Joel Goldman - Motion to Kill

St. John peered across the desk at Mason like a teacher whose student just told him that a squirrel climbed in his window and ate his homework.

“Mr. Mason, your late partner was O’Malley’s gatekeeper, and we’ve been banging on the gate for two years. Did you really think you could make a fortune off O’Malley and not step in his crap?”

Mason was done with nice.

“We don’t have the luxury of sitting around dreaming up conspiracies while sucking on the public tit. If Sullivan stepped on his dick, we’ll deal with it.”

“Stepping on his dick or your own may be the least of your concerns. Have the files here by five o’clock on Friday.”

“Why don’t we just go see the judge and ask him if he thinks an extension is appropriate since the person you served with the subpoena never told us about any of this and is now dead?”

St. John knew the judge would give them more time to respond and that he wouldn’t win any points for being a hard-ass.

“Very well, Mr. Mason. How much time do you want?”

“Thirty days.”

“Will that be all?”

“I want to know if you’re tapping our phones. Once the press gets hold of this, I want to reassure our clients that their communications remain confidential.”

“You’re not entitled to that information, Mr. Mason, and you know it. But, in the spirit of cooperation-Agent McNamara, what’s the status of our intercepts?”

“Holt handled the last round just before her partner was killed. Our authorizations expired after she quit. We don’t have anything in their offices.”

Holt’s name made no sense.

“Kelly Holt?”

“Yeah, why?” McNamara asked.

“She’s the sheriff investigating Sullivan’s death.”

“I wasn’t aware that she stayed in law enforcement,” St. John said as he glared at McNamara, reprimanding him for his oversight. “The paper said that Sullivan drowned.”

“He died during our firm retreat. I helped identify the body. That’s all I know. We’ll have a response to the subpoena in a month.”

Mason was silent on the walk back to the office, trying to piece together fragments that didn’t match. Sandra waited to interrupt his thoughts until they were in the conference room, surrounded by the O’Malley files.

“Are you going to tell me what Kelly Holt has to do with Sullivan’s death or do I have to use my knife?” No response. “Lou, it’s a very sharp knife.”

“Do you believe in coincidences?”

“No. I believe in chaos.”

“O’Malley, Sullivan, and the firm are being investigated by the FBI. Sullivan dies and the sheriff who is investigating his death just happens to be an ex-FBI agent who just happened to be in charge of wiretapping O’Malley. Coincidence or chaos?”

He didn’t add that the sheriff didn’t tell him she’d been involved in the investigation. He hadn’t had time to sort through that piece.

“Chaos-the rule of unintended consequences. Seemingly unconnected events run headlong into each other. It’s like God is using people to play bumper cars. Sullivan drowned. Where’s the connection?”

“Sullivan was murdered. That’s not what I would call an unintended consequence.”

Maggie Boylan and Phil Rosa pushed the door open, wheeling in a portable workstation with a PC, printer, paper, legal pads, calculators, and a lifetime supply of Post-its. Mason and Sandra exchanged looks, agreeing to table the discussion of murder.

“Do you have any idea how many trees will die before we’re done with the paper in this case?” Rosa asked.

“I don’t care,” Mason said, “as long as you finish reviewing O’Malley’s files by Sunday night. I want an analysis of all of the transactions we’ve handled for O’Malley. I want to know what each deal involved, who financed it, what changed hands, and the names of all past and present Sullivan amp; Christenson attorneys who worked on them.”

“We could really use a legal assistant to set up a database for all that information. We’ve got the software to sort the data, but we need someone who uses it all the time if we’re going to be ready for O’Malley on Monday,” Maggie Boylan said.

“Sorry, we’ve got to keep this team as small as possible. I can’t take the chance of leaks.”

“She’s right,” Sandra said. “There are thousands of documents to review. Diane Farrell was Sullivan’s paralegal. There can’t be anything in these files she doesn’t already know.”

Phil stiffened at the suggestion. “That woman is the biggest pain in the ass in four states. If she wasn’t screwing Sullivan, she had him by the short hairs some other way. Sullivan let her get away with murder. No one can stand to work with her.”

“For Christ’s sake, Phil,” Maggie said, “can’t we wait until the body’s cold before we start shitting all over the grave? She knows this stuff inside and out. Besides, I’d rather have her where I can watch her than wonder what she’s doing to get even for being left out.”

Mason gave in. “All right, I’m convinced by this underwhelming endorsement. Bring her in, but tell her she’s out of a job if she can’t keep her mouth shut. Sandra and I will be in Sullivan’s office.”

Sullivan had a corner office with glass on three sides, giving him a panoramic view stretching from downtown to the horizon. Bookshelves mounted above file drawers stood behind his wraparound desk.

Mason tackled the file drawers and Sandra poked through the desk. When they were finished, they were no closer to any answers. There was nothing pertaining to O’Malley or St. John’s subpoena.

“Scott said he found St. John’s subpoena on Sullivan’s desk. If Sullivan was hiding that from us, I don’t think he would have left it lying around and I don’t think he would have put it in his out basket so his secretary could file it. He would have hidden it, probably with whatever other files on O’Malley he didn’t want anyone else to see,” Sandra said.

“Makes sense, but it doesn’t look like he kept them in his office.”

“Maybe somebody got here ahead of us or maybe he kept them in an office at home. We should have a look after the funeral. I did find this DVD, but it’s not labeled.”

She handed it to Mason. He booted up Sullivan’s desktop PC and inserted the disk into the CD/DVD drive.

“Man-O-Manischewitz,” Mason said.

They watched as a half dozen naked men and women mixed and matched parts as if they were playing a deviant version of Mr. Potato Head.

“Look at those angles. I better take some notes,” Sandra said.

“That’s all the excitement I can stand,” Mason announced. His face was flushed as he punched the disk out of the computer and returned it to its case.

“What’s the matter?” Sandra teased. “Afraid to walk down the hall with Johnny Rocket ready for liftoff?”

She made a show of letting her eyes slide down his chest to his zipper.

“You are brutal. You know that? But watching a porno flick together is not my idea of bonding with you.”

Sandra wouldn’t let up. “You sure those big boys aren’t making you insecure?”

“Of all people, Sandra, I thought you would know.”

“Know what?”

“Like the song says, it ain’t the meat. It’s the motion.” Mason enjoyed Sandra’s silent, red-faced response. “Let’s go,” he added, grabbing the DVD. “I think I’ll keep this so it doesn’t show up in the stuff we turn over to St. John.”

“Just a minute. Let’s try a reality check with St. John.” Sandra unscrewed the mouthpiece of the telephone receiver on Sullivan’s desk. “You’re going to love this,” she said, showing him the miniature microphone attached to the mouthpiece.