David Bishop - The Original Alibi

“Well, sir. Please take my curiosity down a notch or two. What is this about?”

“I’d like you to indulge me by finishing a brief sentence: Karen’s father is?”

“What is this about?”

“Indulge me, Charles. Who is Karen’s father?”

“Why, the general, Mr. Kile, everyone knows that.”

“Her birth father, Charles. Who is Karen’s birth father?”

“The general.”

“No. General Whittaker did not sire Karen Whittaker, therefore her last name is not even Whittaker. I figure that only two people, not counting Karen’s mother, know the answer, you and the general. Do I need to ask General Whittaker?”

“No, sir. You do not. I am Karen’s father. The general’s wife, Mary, and I … well, you know. She was a frisky woman. The general was in his fifties, I in my thirties. Her needs exceeded his. Due to my living here then as I do now, my sex drive could best be described as involuntary hibernation. It just happened that once. No. That’s not true. It happened several times over a month or so. Then I put a stop to it. It was wrong. Mary always insisted the general was Karen’s father, but I doubted it, sir. When DNA tests became available, I had them run. She is my daughter. How did you learn this, Mr. Kile?”

Charles had spent a good part of his life serving his daughter as if she were the mistress of the house.

“Charles, do you sometimes use the general’s bathroom, the one between his bedroom and his private study?”

“Yes. Often when I am in the general’s wing, it is closer and the general finds my doing so acceptable. Not regularly, but several times a week I would imagine. I asked how you learned the general was not-”

“The same as you. The general’s DNA didn’t match. Someone else’s did. I figured you. Does Karen know?”

“No sir. I will tell her someday.”

“After the general dies?”

“Yes, Mr. Kile, after the general dies. That is something I cannot imagine. I mean I am here. I talk to the doctors. I know. But the general always seemed indestructible, a man who would always be here. Always be in charge. Yet the reality is now undeniable. The general’s deterioration is accelerating at a rapid pace.”

“Would you have stayed with the general had Karen not been your daughter?”

Charles got up and walked to the window and looked out toward the ocean. “I don’t know,” he said with his back to me. Then he returned to sit with me again at the table. “I have wondered. It has been a distinct honor to be his friend and companion all these years. After my tryst with Mary, I felt so dishonest to be here. But with time that eased and finally passed.”

“You said Karen doesn’t know?”

He shook his head. “No sir. I saw no reason.”

“Then there’s the inheritance. Yours and your daughter’s. If the general knew, he would likely remove you both from his will.”

“I would expect so, sir. Karen has been loving and loyal to the general, as I have been. She is entitled, I believe. Don’t you agree, Mr. Kile?”

“It is not my place to judge that. I leave that to you. My job is simply to determine who killed Ileana Corrigan. I don’t have much time left, so what else can you tell me about that?”

“Nothing. I have been fully candid with you on that entire matter. I know nothing further.”

“Have you ever heard the name, Ernest Podkin?”

“No, I have not. Who is he?”

“A biker. That’s all I know. And I’d appreciate you not repeating that name to anyone.”

“As you wish. You might ask Cliff, he rides a Harley and hangs out with those guys. Used to a lot. Less now, but he still does.”

“I’ll do that. Thanks for talking with me. I appreciate your honesty.”

“Where do we go from here, sir? Will you need to tell the general? I realize I have a selfish interest on this, but the general would not take the news well. He is weak now. I see no reason to … change his memories at this point, sir.”

“I think I agree. Then, I do work for the man which obligates me to tell him what I learn.”

“What you learn about who killed his great grandson. You were hired to learn that, not who fathered his daughter.”

“That’s a point. I just don’t know yet. If I decide I need to, I’ll let you know first.”

“Is there anything else, Mr. Kile?”

“One more thing. Did you kill the Corrigan woman?”

“Sir? Why would you think that? What reason could I have?”

“There was an attempt to frame Eddie. Had that held, he would have gone to prison. It is more than likely the general would have left his entire estate to your daughter, thinking she was his.”

“I understand you must consider every angle, your job and the nature of being a detective, but I don’t believe you think I did. Besides, while I could have arranged to frame Eddie in the manner it was done, why would I bribe Mr. and Mrs. Yarbrough to provide a defense to get Eddie released?”

“Yes. There is that, Charles. However, given your devotion to the general, it is possible you could not bring yourself to be the cause of him watching his grandson being convicted of murder. You could have used the Yarbroughs so you could shake down the general for the two million by selling him the alibi. That amount along with what the general is leaving you and Karen would set you both up without destroying the relationship between Eddie and the general.”

“Being a detective can be a disgusting business, can’t it, Mr. Kile?”

“Yes, Charles. At times like this, it can.”

*

Cliff was in the garage changing spark plugs on the general’s MG Roadster. It didn’t get driven much anymore. Karen took it out once in a while, but the general loved the car.

“I can’t imagine anyone getting their fists on you that much, Matt.”

“You could if you knew my arms were tied, as well as my feet.”

Cliff and I went over to the workbench and occupied two of the stools. “You okay for a beer?” he asked. I nodded, not knowing how it would go, but eager to find out. He brought them over, twisting the cap off mine before handing it to me.

“Ernest Podkin.”

“How do you know Poddy?”

“Poddy?”

“Yeah. We used to call him that because he had bad breath. Poddy mouth. You know. Potty mouth. It stuck. Where do you know him from?”

I circled the air with my index finger pointing at my face.

“Poddy did that? I mean, he’s tough but …” He left the rest unsaid.

“Are you two tight?”

“We know each other. He rides with the gang I once did. We always got along, but never close. It was a big gang. I can’t imagine him doing that to you.”

“Like I said, my arms were tied. So tell me about Mr. Podkin.”

“Lifetime biker. Petty criminal. Hauls drugs up and down the coast. Strong arm work. Not a killer. Least not as I know. If he did this, he was hired by someone who wanted you worked over.”

“That’s right. Podkin told me so before I left him on a concrete floor down by the docks. He said he didn’t know who. I believed him. The way he was set up to do it, well, it was the same way as some others.”

“You say you left him on the floor in a place down in Pedro?” I nodded. “Tell me about the place. Describe it.” I did, including the conveying belt of hooks running along the ceiling. “I know the place,” Cliff said. “I don’t know what those hooks were ever used for. The general had me drive him there after he bought it. He had me go in with him. I asked him what he was going to do with it. He said it was an investment. He liked the location and that eventually somebody would need the space and he’d turn a profit.”

“How long ago was that?”

“More than a year, less than two.” Then Cliff offered to help me find Podkin.