surrounding buildings and windows, assessing lines of sight into the dimly lit area. She shone a penlight on her notes as she updated them and reviewed her sketches and the precanvass done by the responding officers, mining it for witnesses. There wasn’t much to work with from the alley side.

But the front, now, the front was a different story.

In the front she had Bernice Burnett, age seventythree, a widow and retired telephone operator. Lives in the adjacent building, alone with her cats. Bernice Burnett’s big window looks into Sister Anne’s second-floor apartment. Would she be reliable? Most witnesses weren’t and Grace could feel time ticking away. She could not let this one get cold. She had to build on the positives. She had possible evidence, maybe a witness. Bit by bit, piece by piece, that’s how you get it done, she told herself as she knocked on Bernice Burnett’s door.

Locks clicked and it opened to a woman in a full-length sweater and fluffy slippers.

“Bernice Burnett?

“Yes.”

Grace held out her identification.

“Detective Grace Garner. I’d like to talk to you about this evening, follow up on what you told the officer earlier. May I come in?”

“Oh. Yes, Detective, of course, but I’ve got-” Bernice glanced back to her visitor, Jason Wade.

“That’s okay,” Jason stood. “Thank you, Mrs. Burnett, you’ve been very helpful, I was just leaving.”

Grace snapped her ID closed. She was annoyed. Annoyed as hell that a reporter was talking to her witness before her, the primary. And why, damn it, why did it have to be Jason Wade?

He didn’t even glance at her until they were inches apart at the doorway, then he leveled a cold look at her. Or was it only a reflection of what he’d discovered in her eyes? Did he even know about her disaster with Agent Asshole? Well, to hell with it all, Grace. Do your job. Just do your damn job.

“Excuse me for a moment, Bernice, I’ll be right back,” Grace said.

She couldn’t risk damage to her case by letting testimonial evidence become a headline. She followed Jason down the hall but he refused to stop.

“Will you hold on, please?”

He halted. But he refused to turn and face her, forcing her to walk around him until she stood before him.

“How did you get in this building?”

“Give me a break.”

“All right, what did she tell you? What’re you going to print? Are you going to hurt my investigation?”

“Ever heard of freedom of the press? I don’t work for you, so back off.”

Both of them were breathing hard; neither wanted to acknowledge what was raging beneath the surface, until finally Grace took the first step.

“Jason, look, maybe I made a mistake. I’m sorry if I hurt you.”

“ If you hurt me? ” He shook his head. “I thought we had something good. That it was going somewhere. You just tossed me like yesterday’s news without so much as a ‘hey, we have to talk.’”

“So I suck at these things. I’ve always been alone. I-”

“You got a name on the victim, the nun?”

“What?”

Pages of his notebook snapped to a fresh one. His pen was poised.

“You’re on the record. Can you confirm that it’s Sister Anne Braxton?”

“No. We’re not prepared to release-”

“Any indication on cause of death?”

“That will be confirmed by the Medical Ex-”

“I didn’t ask you for confirmation, I asked for an indication?”

“Jason, come on.”

“Was she shot, stabbed, beaten? Was it an act of God, Grace, tell me?”

“You’re being rude.”

“I’m doing my job. People around here are going to be outraged that someone would murder this nun. They call her an angel of the community. So you got a suspect yet?”

“This is how you want to play it?”

The jingle of keys interrupted them as a uniformed officer trotted up the stairs.

“Detective, we’ve got a bunch of media out front who’re demanding to talk to you right now.”

Without releasing Jason from her glare, she said, “Tell them to wait. We’ve got a press person coming to us from downtown.”

The officer sized up Jason. “You got some trouble here, detective?”