Stuart Kaminsky - Now You See It

Shelly pushed his glasses back on his nose and looked as if he were going to speak, then changed his mind and sagged back in his chair.

“I’ve talked to the District Attorney’s office,” Marty said. “I told them that if Mr. Blackstone were arrested for murder without airtight evidence, his reputation would be severely damaged and Mr. Blackstone would bring suit for one million three hundred and sixty dollars.”

“How did you come up with that figure?” asked Pancho.

“Mr. Blackstone and I roughly calculated lost income,” said Marty. “Roughly. The result was that there will be no arrest yet but there will be an investigation. My best estimation is that the brothers Bouton might well be arrested within the next week if we do not come up with the person or persons who killed Cunningham and Ott. And that is the job of the brothers Pevsner.”

Marty looked at my brother and me. So did everyone else at the table.

“Would you gentlemen like to ask some questions?” Marty asked.

“Is Blackstone on the clock?” I asked.

Marty shrugged.

“I think we’ll ask our questions in our office where we’re not going at thirty dollars an hour.”

“Forty-five dollars an hour,” said Blackstone.

“This case will consume all my time till you come up with the killer,” said Marty. “I’ll tell you what. To show my good faith, you are off the clock until I inform you otherwise.”

Phil and I looked at each other. Phil rubbed his thick right palm across his short gray hair. He looked tired.

“Who turned off the lights last night?” he asked looking at the Boutons.

“Jimmy,” said Pete. “Jimmy Clark.”

“The kid with the limp?” Phil asked.

Pete and Harry both nodded.

“The light switch is behind the curtains near the door. Jimmy was behind the curtain two hours before the doors were opened. He waited for the cue from me,” said Harry. “Turned off the lights. Counted to three. Turned on the lights. Pete clapped to draw everyone’s attention while Jimmy counted to five and turned off the lights again for a count of two before he turned the lights on again.”

“We rehearsed it in the ballroom yesterday morning for more than an hour,” said Blackstone. “Timing and misdirection are crucial ingredients in a successful illusion.”

“Right,” said Phil. “But who turned off the lights and did pretty much the same trick when Ott was stabbed?”

“I don’t know,” said Peter.

Harry shrugged.

“Maybe Jimmy saw someone by the lights,” I said.

“Let’s ask him,” said Phil.

Marty remained stone silent, looking at his manicured thumbnails.

“It was deeper,” said Gunther.

Everyone, including Marty, looked at Gunther.

“Deeper than what?” I asked.

“The knife,” said Gunther. “When the lights came on and Ott was on his face, the knife was in so deep.”

He demonstrated with his small fingers.

“When we returned after chasing that young man, the knife was in like so.”

Gunther demonstrated again.

“So,” said Phil. “You’re telling us that, after Ott was killed, someone snuck back in and pushed the knife in deeper just to make sure?”

“I don’t know,” said Gunther. “But it was deeper. Of that I am certain.”

“Why take the chance?” asked Phil.

“I do not know,” said Gunther. “I am only reporting to you what I observed.”

The Bouton brothers were whispering at the end of the table. Pete said something. Harry nodded and whispered back. It was Pete’s turn to nod.

“What?” asked Phil.

“We may have an idea,” said Harry.

“About what?” asked Phil.

“About how Calvin Ott was murdered,” said Peter.

“Well?” asked Phil.

“We’ll have to work it out before we say anything more,” said Harry, touching his mustache. “We’re not certain.”

“Are we finished?” asked Marty, looking at his many-jeweled watch. “Anyone have anything more to say.”

“Did you rescue the bird?” asked Gunther, looking at Jeremy.

“The bird is fine,” said Jeremy. “I’ve returned it to Mr. Leib.”

“And I’ve told my secretary to get it back to the magician I bought it from,” said Marty. “Now I suggest that you …” he looked at me and Phil, “find that second man who was with Cunningham and talk to this Jimmy Clark about what or who, if anything or anyone, he saw behind that curtain.”

“And you?” I asked.

“I,” said Marty, “shall be making the life of Detective John Cawelti miserable and the District Attorney of this great county of Los Angeles angry and miserable. In short, I’ll be stalling and earning my fee. Gentlemen.…”

Marty rose heavily, adjusted the white flower in his lapel, nodded, and waited while we all left his office.

As soon as we hit the landing, Shelly lit a cigar and said, “You get all that?” to Pancho, who nodded.

“Guys,” said Shelly, examining his cigar and pausing dramatically. “Pancho is a very gifted writer, a man of great talent, but his imagination can’t be stifled by the dull facts.”

We all looked at Pancho, who pulled his scarf around his neck as if a cold front had leaped over a bunch of states from Canada and landed on his skinny body.

“So?” I asked.

“I believe Dr. Minck is informing us that Mr. Vanderhoff plans to take liberties with the truth,” said Gunther.

“The truth,” said Shelly with a wave of his hand that shifted a cloud of smoke and disposed of the need for facts. “My role in ongoing events will be …”

“Enhanced,” said Pancho.

“We’re going,” said Harry Blackstone. “We have some things to do and then we’ll be at the theater for tonight’s performance.”

“Let’s go talk to Jimmy the Kid and ask some people about this blonde guy Cunningham was working with,” I said.

Phil nodded.

“And how can we be of service?” Gunther said.

“Jeremy,” I said. “If you can spare the time, you might keep an eye on Blackstone’s back. Whoever killed Cunningham and Ott might be looking for number three, our client.”

“I shall,” said Jeremy solemnly.

“Whertham,” said Phil. “Think you could do some leg work on Ott, see who he hung out with, or who hung onto his wallet? Might be a few people out there who didn’t like him.”

“He did not appear to be a likable individual,” said Gunther. “I shall begin immediately.

“Our office, tomorrow, nine?” I asked.

“Nine-thirty,” said Shelly. “I’ve got Mrs. Odell coming in for an impacted wisdom tooth.”

I could almost swear I saw a Mona Lisa smile on the face of one round rich little dentist as he imagined Mrs. Odell, whoever the hell she was, in his chair. My tooth began to ache.