Archer Mayor - Three Can Keep a Secret

He charged the shotgun’s chamber as his colleagues pulled out their handguns. “Okay,” he said, “Exigent circumstances. We’re going in, but no fanfare. Fast and low.”

He swung open the door and swept in, cutting to the left as Lester and Sam followed suit like parachutists leaping from a plane.

They found themselves in a large, front lobby, facing an ostentatious curved staircase ahead and a row of doors down both side walls, all dominated from above by a chandelier better suited to a European castle.

There wasn’t a sound or a movement aside from their own.

Joe gestured to them to spread out and check the doors as he approached the staircase walking backwards, his weapon at the ready, his eyes fixed on the second-floor balcony that was half hidden by the chandelier-an ideal nest for a shooter anticipating their entry.

But he saw no one.

“Joe,” came Sammie’s voice, echoing off the towering walls and marble floor.

He left the stairs for the door she’d opened to enter the library, which turned out to occupy most of the house’s left wing, and which-unbeknownst to any of them-resembled Scott’s office in Montpelier.

Lester joined him to see Sam standing near the center of the room, before an elaborate antique wingback chair.

Sitting there comfortably, with a surprised look on his face, was Sheldon Scott.

“He dead?” Joe asked, thinking-in one of those disconnected moments that challenge one’s sense of proportion-that Gail’s current woes were going to be considerably lessened by this development. She was still facing a storm of her own-no doubt about it-but with Scott’s demise, its primary driving force had been suddenly removed.

“Yeah.”

“You’re sure?”

“No carotid,” she answered. “He’s still warm, but I know dead.”

Joe could attest to that. He turned to Lester, who anticipated him by reaching for his cell phone and saying, “Upgrade the BOL on Carolyn and get a full homicide response on this, including the crime lab.”

Joe nodded, adding to them both, “And let’s make sure the house is clear. Right now. We can come back here once we’re sure we’re alone.”

They quickly made a tactical sweep of the entire building, ending up in the four-car garage, where they discovered a vehicle missing and one of the doors wide open. A phone call to VBI Dispatch revealed that Scott had four cars registered to him; the missing one was added to the alert.

Minutes later, they were back at the library door. “Did you see what did him in?” Joe asked of Sammie.

“Small puncture wound over the heart,” she replied. “But smaller than a bullet, and no gunshot residue. That seemed to be it.”

Joe recalled Beverly’s finding with William Friel. “Like an icepick?”

“That would fit.”

They stayed where they were, not wanting to further contaminate a crime scene. Sammie added, pointing, “The pillow on the chair opposite him looked depressed, unlike any of the others. Like somebody had been sitting on it.”

Joe nodded, mostly to himself, and turned to face the front entrance across the lobby. “So maybe she knocks on the door, he opens up, they begin to talk and he brings her in here. They sit, she hears all she needs to, and she sticks him.”

The three of them retreated to the foot of the stairs, hearing sirens approaching from afar. “God only knows where Carolyn is now,” Joe said, “but I bet she’s not moving too fast, given how long it’s been since she drove regularly. Maybe we’ll get lucky.”

Sam sighed, “Let’s hope somebody gets her before she does any more damage. She’s doubling the state’s homicide rate.”

* * *

They didn’t find Carolyn Barber. They located Sheldon Scott’s BMW, abandoned in a nearby grocery store parking lot and covered with Carolyn’s fingerprints, but of her, they found no further trace.

They did discover the stolen photograph from Gorden Marshall’s apartment-along with the key and the uniform that Travis Reynolds had used to infiltrate The Woods. They were in Scott’s office, off his upstairs bedroom, lumped together in a pile. There was no CC lapel pin, however, and no files-which were now presumed to have been stolen by Carolyn for their contents on the same day that she smothered an alcoholically impaired Gorden Marshall. Intriguingly to Joe, a single thumbprint of Carolyn’s was lifted from the photograph’s glass, as if she’d held it contemplatively after stabbing Sheldon downstairs. That discovery made him think as well that she’d possibly removed the purple and gold Catamount Cavaliers memento, perhaps as an ironic souvenir. If that was true-and since she remained unaccounted for-Joe couldn’t help considering that she might have more ex-Cavaliers on her list of men to kill. Indeed, that possibility had led to a thorough and ongoing effort to identify who might be left among Scott and Marshall’s fellow club members.

Fueling the concern about Carolyn’s motivation, a search of Scott’s home uncovered a trove of Cavalier artifacts in a large wall safe, along with hundreds of unrelated confidential files. There was only one pin-probably Scott’s own-but many letters, more vintage photos of people in high spirits, and other documents attesting to the faux-formal nature of the organization’s genesis, complete with a salacious but official-looking framed listing of “Rules of Mis-Behaviour,” handwritten in mock Old English style.

Finally, in what amounted to a pathetic footnote, there was a memo in Scott’s hand, informing Marshall to play along with Carolyn’s demand for money and to be named Governor-for-a-Day, complete with attending pomp and ceremony-part of her price for keeping her pregnancy quiet. Then, as inevitable and as cold as revenge can be, there were copies of adoption documents, legally rendering a female infant over to the care of Mr. and Mrs. Gorden Marshall, and a copy of the same commitment papers that Joe had read earlier in the state hospital archives, dated the same year, along with hand-lettered notes indicating the establishment of a mood-altering regimen that was to be perpetually-and illegally-maintained to keep Carolyn Barber in a state of permanent stupor.

Sheldon Scott had clearly been a man to keep track of his favors to others.

* * *

Joe was organizing his paperwork several nights later, closing out as much of the case as possible, and repeatedly reminded of its cost in human misery-not unlike that of Tropical Storm Irene. He kept wondering how and if Carolyn could have possibly survived, assuming that recent events hadn’t already taken their toll, sweeping her away like so much trash in a flood. She was no youngster, after all, and by now had no family, no resources, and-as far as they’d been able to determine-nowhere to go.

Her prior missing person notices had all been taken down, replaced by wanted posters and, sadly, more sensationalist media coverage than she ever received when she was simply presumed missing.

His desk phone rang, as if responding to his ruminations.

“Gunther,” he answered.

“Agent Gunther, this is Michelle Mahoney, Gorden Marshall’s daughter?”

“Of course, Ms. Mahoney. What can I do for you?”

“It’s probably nothing,” she said. “But I was putting the final touches on moving my father’s junk out so they can sell his apartment. I found something I thought you should know about, just in case it’s helpful. Are you able to meet with me right now? I’m on the interstate, heading south, near Brattleboro. I think that’s where you work, no? I am sorry for the short notice, but-”

“Absolutely,” Joe interrupted her. “I’m still at the office. Would you like to come straight here? It’s not far from exit two.”