David Dickinson - Death of a wine merchant

‘And why, pray, do I have to get on another train and then another one after that? I’ve only just got off the last one.’

‘While you fetch your bag, Johnny, I am going to write down for you the main points of what we have discovered here. It is most germane to the trial of Cosmo Colville. We don’t know when the trial starts. It could have started already. It is most important that Charles Augustus Pugh receives my note at the earliest possible moment. It could mean the difference between victory and defeat. It’s too sensitive to entrust it to the cable companies. The information could fall into the wrong hands. Lucy will go with you and tell you what we’ve found out while you fetch your bags.’

Five minutes later Johnny Fitzgerald was tucked up in another cab, bound for the station. The cabbie was astonished for it was the same man who had brought him from the station to the hotel less than an hour before. In his breast pocket he had two pages of Powerscourt’s finest handwriting with the details of their discoveries. He leant out of the window as he left, waving his enormous glass at them.

‘Could you sort out the cost of this glass with the barman, Francis? Haven’t been able to finish it yet, damned thing’s so big it must hold about the same amount as a bloody bottle.’

On the outside Charles Augustus Pugh appeared confident, sure of his ground as he strode into Court Two of the Old Bailey on the opening day of the trial of Cosmo Colville for the murder of his brother. He smiled at the chief counsel for the prosecution, Sir Jasper Bentinck, and made a slight bow to the judge, Mr Justice Black. The court was full, with the members of the public crammed into their seats and looking forward to the show. It was not every day after all that you could see a senior member of one of London’s leading wine merchants on trial for the murder of his brother. Pugh turned from his table to whisper something to his junior, an industrious young man recently arrived in the Pugh chambers by the name of Napier.

Inwardly, Pugh felt more unhappy about this case than he had about any of his previous outings as principal counsel for the defence. He had little fresh evidence and what he had did not inspire him. He was going to have to proceed through a policy of innuendo and suggestion which was alien to his nature. He was going to have to make his appeal to the Doubting Thomas side of the jury rather than the Sir Lancelot. His principal collaborator in this trial, Lord Francis Powerscourt, had vanished into the hills and vineyards of Burgundy and had not returned. Pugh had begun work on this case with high hopes that Powerscourt might pull an enormous rabbit out of a hat at the very last moment as he had the last time the two of them had worked together. Today there was no sign of anything at all, not even a minute mouse with a minuscule tail.

The area reserved for members of the public was crammed. So was the area reserved for the gentlemen of the press. Many members of the public were regular consumers of the Colville products and had come to see the one who had killed his brother. Others had heard rumours of the defendant who had not spoken a word since the murder and had come to Court Two of the Old Bailey to inspect a man whose silence might cost him his life. The pressmen too had heard, of course, of Cosmo’s silence. Their collective memory, even when fortified by Colvilles’ finest in the Bunch of Grapes at the end of Fleet Street, could not recall such a silent witness in living memory.

Pugh turned to inspect the jury. They seemed younger than the normal run of juries, he thought. They sat up in their place looking very serious, conscious perhaps that over the next few days they held a man’s life in their hands.

Sir Jasper rose to begin the case for the prosecution. He called Georgina Nash as chatelaine of the great house where the events had taken place.

‘Mrs Nash. Could you tell the gentlemen of the jury what was happening at your house on the day in question?’

‘Of course,’ she replied. ‘There was a wedding, my daughter’s wedding.’

‘And could you tell us who your daughter was marrying, Mrs Nash?’

‘She was marrying Montague Colville, son of Mr Randolph Colville and Mrs Hermione Colville.’

‘Did the service go off satisfactorily, Mrs Nash? And could you tell us how many guests were in attendance? Not a precise figure, you understand, just a general idea.’

‘The service was fine. The bride was late, but brides often are. I think I cried but then mothers often do at weddings, I believe. And we had a hundred guests or so.’

‘So what happened after the service, Mrs Nash? Perhaps you could give an idea of the sequence of events leading up to the murder.’

‘After the service everybody came back to the house. We served them champagne in the garden. I remember feeling rather cross because the gardeners hadn’t fixed the fountain. It’s a very impressive fountain when it’s working properly. It sits in the middle of the lawn where everybody can see it. I must have asked those gardeners three or four times.’

‘Mrs Nash,’ Sir Jasper was at his most emollient, ‘I don’t think we need concern ourselves about the fountain today.’

‘Sorry, Sir Jasper.’ Georgina Nash looked at the judge, unsure if she should apologize to him too, but she pressed on. ‘I think the champagne lasted about half an hour. Then we began to bring people up to the Long Gallery where the food was to be served. There were two seating plans on display in the garden for people to see where they were going and another two indoors, one in the Great Hall and another at the top of the stairs.’

‘In my experience, Mrs Nash, not that I possess a Long Gallery like yours in my modest home, these manoeuvres involving large numbers of people can take a long time, far longer than one would think.’

Charles Augustus Pugh scribbled a quick note to his junior Richard Napier. ‘Bentinck’s modest home runs over five floors in Holland Park,’ the message said. ‘Enormous garden the size of three or four tennis courts. Platoons of servants. Must be worth a bloody fortune.’

Georgina Nash carried on: ‘How right you are, Sir Jasper.’ She smiled a bright smile at him. Pugh thought you could almost hear Sir Jasper purr. ‘It did take a long time, far longer than I had thought.’

‘So here we are, Mrs Nash, a grand wedding in a grand country house, the guests sipping their champagne in the garden then making their way up to the Long Gallery for the wedding lunch. Perhaps you could tell us, Mrs Nash, how you first became aware of the unfortunate incident which has brought us here today. Were all the guests seated by then?’

‘No, they were not, Sir Jasper. Some of them were still milling about looking for their places. I remember thinking how noisy it all was. Then there was a sharp bang from the rooms at the end of the Long Gallery which I later gathered was the gun being fired.’

‘And how were you informed of what had happened, Mrs Nash?’

Georgina Nash paused. ‘The first I knew about it was when Charlie Healey, our butler, rushed in looking very strained. He whispered something to my husband. Willoughby told me what had happened, about Mr Randolph Colville lying dead on the floor and Mr Cosmo Colville sitting on a chair holding the gun. Everything became something of a blur after that. I felt so sorry for my daughter with her big day ruined and for the guests, many of whom had come a long way.’

‘Quite so, Mrs Nash, quite so.’ Sir Jasper made it sound as if he himself had been one of the unfortunate long distance travellers whose celebration of a wedding turned into a wake. He pressed on with a few more questions about the arrival of the police before he sat down.