Jake Needham - Killing Plato

“Ah, Jack…” Billy shifted his weight slightly and ran his fingers up and down the stem of the martini glass. “Everything around here is a little true and nothing is completely true. You ought to know that.”

“Don’t bullshit me, Billy. Why were the marshals really in Phuket? To bring Karsarkis back, or to kill him?”

“It’s not that simple, Jack.”

“Yes, it is that simple.”

“Look, Jack, there were different people there. They had…different responsibilities.”

Billy flicked a glance at his minders, then he cleared his throat and tapped at the table with his forefinger.

“We?ustif were hoping Karsarkis would see the wisdom of coming back on his own. On the other hand, if we could have found a way to snatch him, we would have done it. I don’t mind telling you that. But nobody really wanted to kill him.”

“Which means you might have. If you thought you had to.”

“Yeah, we might have if we thought somebody else was going to snatch him first.”

“God damn , Billy-” I started in, but he interrupted me before I could get started.

“What else could we have done, Jack? Just sat there with our thumbs up our butts while Karsarkis became Exhibit A in the great hit parade of American fuck-ups? Hell, Karsarkis would probably rather we’d shot him than let the crazies get him.”

“Look, Billy, there’s something important here that you don’t know anything about.”

Billy nodded slowly. “That wouldn’t surprise me.”

“Karsarkis was going to spill it all,” I said. “He thought if he just told the world everything he knew, that would protect him. Then no one would want to kill him anymore to shut him up.”

“How do you know that?”

“Before Karsarkis got on that plane, he came to see me. He told me he was going to go public.”

“Huh,” Billy said. “How about that?”

“There’s more.”

Billy said nothing.

“He told me exactly what it was he was going to spill.”

Billy blinked then, twice in rapid succession, but otherwise his eyes gave nothing away.

“Plato Karsarkis spilled the beans to me before he got on his plane, Billy. He spilled the fucking beans to me about everything he had been doing and all the rest of it as well.”

“And by the rest of it you would be referring to…”

“Cynthia Kim, the NSC operation in Indonesia, and the explosives and detonators used in the Bali bombing.”

Billy didn’t say anything right away. He just scratched the back of his neck and examined the ceiling, which kept me from seeing his face clearly. I assumed that was the whole idea.

“And there’s one other thing you ought to know, too, pal,” I went on before he could regroup. “Karsarkis bugged your debriefing of Cynthia Kim in Singapore. He had tapes of the whole thing, tapes with your voice on them.”

Billy stopped pretending to study the ceiling and shifted his eyes back to mine. “Have you heard them?” he asked.

“No,” I answered truthfully. “I haven’t.”

“But you’re sure he had them.”

“Yes,” I said. “Absolutely sure.”

“How can you be so sure if you didn’t hear them?”

“You’ve known me for over twenty years, Billy. Would I tell you I was sure if I wasn’t?”

Billy’s expression never changed. He was a cool one. Whatever else he might be, I had to give him that at least.

“Well,?="j damn ,” he sighed, flicking his eyes around the room and then back to mine before taking a deep breath. “Don’t that beat all?”

Looking back it was probably only a minute or two before Billy spoke again, but at the time the silence had seemed to stretch on for much longer than that.

“Do you know if he had the tapes with him when his plane blew up?” Billy asked.

“Not for sure.”

“But you think he did.”

I nodded.

“What about copies?” Billy asked. “Were there any copies?”

“There may have been,” I said, avoiding Billy’s eyes. I wondered if Billy noticed me avoid his eyes, but he just nodded slowly a few times, giving no indication of it if he had.

“I could always have those guys,” he inclined his head toward his security men, “come over here and torture you.”

“You could,” I said, “but you probably won’t.”

“No.” Billy made a little popping sound with his lips. “I probably won’t.”

The waiter returned unbidden and replaced Billy’s empty glass with a fresh martini. I noticed he didn’t offer to do anything along similar lines with my nearly empty glass of Bushmills.

“So what happens now?” Billy asked after he had taken a sip.

“I don’t know,” I admitted. “I guess I was hoping…”

I stopped talking and stared for a minute at a spot on the tablecloth.

“I really don’t know,” I said again.

Billy nodded as if that all somehow made perfect sense.

“Look, Jack…”

Billy paused. He look as if he was trying to make up his mind about something and I waited for him to decide on whatever it was.

“A lot of things are more complicated than they seem,” he said after a moment.

“Did your people blow up that plane, Billy?”

“ My people?” Billy smiled slightly at that, although I thought he looked tired and a little sad when he did. “No, not my people.”

“But somebody’s people?”

Billy put his glass down again and adjusted its position slightly. He didn’t say anything.

“Then let me put this plainly just to make sure there’s no misunderstanding between us,” I said. “You’re willing to let me think it is at least possible someone in the government of the United States blew up a plane in order to kill Plato Karsarkis and keep him from telling the world what he knew about White House involvement in covert operations that turned sour.”

Billy leaned across the table. Lowering his voice he tapped me on the back of the wrist with one finger.

“You do not have the first fucking idea how much is possible, Jack. Governments do things all the time that in your wildest imagination you would never begin to believe. We do what we do because-”

“Oh, please,” I interrupted. “Spare me the for-the-sake-of-the-greater-good speech. Could you just do that for me?”

“S?uo;Oh, plure,” Billy said. “I can do that for you. If you want me to.”

We sat for a while in silence again after that, me looking at the wall behind Billy and him watching the room over my shoulder.

“Who was it, Billy?” I asked him finally. “Who sent those guys to kill Karsarkis?”

Billy shook his head, but he didn’t say anything.

“How about me then? I asked. “Who send those guys who tried to kill me ?

“You may not believe this, Jack, but nobody wanted to kill you.”

“You’re right. I don’t believe that.”

“They thought it was Karsarkis in that car,” Billy said. “It was just a coincidence that you were there instead.”

“Nothing about any of this shit ever turns out to be a coincidence,” I said. “Besides, Karsarkis told me it was you who was behind it.”

“ Me ?”

“Not you personally. The White House. The National Security Council. The boys in the basement. You were the ones who wanted to keep Karsarkis from talking because you were afraid of what he was going to say. You were the ones who wanted to shut him up.”

Billy Redwine nodded, but he didn’t say anything.

“Was it you, Billy? Did you send those guys to Phuket?”

“No.”

“Then who?”

“I…don’t…fucking…know.” Billy waved his hand quickly back and forth through the air as if that would brush it all away. “What part of that don’t you understand?”