Reed Coleman - Hurt machine

I was greeted by a handsome if compact man with blue eyes, short gray hair, a bright friendly smile, and a welcoming handshake. He was about ten years my junior and was comfortably clad in a blue and yellow striped shirt, khaki slacks, and deck shoes. It was an outfit I might have worn, but it looked different on him. His shirt was crisply ironed, the rolled cuffs perfectly squared midway up his forearms, the creases in his slacks just so. His office/apartment reflected that same sort of style: comfortable, yet everything in it was neat and clean.

“I’m Henry Handwerker. What can I do for you, officer?”

“Retired,” I said, putting my badge back where it belonged. “Sorry, but the badge sometimes saves a lot of time.”

“Lying may be efficient, but it is unwelcome.”

“I agree, but I didn’t think I could get away with claiming I was the Chinese food delivery man.”

“I see your point, still…”

“I’m an investigator working for the Tillman family.”

Handwerker’s whole body seemed to sag. “Oh.”

“See, it would have been a little difficult explaining through the voice box downstairs.”

“What is it you want to know?” he asked and then volunteered, “I have no desire to crucify those two women EMTs. There was clearly something troubling going on with them.”

“Troubling. How?”

“They were pretty agitated,” he said.

“They were arguing with each other?”

“Not exactly. It wasn’t an argument, per se. It seemed they were both upset over something, but in different ways.”

“I’m sorry, Mr. Handwerker, but I’m a bit confused here. Can you be a little bit more explicit?”

“One, the Hispanic woman-”

“Alta Conseco.”

“Yes. She was angry, but with someone or something, not at her partner. You could see the fire in her. Her face was contorted and her gestures were violent and purposeful.”

“And what about Maya Watson, the partner?”

“A beautiful woman,” he said almost wistfully as he remembered her face.

“She is, I agree.”

“She looked frightened, very frightened and hesitant, almost nauseous really. Maybe she was because she basically headed right for the restrooms. Her partner, Miss Conseco, she was making a straight line for the kitchen.”

This was why you couldn’t just read written statements and take them as being representative of what had actually happened. In his original statement to the police, Mr. Handwerker, probably somewhat stunned, hadn’t described things in quite this way. He’d stated that the two EMTs were agitated, yes, but hadn’t made the finer distinctions he was making for me now, nor had he mentioned that Alta and Maya were in fact headed to different places when they entered the bistro. I pointed that out to him.

“I was still out of sorts and a little bit in shock, I suppose, when I gave my statement,” he said, confirming my impression. “It was all very tumultuous. Things happened so quickly.”

“I understand. So, Miss Conseco was headed to the kitchen and Miss Watson to the restrooms?”

“Exactly.”

“Could you hear any of their conversation?”

“Not really. I was seated facing the door, midway between the bar and the entrance. It was crowded and noisy in there. I could barely hear my client across the table, but there was a definite vibe between them.”

“A vibe?”

“I can’t explain it. It’s just something I picked up on. That’s all.”

I could see he wasn’t going to say more about that and I moved on. We talked through the sequence of events, with estimates of how much time elapsed between the two EMTs entering the restaurant and Chef Liu emerging from the kitchen, screaming for help.

“I wouldn’t have wanted either of those women treating me,” Handwerker said in conclusion. “You could see how totally out of it they were. If it had been anything else other than a stroke, that poor man would have been better served to wait until reinforcements arrived. Both women were shaking and the beautiful one was completely distraught.”

I thanked him for his time and told him I might be back in touch.

“As I stated before, I don’t wish to crucify those women.”

“It’s all right, Mr. Handwerker. I’m not certain the Tillman family will pursue this. Besides, one of the two EMTs is already dead.”

“I heard. Terrible.”

“Well,” I said, “at least she can’t be hurt by any of this.”

“Maybe not her, but her family can suffer and there’s the other woman.”

“Of course. If you don’t mind me saying, Mr. Handwerker, you’re the first person I’ve run into in this whole investigation who’s had an ounce of sympathy for the EMTs.”

“Those other people weren’t there that day. They didn’t see the distress on those women’s faces. Something was dreadfully wrong there.”

I thanked him again and hopped back on the elevator. It was nice to know there were still some people in the world like Henry Handwerker. If there was any redemption to be found in this universe, it lived in the hearts of people like him.

The trouble with eyewitnesses was that they could all see the same exact things, but see them differently. Such was the case with what happened at the High Line Bistro that day last March. By four-thirty in the afternoon, I’d interviewed four other witnesses beside Henry Handwerker who’d given statements to the police about the circumstances that day and the only thing they all agreed on was that the two EMTs refused to treat Tillman. Otherwise, it was difficult to tell that they had actually witnessed a common event. One woman didn’t notice the two EMTs were agitated. “Agitated?” she said when I suggested it. “No, they seemed fine.” Another, younger woman who was then working at an exclusive jewelry boutique on Gansevoort Street and was taking her lunch at the bistro said that both Alta and Maya were headed to the restrooms. “The kitchen? No. They were definitely walking toward the restrooms. I’d swear to it.” She did say the two EMTs were bickering, but not about anything serious. “A girl thing,” she said as if that explained it all.

The older of the two men I spoke with swore Alta and Maya came in separately and resisted any suggestion they were arguing. The younger man barely noticed Alta. “That tall EMT was so hot and, man, she was amazing in that uniform.”

One of the problems with how the human brain functions is its need for a coherent narrative. It perceives events and then builds a story around them, it edits and embellishes, it ascribes motives when none are obvious. The mood, age, and sex of the witness can affect the perceptions of events and, to an even greater extent, the narrative woven out of those events. Although I had no palpable reason to accept Henry Handwerker’s version of what had transpired, I chose to trust his version instead of the others. I don’t know, maybe it was his sense of detail. Maybe it was his sense of style. Maybe it was that he displayed compassion. No matter, because there was one inescapable truth here: Alta and Maya had refused to treat a dying man and no amount of parsing or pretzel twisting of the facts was going to change that.

Nick was late, so I sipped at a glass of Brooklyn Lager and munched on olives at the bar. The Kythira Cafe on 5th Avenue in Park Slope, was, as Nick described it, the crown jewel of his family’s business. The menu featured updated and upscale versions of classic Mediterranean dishes. The interior decor was dark and moody and about as far away from the stereotypical white and blue stucco walls as you could get. There were no Ouzo or retsina bottles, no Greek flags, no bad murals of whitewashed houses on cliffs above the blue Mediterranean, no travel posters of Mykonos, Crete, or the Parthenon.