Arthur Upfield - An Author Bites the Dust

“Smythe-blast his silly hyphen-looked all right, though his hair was dishevelled and his clothes were creased and slightly stained. He said he felt all right, except for a stiff jaw, wanted his breakfast, and wished to return to his hotel. He said he had been grossly assaulted, but for what reason he didn’t know because he hadn’t been robbed. And he didn’t want to lay a complaint, let alone make a statement.”

“Did he say why?” asked Bony.

“Yes. He said that as he hadn’t been robbed he didn’t want the matter to go further and get into the newspapers. He liked publicity, being an author, but not publicity of that kind. I told him I could not have that sort of thing going on in my district, and that he must give me all the details.

“He said he was out last evening walking along the highway towards Yarrabo when a car overtook him, stopped, and two men jumped out. He was able to see that both had handkerchiefs draped under their eyes. One was a largeman, the other was tall and lean. The large man pointed a pistol at him and ordered him to get into the car. Smythe said he couldn’t do anything else but obey, and he got into the back seat where he was followed by the big man. The other got into the driving seat.

“The car was driven through Yarrabo and then turned off the highway on to what we know as the Old Warburton Road. This road is now in disuse after the first half-mile, where there is a house. The car passed the house, and then began to climb the track, which passes a stone-crusher and then winds up and round, past the quarry and on for some distance.

“Then the car was stopped and Smythe was forced out and made to walk up off the road to the tree. He was lashed to the tree and gagged with his own handkerchief. That was about nine last night and he was there until found by Jenks shortly after half past seven this morning. Luckily for him, it was a warm night.”

“What was he tied to the tree with?”

“Old, but still good, half-inch rope,” replied Simes. “The gag was kept in position with ordinary parcel string.”

“Wilcannia-Smythe did not even suggest a motive for the assault?”

“No. He was angry all right, but not angry enough, in my opinion. If anyone had tied me to a tree and left me there all night, I’d be fighting mad. The explanation he thought might hold water was that he had been mistaken for someone else.”

“H’m! Interesting. Did you visit the scene?”

“Yes. I went out there with Jenks. It just happens that everything I know about the bush old Jenks taught me. It happened, too, that Jenks stopped his car yards away from the place where the kidnappers stopped their car, and he was careful not to overrun that car’s tracks. When I went back with him, both of us avoided spoiling the tracks from the kidnappers’ car to the trees and down again, for I knew you’d want to look at them, too.”

“Good man!” murmured Bony.

“Jenks and I agreed that one man was wearing a size sevenboot or shoe, and that the other man was wearing the same size in shoe-leather.”

“But you said-”

“I know. Wilcannia-Smythe said that one man was big and the other tall and lean. He gave me the impression that the big man would wear a bigger size in boots than a seven.”

“Even a big man may have comparatively small feet, and wear a seven boot,” Bony pointed out

“Those tracks still prove that Smythe is a liar.”

“Indeed. How so?”

“Smythe said that one man was large and the other man was tall,” Simes said with slow deliberation. “Jenks and I first saw the tracks of the three men where the car stopped. Then we followed the three sets of tracks up to the tree, being careful not to overstep ’em. We agreed that one man was lean, but not taller than five feet ten, and that the other man was about as tall and slightly heavier. Our agreement was based on the length of stride taken by both men.”

“Ah!” murmured Bony. “Good work, Simes, good work. Mr Wilcannia-Smythe’s inaccuracies do not confirm the theory that he was mistakenly kidnapped for someone else. Whatd’youthink?”

“The tracks don’t fit into his statement, and his demeanour doesn’t fit in, either,” Simes said with conviction. “It’s likely that he knew who kidnapped him, and why. I think that the reason was not revenge so much as to get him away from his hotel or some place for the night.”

“It’s feasible, Simes. Do you think that the kidnappers intended to return to release Wilcannia-Smythe, or let him stay there to rot? What’s the position of the tree in relation to the road?”

“I’m inclined to think that the tree was very well chosen, because no one coming down the road or going up the road could fail to see Smythe lashed to it.”

“Would there be many people likely to use the road at that place?”

“Yes. Beyond the camp occupied by Jenks there is another occupied by a dozen men who are at work cutting afirebreak. They have a truck there, and that truck is driven to Yarrabo every day. Why?”

“It would seem that the kidnappers knew that road intimately, and were aware of the use made of it by forestry workers. Unless, of course, they intended to return there tonight to make sure that Wilcannia-Smythe had been released. It would hardly be their intention to leave him there to die. I’d like you to take me out there.”

“All right! I’ll see how that tea’s coming along. Like to read my report?”

Simes was back again within the minute, carrying the tea-tray with the skill of a club steward.

“I forgot to tell you,” he said. “Dr Fleetwood wants to see you.”

“Please ring him and ascertain if six o’clock this evening will suit him.”

Bony poured tea into two cups, and sipped from his own with genuine relish. Simes replaced the telephone saying that the doctor would be at home that evening at six, and he drank his tea without apparent consciousness of its temperature, regarding Bony like a man who has many questions to ask.

Bony said, almost languidly, “Life is like a moving picture that can’t be stopped. There would be few successful investigations into homicide if murders would, or could, suspend their own animation for a few months. In very many cases it is what they do after the crime that brings them to face the judge, not what they did before it. I am going to accept the responsibility of asking you to retain your report on this Wilcannia-Smythe incident. I agree with you that this Wilcannia-Smythe affair may have an important bearing on the Blake case, and the Blake case, my dear Simes, belongs to you and me. Have you ever been inside Mrs Blake’s garage?”

“Yes, I was in there the day after the discovery of Blake’s body,” Simes answered. “I helped Sub-Inspector Martin to examine the place for-anything unusual. Nothing unusual was found.”

“Did you come across any spirits-whisky or brandy?”

“No.”

“There is a cupboard in the garage. What did that contain, d’youremember?”

“Yes. Battery acid and distilled water. Cleaning rags and tins of polish.”

“No spirits?”

Simes shook his head.

“Any drinking glasses?”

“No.”

“How long have you known Sid Walsh?”

“Why, ever since I took up duty here.”

“H’m! Let us go along to examine those tracks. Thanks for not asking pertinent questions. When I establish anything of value, I’ll let you have it.”

The policeman’s car was standing at the rear of the station, and at the end of ten minutes they had passed the stone-crusher on the Old Warburton Road. Swinging round a bend, they saw the road running almost straight for two hundred yards when it was thrust to the right by the hill-slope. At that right turn the slope above the road was denuded of trees save one growing eighty or ninety yards up the slope, and on reaching the turn it could be seen that the road ran again straight for almost a hundred yards. Thus anyone approaching that bend from either direction would be bound to note the tree growing in solitary state.