Nancy Grace - Murder in the Courthouse

“I mean what normal, red-blooded man wouldn’t give in? After all, he’s only human . But I assure you… it was all her. I assure you. All her!”

Without thinking, Eunah Mabry lifted the wine glass from the coffee table instead of her coffee, held it up as if in a toast, and drained the tiny bit of wine left in the bottom. Hailey stared, saying nothing. Mabry slammed the wine glass back on the table almost defiantly, her anger and loathing boiling just beneath the surface.

The hate in her voice, the sofa-matted hair hanging in scraggly tendrils around her face, the smeared lipstick, the stink of old cigarettes combined with a glint of pure malice in her voice all combined to give Eunah Mabry the appearance of being… somewhat maniacal.

Or maybe she wasn’t. Maybe Mabry was simply an aging woman, living alone, lonely and disliking it. Likely scorned-or worse, not even noticed-by the man she appeared to have loved for many years, Judge Bill Regard.

“Well, the judge is married, right? His wife must have been livid about Eleanor Odom… if she knew about it.”

“Oh, that one. Well she’s a piece of work herself, let me tell you that. Rich family, new money, you know, showy, private schools, never worked a day in her life. Blind to the man she married… couldn’t care less. Spends all her time at the country club with the tennis pro and I will say no more. I’m not one to gossip. Evil, foul thing, gossip is. My daddy always said that and he was right.”

“Absolutely. And you, Eunah Mabry, strike me as a woman who would never say a false word, let alone gossip.” Hailey said it with the straightest face she could muster. Was this woman still drunk? Or just hungover?

“Actually, it’s almost lunchtime. Would you care for a cordial? A small glass of wine?”

Hailey glanced over at a grandfather clock standing solemnly in the corner. It plainly said ten-thirty.

Ignoring the drink offer, Hailey went on. “Earlier, you mentioned a scandal?”

“Did I?” Eunah looked almost surprised.

“Yes. Something to do with Eleanor Odom?”

“Oh, of course. The scandal of it all … to drop dead just before the governor’s race really heats up. I mean… what if the press connects her back to the judge? Not that there’s anything to connect… but what if they did? It could ruin everything! Everything!”

Hailey didn’t answer, merely held Eunah’s gaze as if willing her to go on. And she did.

“If someone knew how she chased him and thought they were putting two and two together… I mean… for him to be connected to a girl like… like… her . What if someone thought he was somehow…”

“Somehow what?”

“Somehow responsible. He’s not, of course! But having someone like… like Eleanor Odom pop up during a political race… I mean, after all, the woman keels over one floor directly under the judge’s chambers! And, of course, she had to put on quite the performance, even in death. With everyone looking at her. Just as she always wanted… everyone… the judge… looking at her .”

Just then, a horn beeped very close by. Eunah leaped from her seat and instinctively turned toward a mirror hanging on the wall beside them, patting her hair into place. With her two index fingers, she wiped the corners of her mouth where lipstick mixed with red wine had gathered and crusted over.

“Oh dear, it might be the judge! He’s here to pick up some letters and orders I finished up for him last night at the courthouse.”

She practically flew to one of the front windows, pulled the gauzy white sheers to one side, and peeked out. “It’s him!”

Eunah Mabry hurried over to a hardwood secretary, eighteenth century by the look of it, and pulled back the roll top to scoop up a good eight inches of stacked papers. Several yellow stickies stuck out on the sides with handwritten instructions on them.

The doorbell rang. Hailey remained seated, but she could easily hear the conversation at the door.

“Well, good morning, Eunah! You must have slept like a baby… you look absolutely gorgeous this morning!”

“Judge! How you go on! Please, won’t you come in for a cup of coffee?”

“Well, I, uh…” the judge stalled.

“Or a glass of wine? I have your favorite, you know!”

“Eunah… nothing, absolutely nothing, would please me more than to come in and have a glass of wine with you and just visit. You know, I miss that. Just visiting with you. We’ve just been so busy with the upcoming race and all… and… to tell you the truth…” he paused.

“Yes, Judge?” Desperation was creeping into Eunah’s voice.

“Well, I can’t lie to you, Eunah. You know me better than I know myself. I’ve got Mrs. Regard in the car with me. She has a tennis tournament at the club and she’s in a hurry. And… you know how she is, Eunah.”

On cue, the horn blew as if ordering the judge to hurry up. It wasn’t a little toot, either. It was a much longer, agitated blow, like a jab to the back or an elbow to the rib. It was a subtle but important difference in horn blowing that anyone in the South would recognize and immediately take issue with.

“I understand, Judge. Maybe next time?” Her voice actually quivered.

“Absolutely next time. It’s a date, Eunah. I’m looking forward to it.”

No wonder Eunah Mabry fell in love. This guy was certainly a charmer. Hailey paused. Wonder who else was in love with him?

Hailey stood up from the sofa almost involuntarily. She silently stepped over to the window. Looking out between the sheers, there in the circular driveway behind Hailey’s rental sat a metallic baby blue Mercedes convertible SL65. The new ones listed at more than $200,000. Hailey let out a low whistle. That wasn’t cheap and it certainly wasn’t affordable on a county judge’s salary.

The top was down and Hailey could easily see Victoria Regard in the passenger’s seat. She had pale white skin, dark silky hair cut in a bob curling in around her neck, and black Jackie O glasses.

Victoria Regard reached her left hand over. The horn blew again. Hailey noticed she didn’t bother to look up at her husband and Eunah across the front porch at the front door.

“Gotta run, Eunah. But I’ll see you Monday morning, OK?”

“Of course, Judge. I’ll see you… Monday morning.” Eunah’s voice was noticeably thin, almost cracking.

“Promise? You won’t run off with the mailman? We’ll have coffee like we always do? You make the best coffee in the world. I wish you’d give tips to Mrs. Regard; hers tastes like poison!” Hailey imagined he had the same inviting smile he wore in the photo with Scorsese, thin upper lip, full lower one, curved up at one corner.

“Promise,” she said it so quietly that Hailey could barely hear her.

Hailey quickly left the window and settled back at her seat before Eunah returned. She heard the front door close quietly, followed by the Mercedes’s motor gunning and the sound of gravel churning as the car scratched off.

Eunah Mabry came around the corner and into Hailey’s view. She gripped the side of the wall with one hand as if she needed support. She held the fingertips of her other hand to her temple.

“Miss… ah…”

“Dean. Hailey Dean,” Hailey interjected quickly to save her the embarrassment of having forgotten her name.

“Yes. Miss Dean, I seem to have developed a terrible headache. Would it be too rude if I asked you if we could continue our conversation about the judge’s campaign at a later time?”

“Of course! I’m so sorry to have barged in on you like this. And thank you for the coffee and the conversation. It’s such a pleasure to meet you and see your lovely home.”