Arthur Upfield: Death of a Lake

Inspector Bonaparte Works

AFTERBREAKFAST, eaten before sun-up, everyone went into action, determined to accomplish as much as possible before the intense heat once again singed the earth and them. By nine o’clock the heat was severe, but a high-level haze smoked the sky and forecast a change accompanied by wind.

SergeantMansell and his constable appeared much interested in the interior of the machinery shed, whilst the others, including the owner and the overseer, relaxed on the veranda of the quarters.

Then the constable crossed to the group on the veranda to address Bony:

“Sergeant would like a few words with you.”

The general conversation petered out as Bony accompanied the policeman to the machinery shed. The doors were wide, the roof was high, the temperature was not yet unbearable. Packing-cases had been placed to form a desk and serve as seats, and the sergeant was taking from his brief-case paper, pens and ink.

“This do, Inspector?” he asked a little stiffly.

“Yes. We’llsit, so. As we deal with each of these people they must be kept here, not allowed to circulate. We’ll begin with Carney. All right, Constable. Produce Henry Carney.”

Like those who were to follow him, Carney received a succession of surprises. He was surprised by finding Bony sitting withMansell behind the ‘desk’, and was surprised by the invitation to sit on a tea-chest before them. Carney had been told that the sergeant wanted a few words with him, therefore the culminating surprise came whenMansell said:

“This is Inspector Bonaparte, Harry. He wants to ask a few questions.”

“Concerning Raymond Gillen, Mr Carney,” Bony said smoothly. “We won’t waste time by going into what is general knowledge but keep to essentials.”

Carney stared, knew he stared. The easy-going, softly-spoken horse-breaker had undergone a remarkable metamorphosis, for he sat squarely, his eyes were deeply blue, and there was no trace of the previous reticence of the aboriginal part of him. The voice was precise and authoritative.

“Mr Carney. Did you ever have a serious disagreement with Raymond Gillen?”

“No. Never,” answered Carney, barely side-stepping the ‘sir’.

“What was your feeling towards Gillen?”

“Friendly enough. We got on all right. Camped in the same room. Most of us liked him. I know I did.”

“Despite the fact that you were both in love with the same girl?”

“That’s only partly true. Ray wasn’t in love with Joan. He thought he had a chance, that’s all.”

“You were in love with her, were you not?”

“Yes. I was, then.”

“You imply you are not in love with her now. Would you tell me what changed your feelings?”

“That had nothing to do with Gillen,”prevaricated Carney. “Gillen was a good type. Dare anything; try anything. He had a try for Joan, and it didn’t upset me because I thought he would never get her. I know what she is. Yes, I loved her and hoped she’d marry me. I knew that Gillen meant to buy her, and I knew that because Gillen told me, and showed me money enough to buy a dozen women. It was in his case… rolls and rolls of it.”

“Did he tell you where he obtained the money?”

“Spun a yarn about winning it in a lottery.”

“Do you know what happened to the money?”

“No.”

“You will remember that whenMacLennon was shown the locket belonging to Gillen, he became enraged and said that Gillen had left a letter in his suitcase which you had found. Was that true?”

“Yes,” replied Carney. “I’ll tell you what happened from the time Ray had been here about a month. We’d become good friends, and he knew I was keen to marry Joan. He asked me, and I told him straight. He asked what I thought of my chances, and I said they were good… until he came to the Lake. He said ‘Look, Harry. Don’t be a mug. You’ve got no money and that’s all she’s after. She’s a teasing bitch.’ ”

Carney’s mouth was grim, and his brown eyes were empty of the laughter Bony so often had seen.

“I knew what Ray said was right,” he went on. “And then he said if I gave away the idea of marrying Joan, he’d give me a hundred to get her out of my system. When I laughed at him about the hundred, he opened his case and told me to help myself. He said again he’d won it in a lottery, but I couldn’t believe that. But he did offer me a hundred to work off on Joan. I wouldn’t take it. But I thought a hell of a lot of Ray Gillen.

“Then one night Joan said she wanted to go for a walk. She told me that Gillen had a case full of notes, and that he must have pinched it, and she wasn’t being mixed up with hot money. She said she’d marry me if I stole it from Gillen, because then Gillen couldn’t do anything about it, as he stole it in the first place. That woke me up to her properly. I didn’t hate her exactly. I still loved her, or what I thought she could be. I still love her that way. I’m sorry if I can’t make you understand.”

“I do understand,” Bony said slowly. “Go on.”

“It turned out that Gillen got to work on her, offering her a thousand quid to clear out with him on his bike. She wouldn’t fall for it. So he raised the ante… just like he would. She said she didn’t believe his yarns, and so he took her to his room and opened his case for her to see for herself.

“D’youknowwhat, Bony? Joan planned to get all that money for free. She told her mother about it, and then the mother sooledMacLennon to steal it for her. Mac must have thought it over, and must have tried to open Gillen’s case, because Ray found marks on the locks.

“Four days after that, or four nights after, Ray went for his last swim. Or so it turned out. When he wasn’t on hand the next morning I looked at his case. It wasn’t locked. Instead of the money, there was a letter. And the letter read: ‘What you want isn’t here. It’s well planted, and the clue is inside the locket around my neck. Try for the locket if you have guts enough. Ray G.’

“I thought one of them had murdered Gillen, for the money. I don’t think so now, not after you opened the locket for everyone to see.”

“Did Gillen tell you he was going to plant the money?”

“No. Not a word.”

“What did you do with the letter?”

“I gave it to Joan for a birthday present,” Carney grimaced. “She didn’t even thank me.”

“Did Gillen write letters?”

“No. He told me his parents were dead.”

“Did he seem to be worried… just before the night he disappeared?”

“No. I’ve been trying to tell you what Gillen was, a chap who feared nothing, and no one. He never lost his temper.”

“He did fight Mac. Why?”

“Over what he said about Ma Fowler. But he didn’t lose his temper about it. Mac did, and got a hell of a thrashing. Gillen laughed all the time he was dealing it out.”

“Let us return to the suitcase. The rooms are small, and each contains two beds. You camped with Gillen in the same room. When on your bed could you see Gillen’s case under his?”

“At times. Depended on how far he pushed it under.”

“Quite so. When you could see the case, it was invariably locked?”

“The locks were in place and the catches were up. By looking at the case, I wouldn’t know if the key had been turned in the lock.”

“When did you first find the case unlocked?”

“That morning Gillen was missing. I sat up and found Ray wasn’t in his bed. I could see his suitcase under the bed. The ordinary catches weren’t in place, and the slides were open. In fact the lid wasn’t closed properly. That’s why I pulled the case out and looked for the money, and found the letter.”