Erle Gardner - Case of the Silent Partner

“Is that enough to keep him busy?”

“It was when there was more of it.”

Mason smiled. “I take it things haven’t gone so well under his management.”

“No.”

“What does your sister say to that?”

She said, “Carla developed heart trouble about a year ago. She didn’t go to a doctor as soon as she should have. She kept on in a mad round of activity, and by the time she had to give in to it, she was pretty far gone. The doctor says it will take a long time before he can bring her back to normal. In the meantime, she isn’t to be excited, or worried.”

“She knows the true state of her finances?” Mason asked.

Mildreth Faulkner said, with feeling, “I hope to God she does.”

“But you’ve never asked her?”

“We don’t talk about her husband,” she said. “I never did like him. Carla thought I was prejudiced.”

“She loves him?”

“Crazy about him. He’s smart enough to keep her that way. A little flattery and those little attentions which women crave are all that’s necessary. You know how it is with a man when the wife has the money. It’s a shame more men can’t learn that lesson, but it seems that only the ones who are in a position to profit financially ever do it.”

“I take it you didn’t approve of the match in the first place.”

“I certainly did not. I always thought Bob was a weak sister, a fortune hunter, and a four-flusher.”

“And I take it he knows that?”

“He does. Oh, we’ve tried to be civilized about the thing. We’ve gotten along all right. Occasionally, before Carla’s heart got bad, we’d go on week-end trips together, and Bob would be so nice to me that butter wouldn’t melt in his mouth. Then Carla would look at me as much as to say, ‘Can’t you see how perfectly swell he is, Millie?’ ”

“And what would you do?” Mason asked.

She said, “I’d try to be just as oily and smooth as he was, but I was burning up inside. I don’t mind a man who’s frankly on the make, but I do hate mealy-mouthed hypocrisy.”

Mason said, “Well, that’s the background. What comes next?”

“Bob has Carla’s complete confidence. When her heart went bad, Bob started managing all of her affairs. When she’d ask questions, he told her it was no time to bother with business details, that things were going simply grand.”

“And you didn’t believe that?”

“I knew it wasn’t true.”

“How?”

“Well, about a week ago, Bob was in an automobile accident. No one would have thought anything of it if it hadn’t been for the way he started making glib explanations. When you get to know Bob, he’s like an open book. If he’s going to lie, he’ll rehearse it so carefully that the pieces all fit together so smoothly that — well, it’s just too good to be true. It’s like a gilded lily or a painted rose.”

“So he lied about the automobile accident?”

“Yes... when I asked him about it.”

“And you started checking up on him?”

She flushed slightly, and said, “When Peavis came in and asked to have that stock transferred on the books of the corporation, I began to do a lot of thinking. I realized suddenly that if someone controlled that five shares of stock and then could get Carla’s block of stock, he’d have complete control of the corporation. I suppose it was very foolish of us, but we never thought of anything like that because it was all a family affair. I’d even forgotten about those five shares of stock, because we just went ahead with the business and did what we wanted. We never do have a directors’ meeting, and there hasn’t been a stockholders’ meeting for three years. Well, anyway, that five shares of stock represents the balance of power.”

“I presume,” Mason said, “you’re leading up to telling me that your brother-in-law has managed to get control of the stock your sister held.”

“That’s exactly it, only it’s worse than that. Bob evidently has been plunging pretty heavily. Carla has unlimited confidence in him. She gave him a complete power of attorney, and endorsed all of her securities in blank when she got sick. The doctor said she wasn’t to be bothered with business affairs. I always did think that Bob had a finger in that pie somewhere, and got the doctor to say that. It would have been rather easy to do, telling the doctor that Carla worried a lot about business.”

Mason nodded. “Any idea where the stock is?” he asked.

She said, “It’s apparently in the hands of a man by the name of Lynk who is one of the owners of the Golden Horn. The girl with whom my brother-in-law was riding at the time of the accident is a glamour girl who acts as decoy for— She’s supposed to be here. She’s the one I telephoned about. I’m expecting her any minute.”

Mason said, “She isn’t coming.”

“What do you mean?”

“Someone sent her a box of poisoned candy. She rang me up about eleven-thirty, and could hardly talk. She apparently collapsed while she was talking over the telephone.”

“Sent her poisoned candy!” Mildreth Faulkner exclaimed.

Mason nodded.

“But who on earth could have done that?”

Mason said, “There was a card on the candy box. It said, ‘These will make you feel better,’ and was signed simply with the initials ‘M.F.’ Do you know anything about that?”

She looked at him, her eyes getting round. “Why, Mr. Mason— That card— Why, I sent it!”

“With the candy?” Mason asked.

“Good heavens, no! Understand, Mr. Mason, I started doing a little detective work. That automobile accident was my clue. I realized after Peavis called on me what an awful fix I’d be in if Bob had done something with that stock. I knew Carla had endorsed it and given him a power of attorney.”

“But I thought it was Lynk who had the stock.”

“I think Peavis either put him up to it, or Lynk is in touch with Peavis.”

“I see. Tell me about that card.”

“Well, as soon as Bob started talking about the accident with all those glib explanations, I realized at once that if there was anything wrong, that automobile accident would have something to do with it. I knew that there was something about that accident he didn’t want me to find out. So I investigated. I could do that very easily because the other party had reported it to the Traffic Department. It seems that at the time of the accident, Bob had just left the Golden Horn and had a man named Sindler Coll, who I think is a gambler, and Esther Dilmeyer in the car with him.

“I don’t think Bob would deliberately surrender the stock in order to get money to gamble, but I think they’d persuaded him his credit was good, and he’d plunged pretty deeply and had some bad luck. They’d given him something that was supposed to be a sure thing, and he wanted to collect a lot of winnings before he had to pay out his losses.”

“All right, what about the card?”

She laughed. “I do seem to be getting all involved in explanations, don’t I? Well, anyway, I went to the Golden Horn and managed to get acquainted with Esther Dilmeyer. She was feeling pretty low tonight. I gathered that she and Sindler Coll had been — well, pretty sweet on each other, and apparently he’d...”

Mason said, “All right. How about the card?”

She said, “I sent her some orchids.”

“When?”

“When I left. She was feeling blue, and I told her I was in the flower business.”

“She told you about the stock?” Mason asked.

“Not about the stock, but generally what was going on.”

“Would Peavis surrender that stock if you threatened to sue?”

“Not Peavis,” she said. “When he once gets his hands on anything, he hangs on until the last ditch. We might get the stock back, but we’d have five years of litigation doing it — and we might as well sell him control of the company as do that. But tell me, Mr. Mason, how did it happen that you thought my card was in the candy? That card was on the orchids.”