Amanda Stevens - The Dollmaker

The bartender poured Dave a Coke and stuck in a spear of cherries. “No extra charge.” He grinned and slid the glass across the bar.

Dave took out the cherries and put them on the napkin.

The bartender was still grinning. “You don’t remember me, do you?”

“Should I?”

“Carver High School. Senior year. You split open my lip with your class ring. We both got suspended for fighting and almost didn’t graduate. I still got the scar, see?” He tapped a finger against his lower lip, where a thin, raised line snaked halfway down his chin.

Dave narrowed his eyes. “Bobby Ray Taubin, right?”

“I go by Robert these days.” He stuck his hand across the bar. “How the hell have you been?”

Dave shook his hand and shrugged. “So what were we fighting about?”

“Damned if I remember. Some lil ol’ girl, probably. Seems like you and me share the same taste in women.” He nodded toward the redhead on stage. “Not bad, huh? You want a piece of that action, I’m the guy who can hook you up.”

“Thanks. I’m just here to see JoJo.”

“Change your mind, let me know,” he said. His eyes were dark and beady, and they shifted back and forth as he talked.

Dave sipped his Coke. “How long have you worked for JoJo?”

The bartender grabbed up a dish towel and started wiping down the counter. “Off and on for a couple of years. Ever since I got out of Angola.” He threw the towel over his shoulder as he waited for Dave’s reaction.

“What were you in for?”

“Liquor store holdup. The guy behind the register tried to stop me. Dude looked like he’d been put through a sausage grinder when I got through with him, but he was still coming at me when the cops got there.” Taubin laughed and went back to polishing the bar. “I guess I almost killed the little bastard, but I wasn’t thinking too straight back then. Had too much glass in my system. I came out of the joint clean and sober, but you won’t find too many people willing to take a chance on a guy with a record like mine. JoJo was the only one who’d hire me, so I’ve got a soft spot for the old coot.”

“Meaning?”

The bartender stuck a toothpick in his mouth as he leaned an arm on the bar. His eyes darted back and forth as he stared Dave in the face. “JoJo’s got enough problems these days without the law breathing down his neck.”

“I’m not a cop,” Dave said.

“Then why are you here? You don’t drink, you don’t watch the show. I gotta think a man like you has an agenda.” He moved slightly so that Dave could see the baseball bat on the shelf behind him.

“I’m not here to start any trouble. I just want to ask JoJo a few questions.”

“About what?”

“That’s between him and me.”

“Is that right?” The bartender flicked the toothpick toward the trash. “Like I said, he’ll be out in a little while. He may give you a few minutes of his time and he may not. But a word of advice, chief. I’ll be right here the whole time just itching for a chance to even an old score.”

Dave threw some bills on the bar as he stood. “I tell you what, Bobby Ray. You just keep right on convincing yourself you’re ready to rock and roll, and when I come back, you let me know if you still want to even that score.”

To kill some time, Dave walked back to Decatur and picked up a muffuletta and an icy bottle of water from the Central Grocery. Then he carried his early dinner into the square and found an empty bench in the shade.

Angelette had suggested he drop by the Hotel Monteleone later that night to meet Graydon Losier, the murdered girl’s father, but Dave wanted a chance to talk to JoJo first. He’d gone over the case file several times and read through all the statements. Nina Losier had been brutally beaten, her body rolled out of a car onto the wide neutral ground on Esplanade Avenue, where she was found early the next morning.

The neighborhood had been canvassed for eyewitnesses, her friends, family and the people she worked with were interviewed, and her boyfriend, Jimmy Caisson, brought in for questioning. Caisson had a history of violence, particularly against women, but when he’d produced an alibi for the night of Nina’s murder, the investigation had hit a wall.

The only angle Dave could find that hadn’t been exhausted by the police was the possible connection to Renee Savaria’s murder. Both women had worked at the Gold Medallion, but the murders had occurred seven years apart. The lead was a slim one at best, and probably wouldn’t amount to anything more than wishful thinking on Dave’s part that he could finally put some closure to one of the darkest chapters of his life. The Savaria case was a black mark against a career he’d otherwise been proud of, and what he’d done in a time of desperation still ate at him.

It wasn’t that his record had been spotless before the Savaria case. Like a lot of other cops he knew, he’d taken some liberties in the name of justice. But he’d loved his job and believed in what he was doing. He’d never thought of himself as the type of cop who could be coerced or bribed, but Ruby’s kidnapping had changed everything. She’d been missing for nearly forty-eight hours when he got the first call.

“Don’t say anything, Detective Creasy, just listen. I know your place is crawling with cops, so if you want your daughter back in one piece, you’ll go someplace more private. I’ll call you back in ten minutes.”

Dave had been trembling by the time he hung up his cell phone, but somehow he’d managed to keep the fear from his face and voice as he muttered to Claire that he needed some air. He’d walked two blocks over from their apartment and sat down on the curb to wait for the call. It came exactly ten minutes after the first.

“Where are you, Detective?”

“Outside. No one can hear me.”

“For your daughter’s sake, I hope you’re being straight with me.”

Dave gripped the phone. “Where is she? Let me talk to her.”

“She’s asleep. You don’t want me to wake her up, do you? She’s had a rough couple of days.”

“You son of a bitch. If you’ve hurt her—”

“Save your threats, Detective. You’re never going to find me and we’re wasting valuable time, so let’s just get down to business. You have something I want.”

The pounding in Dave’s ears was so loud he couldn’t think straight. “What are you talking about?”

“The morning before your daughter disappeared, you had a meeting with Renee Savaria’s roommate. She gave you Renee’s diary. If you ever want to see your daughter again, you’ll do exactly as I say. One little deviation and she dies, is that clear?” The voice paused. “And that would be a real shame, too, because she’s such a pretty little thing.”

Dave had walked back home dripping with sweat as he tried to figure out what to do. As he’d approached the back gate, he saw a bloodstained hair ribbon draped through the latch, and he knew that it had been left there for him to find. The kidnapper had been close. He’d probably been watching the whole time.

Dave had turned, scoured the area, as terrible thoughts ran through his head. His little girl hurt, bleeding, needing him to come for her and him not having a clue where to look. Those thoughts had been his undoing, and by the time he received the next phone call, he’d been ready to deal. He’d gone to the evidence room, ripped out the last page of the diary and burned it, just as the caller had instructed. And then he’d waited for his daughter to come home.

A part of him suspected all along that he was being played. He was a cop. He should have known better. But he’d been so desperate and scared, so racked with guilt, that he was willing to try anything to bring Ruby safely home. But as days and then weeks went by with hope ever dwindling, he’d come to the terrible realization that Renee Savaria’s murderer had used his daughter’s kidnapping to manipulate him into destroying the evidence. The cases weren’t related at all. A cold-blooded killer had simply taken advantage of a heartbreaking situation.