Rex Stout - Home to Roost

“Did it impeach my assumption?”

“No, sir.”

“Did it support it?”

“Yes, sir. Plenty.”

Wolfe went to Heath. “Mr. Panzer’s quality is known, though not to you until now. I think a jury will believe him, and I’m sure the police and the FBI will. My advice, sir, is to cut the loss.”

“Loss?” Heath was trying to sneer but with that face he couldn’t make it. “I haven’t lost anything.”

“You’re about to. You can’t help it.” Wolfe wiggled a finger at him. “Must I spell it out for you? Wednesday evening, day before yesterday, when you and six others were here, I was nonplused. I had my choice of giving up or of attempting simultaneously a dozen elaborate lines of inquiry, any one of which would have strained my resources. Neither was tolerable. Since I was helpless with what had already happened, I had to try to make something happen under my eye, and I devised a stratagem — a clumsy one, but the best I could do. I made a proposal to Mr. and Mrs. Rackell. I phrased it with care, but in effect I asked for money to bribe a witness and solve the case by chicanery.”

Wolfe’s eyes darted to Mrs. Rackell. “And you idiotically exposed yourself.”

“I did?” She was contemptuous. “How?”

“You grabbed at it. Your husband, in his innocence, was dubious, but not you. You thought that, having decided the job was beyond me, I was trying to earn a fee by knavery, and you eagerly acquiesced. Why? It was out of character and indeed preposterous. What you had said you wanted was the murderer of your nephew caught and punished, but apparently you were willing to spend a large sum of money, your own money, on a frame-up. Either that or you were excessively naive, and at least it justified speculation.”

His gaze was straight at her, and she was meeting it. He went on, “So I speculated. What if you had yourself killed your nephew? As for getting the poison, that was as feasible for you as for the others. As for opportunity, you said you had not entered your nephew’s room after Mrs. Kremp had been there and put the capsules in the pillbox, but could you prove it? There was nothing to my knowledge that excluded you. Your harassment of the FBI and the police could have been for assurance that you were safe. It was your husband who insisted on coming to me, and naturally you would have wanted to be present. As for motive, that would have to be explored, but for speculation there was material at hand, furnished by you. You were positive, with no real evidence for it, that your nephew had been killed by a Communist who had discovered that he was betraying the cause; you got that in first thing when you called here Tuesday with your husband. Might it not be true and you yourself the Communist?”

“Rot!” She snorted.

Wolfe shook his head. “Not necessarily. I deplore the current tendency to accuse people of pro-communism irresponsibly and unjustly, but anybody could be one secretly, no matter what façade he presented. There was the question, if you were in fact a Communist or a sympathizer, why did you so badger your nephew that he had to pacify you by telling the lie that he was working for the FBI? Why didn’t you confide in him your own devotion to the cause? Of course you didn’t dare. There would have been the danger that he might recant; he might have become an ex-Communist and told all he knew, as so many have done the past year or two; and to preserve your façade for your husband and friends you had to keep after him. It must have been a severe shock when you learned, or thought you did, that he was an agent of communism’s implacable enemy. It made him an imminent threat, there in your own household.”

Wolfe came forward in his chair. “That was all speculation two days ago, but not now. Your meeting with Mr. Heath has made it a confident assumption. Why would you make a secret rendezvous with him? What could give him the right to demand that you withdraw the offer of money for Miss Devlin? Well. If you are secretly a Communist, almost certainly you have contributed substantial sums of money — to the party of course, but also to the bail fund; and Mr. Heath is the trustee of the bail fund and is inviting a term in jail rather than disclose the names of the contributors. So, madam, my stratagem worked — with, I confess, a full share of luck. Mr, Goodwin and I have been under some strain. Until a few minutes ago, when he entered and told me you two were here, I wouldn’t have wagered a nickel on it. Now it’s over, thank heaven. My assumptions are on rock. You’re cooked.”

“You’re a conceited fool,” Mrs. Rackell said flatly. For the first time I thought she was really impressive. He hadn’t made a dent in her. She was still dead sure of herself. “With your crazy assumptions,” she said. “I was resting on a park bench, and this Mr. Heath came along and spoke.” She darted a contemptuous glance at Saul. “Whatever lies that man tells about what he heard.”

Wolfe nodded. “That of course is your best position, and no doubt you’re capable of defending it against all assault, so I won’t try butting it.” He looked at Heath. “But yours is much weaker, and I don’t see how you can hold it.”

“I have withstood better men than you,” Heath declared. “Men in positions of great power. Men who head the imperialist conspiracy to dominate the world.”

“No doubt,” Wolfe conceded. “But even if you appraise them correctly, which I question, right now you have to appraise me. I head no conspiracy to dominate anything, but I’ve got you in a hole you can’t scramble out of. Must I spell it out for you? You’re a trustee of that Communist bail fund, amounting to nearly a million dollars, and at great personal risk you are determined to keep the names of the contributors secret. Court orders haven’t budged you. Obviously you prefer any alternative to disclosure of the names. But you’re going to disclose one of them to me now: Mrs. Benjamin Rackell. And the amounts and dates of her contributions. Well?”

“No comment.”

“Pfui. I say you can’t hold it. Consider what’s going to happen. I am convinced that Mrs. Rackell murdered her nephew because she thought he was spying on Communists for the FBI, and therefore, of course, her own secret was in danger. The FBI and the police will now share that conviction. Whether it takes a day or a year, do you think there’s any chance we won’t get her? Knowing she had the poison, do you think we won’t discover where and how she got it?”

Wolfe shook his head. “No. You’ll have to ditch her. She’s too hot to hold. The police will put it to you — have you any knowledge or evidence that she has been in sympathy with the Communist cause? You say no or refuse to answer. Subsequently they get such evidence, with proof that you were aware of it; it is easily possible that, through some process which you cannot avert, they will get the whole list of contributors. And instead of a brief commitment for contempt of court you’ll get a considerable term for withholding vital evidence in a murder case. Besides, what of the cause you’re devoted to? You know the opinion of communism held by most Americans, including me. To the odium already attached to it would you add the stigma of shielding a murderer?”

Wolfe raised his brows. “Really, Mr. Heath. There are plenty of precedents to guide you. This will be by no means the first time that an act of misguided zeal by a Communist has come home to roost. In the countries they rule the jails are full — let alone the graves — of former comrades who were indiscreet. In America, where you don’t rule and I hope you never will, can you afford the luxury of shielding a murderer? No. She’s too much for you. How much has she contributed and when?”

Heath’s face was really something. If he hadn’t inherited money he could have piled it up playing poker. From looking at him no one could have got the faintest notion how to bet.