Parnell Hall - The Wrong Gun

“No, I did not.”

“But you could see the R in the handle?”

“Yes, it was facing up.”

“Tell me, had you ever seen that gun before?”

“Objected to as leading and suggestive,” Steve Winslow said.

“Sustained,” Judge Hendrick said. “Mr. Vaulding, this is an area where for obvious reasons care should be taken not to lead the witness.”

“Yes, Your Honor.”

“Rephrase your question.”

“Yes, Your Honor. Mr. Kessington, at the time that you saw the gun, did you think that you recognized it?”

“Yes, I did.”

“What did you think you recognized it to be?”

“When I saw the gun, I thought it was a gun from Russ Timberlaine’s collection. Specifically, a collector’s item, a gun once owned by Pistol Pete Robbins.”

“You were familiar with this gun?”

“Yes, I was.”

“You had seen the gun before?”

“Yes, I had.”

“You are familiar with all of the guns in Russ Timberlaine’s collection?”

“No, I am not.”

“Why were you familiar with that particular gun?”

“It had been brought to my attention.”

“By whom?”

“By Russ Timberlaine.”

“Russ Timberlaine brought that gun to your attention?”

“Yes, he did.”

“When was that?”

“The week before the murder.”

“Can you be more specific?”

“No, I can’t. It was on one of the days of the week before the murder. I believe it was toward the beginning of the week. Might have been Monday or Tuesday. Possibly Wednesday.”

“At any rate, Russ Timberlaine brought it to your attention?”

“Yes, he did.”

“How did that happen?”

“He called me into the gun room and showed me the gun.”

“Where was it?”

“In a glass-topped case.”

“Was the gun in the case at the time?”

“Actually, the case was open and Russ Timberlaine had taken it out of the case.”

“And he showed you the gun?”

“Yes, he did.”

“Did he make any statement to you at the time?”

“Yes, sir. He said this was not his gun. He said he believed his gun had been stolen and that this was a duplicate that had been left in its place.”

“Why was he pointing this out to you?”

“He wanted to know who could have had the opportunity to have taken the gun. See, the case it was in had been kept locked. Unfortunately, one of the keys to it was kept in the office, which was not kept locked.”

“Did you point this out to Russ Timberlaine?”

“Yes, I did.”

“What did he say?”

“He seemed to think if the gun had been taken, it must have been two weekends before when there had been guests at the mansion. He wanted to know if I had seen anyone going in or out of the office on that occasion who might have taken the key.”

“And had you?”

“No, I had not.”

“Getting back to the gun that you found lying next to the body-you said when you saw the gun you first thought it was the original Pistol Pete gun?”

“That’s right.”

“If I understand your testimony, you knew that that gun had been stolen.”

“Yes, I did.”

“Then why did you assume that the gun next to the body was the stolen gun and not the one that had been found substituted?”

“From what Mr. Timberlaine said. When he called me in and showed me the substituted gun.”

“What was that?”

“He suspected something like this would happen.”

That answer was greeted by a loud murmur in the courtroom. Judge Hendrick silenced it with his gavel.

“That was the week before the murder?” Vaulding asked.

“That’s right.”

“And Russ Timberlaine told you he suspected something like this would happen?”

“Not this exactly, of course.”

“Yes, but something similar?”

“Objection.”

“Sustained.”

“Mr. Kessington, to the best of your recollection, what exactly was it Russ Timberlaine said?”

“He said he was afraid someone had stolen his gun to frame him for a crime. He said, ‘What if my gun were found at the scene of a crime? Everybody knows it’s my gun. I’d have a devil of a time proving I didn’t do it.’”

“I see. So when you saw the gun lying next to the body …?”

“I thought of what Russ Timberlaine said, of course. That’s why I immediately thought it was the stolen Pistol Pete gun.”

“I see,” Vaulding said. “Now, tell me. When you first found the body of Jack Potter, who was there?”

“Mr. Winslow and Miss Garvin.”

“As I understand your testimony, she came and got you and brought you to the gun room. When you got back there, who else was there?”

“Just Mr. Winslow.”

“The three of you were alone with the body?”

“That’s right.”

“What happened next?”

“I phoned the police.”

“You did?”

“That’s right.”

“Why you? Why not Mr. Winslow or Miss Garvin?”

“Because it would have been awkward. They didn’t have access to a phone.”

“Could you explain that?”

“Yes. There are very few outside lines in the Timberlaine mansion. There are phones in the rooms, but they are for internal use only. More like an intercom system. There are very few outside lines.”

“Why is that?”

“Mr. Timberlaine used to have a multi-lined system with regular phones in the rooms. But with so many weekend guests it was almost inevitable that people would abuse the privilege. Having people call California was one thing, but we had people calling Europe. Phone bills were astronomical. So the phones were switched over to an in-house system for the rooms, with only a few select outside lines. I, of course, had access to the one in the office, so I placed the call.”

“I see. And that is why you went to call, instead of staying with the body?”

“That’s correct.”

“And while you went to call, did you take any steps to see that the body was left undisturbed?”

“Yes, I did.”

“And what did you do?”

“I left Mr. Winslow and Miss Garvin to watch it.”

“You left them alone with the body while you went to call the police?”

“Yes, I did.”

“When you finished calling the police, what did you do?”

“I went back to the gun room and waited with Mr. Winslow and Miss Garvin for the police to arrive.”

“Mr. Winslow and Miss Garvin were there when you returned?”

“Yes, they were.”

“How long were you gone calling the police?”

“Not long. Maybe five minutes.”

“When you returned from calling the police, did you look at the body and the gun?”

“Yes, I did.”

“Was it just as you had left it?”

“Yes, it was.”

Vaulding picked up one of the exhibits, extended it to the witness. “Mr. Kessington, I hand you a gun marked People’s Exhibit Three and ask you if you have ever seen it before?”

Kessington took the gun and looked it over. “I can’t be sure. It looks like the gun I found next to the body.”

“But you can’t swear to it?”

“No, I cannot.”

“I hand you another gun marked People’s Exhibit Four and ask you if you have seen that gun before.”

“Again, I can’t say. It also looks like the gun I found next to the body.”

“You can’t tell which of these guns that was?”

“No, sir.”

“It could have been either of them?”

“That is right.”

“I am referring to the gun that you found next to the body when you first discovered the body of Jack Potter. You say that could have been either of these two guns?”

“That’s right.”

“Then when you returned from calling the police-the gun that you examined on the floor next to Jack Potter at that time-that could have been either of these two guns?”