Peter Robinson - Aftermath

After the chaos of the weekend, the police station was back to its normal level of activity; the reporters had disappeared, just as Lucy Payne had. Banks wasn’t overly concerned about Lucy’s going missing, he thought as he closed his office door and turned on the radio. She would probably turn up again, and even if she didn’t, there was no real cause for concern. Not unless they came up with some concrete evidence against her. At least in the meantime, they could keep track of her through ATM withdrawals and credit card transactions. No matter where she was, she would need money.

After he had finished the paperwork, Banks went into the squad room. DC Winsome Jackman was sitting at her desk chewing on the end of a pencil.

“Winsome,” he said, remembering one of the details that had awoken him so early in the morning, “I’ve got another job for you.”

And when he’d told her what he wanted her to do, he left by the back exit and set off for Leeds.

It was just after lunch when Annie entered the CPS offices, though she hadn’t managed to grab a bite to eat herself yet. The Crown solicitor appointed to the case, Jack Whitaker, turned out to be younger than she had expected, late twenties or early thirties, she guessed, prematurely balding, and he spoke with a slight lisp. His handshake was firm, his palm just a little damp. His office was certainly far tidier than Stafford Oakes’s in Eastvale, where every file was out of place and stained with an Olympic symbol of coffee rings.

“Any new developments?” he asked after Annie had sat down.

“Yes,” said Annie. “PC Taylor changed her statement this morning.”

“May I?”

Annie handed him Janet Taylor’s revised statement, and Whitaker read it over. When he’d finished, he slid the papers over the desk back toward Annie. “What do you think?” she asked.

“I think,” Jack Whitaker said slowly, “that we might be charging Janet Taylor with murder.”

“What?” Annie couldn’t believe what she’d just heard. “She acted as a policewoman in pursuit of her duty. I was thinking justifiable homicide, or, at the very most, excusable. But murder ?”

Whitaker sighed. “Oh, dear. I don’t suppose you’ve heard the news, then?”

“What news?” Annie hadn’t turned on the radio when she drove down to Leeds, being far too preoccupied with Janet’s case and her confused feelings about Banks to concentrate on news or chat.

“The jury came back on the John Hadleigh case just before lunch. You know, the Devon farmer.”

“I know about the Hadleigh case. What was the verdict?”

“Guilty of murder.”

“Jesus Christ,” said Annie. “But even so, surely that’s different entirely? I mean, Hadleigh was civilian. He shot a burglar in the back. Janet Taylor-”

Whitaker held his hand up. “The point is that it’s a clear message. Given the Hadleigh verdict, we have to be seen to be acting fairly toward everyone. We can’t afford to have the press screaming at us for going easy on Janet Taylor just because she’s a policewoman.”

“So it is political?”

“Isn’t it always? Justice must be seen to be done.”

“Justice?”

Whitaker raised his eyebrows. “Listen,” he said, “I can understand your sympathies; believe me, I can. But according to her statement, Janet Taylor handcuffed Terence Payne to a metal pipe after she had already subdued him, then she hit him twice with her baton. Hard. Think about it, Annie. That’s deliberate. That’s murder.”

“She didn’t necessarily mean to kill him. There was no intent.”

“That’s for a jury to decide. A good prosecutor could argue that she knew damn well what the effect of two more hard blows to the head would be after she’d already given him seven previous blows.”

“I can’t believe I’m hearing this,” Annie said.

“No one’s sorrier than I am,” said Whitaker.

“Except Janet Taylor.”

“Then she shouldn’t have killed Terence Payne.”

“What the hell do you know? You weren’t there, in that cellar, with your partner bleeding to death on the floor, a dead girl staked out on a mattress. You didn’t have just seconds to react to a man coming at you with a machete. This is a bloody farce! It’s politics, is all it is.”

“Calm down, Annie,” said Whitaker.

Annie stood up and paced, arms folded. “Why should I? I don’t feel calm. This woman has been going through hell. I provoked her into changing her statement because I thought it would go better for her in the long run than saying she couldn’t remember. How does this make me look?”

“Is that all you’re concerned about? How it makes you look?”

“Of course it’s not.” Annie lowered herself slowly back into the chair. She still felt flushed and angry, her breath coming in sharp gasps. “But it makes me look like a liar. It makes it look as if I tricked her. I don’t like that.”

“You were only doing your job.”

“Only doing my job. Only obeying orders. Right. Thanks. That makes me feel a whole lot better.”

“Look, we might be able to get a bit of leeway here, Annie, but there’ll have to be a trial. It’ll all have to be a matter of public record. Aboveboard. There’ll be no sweeping it under the table.”

“That’s not what I had in mind, anyway. What leeway?”

“I don’t suppose Janet Taylor would plead guilty to murder.”

“Damn right she wouldn’t, and I wouldn’t advise her to.”

“It’s not exactly a matter of advising . Besides, that’s not your job. What do you think she would plead guilty to?”

“Excusable homicide.”

“It wasn’t self-defense. Not when she crossed the line and delivered those final blows after Payne was rendered incapable of defending himself or of attacking her further.”

“What, then?”

“Voluntary manslaughter.”

“How long would she have to serve?”

“Between eighteen months and three years.”

“That’s still a long time, especially for a copper in jail.”

“Not as long as John Hadleigh.”

“Hadleigh shot a kid in the back with a shotgun.”

“Janet Taylor beat a defenseless man about the head with a police baton, causing his death.”

“He was a serial killer.”

“She didn’t know that at the time.”

“But he came at her with a machete!”

“And after she’d disarmed him, she used more force than necessary to subdue him, causing his death. Annie, it doesn’t matter that he was a serial killer. It wouldn’t matter if he’d been Jack the bloody Ripper.”

“He’d cut her partner. She was upset.”

“Well, I’m certainly glad to hear she wasn’t calm, cool and collected when she did it.”

“You know what I mean. There’s no need for sarcasm.”

“Sorry. I’m sure the judge and jury will take the whole picture into account, her state of mind.”

Annie sighed. She felt sick. As soon as this farce was over she was getting the hell out of Complaints and Discipline, back to real police work, catching the villains.

“All right,” she said. “What next?”

“You know what next, Annie. Find Janet Taylor. Arrest her, take her to the police station and charge her with voluntary manslaughter.”

“Someone asking to see you, sir.”

Why was the fresh-faced PC who popped his head around the door of Banks’s temporary office at Millgarth smirking? Banks wondered. “Who is it?” he asked.

“You’d better see for yourself, sir.”

“Can’t someone else deal with it?”

“She specifically asked to see someone in charge of the missing girls case, sir. Area Commander Hartnell’s in Wakefield with the ACC, and DCI Blackstone’s out. That leaves you, sir.”